Late last year, the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority floated its plans for sewage elimination in our rivers. But MassDEP rejected those plans in December, stating, “an approach that would result in a greater number of activations and/or volumes than occur at present would not appear to be consistent with the federal Clean Water Act or the Massachusetts Surface Water Quality Standards.” Conservation Law Foundation looked at MWRA’s plans and said, “MWRA’s current approach to CSOs violates both the letter and spirit of the law.”
But MWRA has not changed course.
Massachusetts Water Resources Authority is expected to say that eliminating sewage pollution will not improve water quality. Nonsense.
MWRA has $2.1 billion in expiring bonds. These are the bonds that were used to fund the original Boston Harbor projects. With this debt expiring, MWRA has the budget to issue new bonds to fund CSO projects without a shocking impact on our sewer bills.
Sewer Separation and Green Infrastructure is the Solution.
During intense rains, Cambridge discharges tens of millions of gallons of raw sewage into Alewife Brook through combined sewer pipes. Parts of the city still have an antiquated sewer system that combines rainwater and sewage into a single pipe. Cambridge’s old combined sewer system is a relic from the 1800s when open sewers were common.
Combined Sewer System Diagram Source: Jersey Waterworks
The solution to ending raw sewage discharges in the brook is to complete modernizing the city’s sewer system. This means separating the sewage from the stormwater, from a single combined pipe into two pipes. Sewage then goes to the Deer Island Sewage Treatment Plant every day of the year. A second pipe sends stormwater flows into wetlands to be naturally cleaned before entering Alewife Brook.
Sewer Separation in Cambridge is Feasible
Ending sewage pollution at Alewife Brook is necessary because of health impacts in such a densely populated and flood-prone area. Sewer separation in Cambridge is feasible and necessary to achieve an end to sewage pollution at Alewife Brook. Half of the sewer separation in the Alewife Brook watershed was accomplished by 2015.1 That sewer separation work also resulted in the 3.4 acre Alewife Stormwater Wetland to handle the separated stormwater. But the work was not completed, and Alewife sewage discharges continue to be in violation of a court order. This means that the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority is on the hook to pay for the lion’s share of sewer infrastructure work.2
There are 188 acres of combined sewers left that flow from Cambridge into Alewife Brook. Sewer separation also requires reducing stormwater surges (aka: attenuation) to prevent area flooding. The good news is there are 12 acres of public parkland for new wetlands to hold stormwater flows from sewer separation. In fact, the state’s 2003 Alewife Master Plan recommends using Department of Conservation & Recreation parkland for stormwater wetlands. The estimated cost of 188 acres of sewer separation is $100,000,000. The time to complete planning and construction is approximately 15 years or less.
188 Acres of Combined Sewer in Cambridge, Tributary to Alewife Brook
We created an interactive map with combined sewer pipes in orange and arrows showing sewage flows. 188 acres of sewer separation were identified that drain to Alewife Brook from Cambridge. Note: we did not include the Charles River watershed, nor areas in Somerville.
Map of remaining combined sewer pipes that drain to Alewife Brook in Cambridge shown in orange. Alewife Raw Sewage Outfalls are depicted as red dots.
Available Public Space for Stormwater Wetlands
DCR recommends wetlands projects in their 2003 Alewife Masterplan,3 to be sited next to Little River and Alewife Brook. These wetlands recommendations are on state parkland, shown below.
Section of Planning Map from DCR’s Alewife Masterplan shows recommendations for wetlands in yellow, green, and blue.
There are 12 acres of parkland next to Alewife Brook and Little River in DCR plans for wetlands. This is enough space for three more constructed stormwater wetlands. It is enough space to support complete sewer separation for Cambridge’s combined sewer pipes now flowing into to Alewife Brook. The areas for stormwater wetlands are shown below in purple. According to the Massachusetts Stormwater Handbook (2008, Vol. 1 and Vol. 2) this is adequate sizing for constructed wetlands to treat this volume of stormwater.
Screenshot of map, showing available public parkland to site constructed stormwater wetlands.
As a comparison, the Alewife Constructed Stormwater Wetland is 3.4 acres within state DCR land. It receives stormwater from 211 acres. This beloved Stormwater Wetland is a project that is included in the state’s 2003 Alewife Masterplan.
Slide from the City of Cambridge, presented to the Alewife Zoning Working Group.
$510,000 Per Acre Cost of Sewer Separation
According to MWRA’s Chief Operating Officer, the cost of sewer separation is $510,000 per acre.4 At Alewife Brook, the cost of completing 188 acres of sewer separation in Cambridge is $100,000,000.
In the next 10 years, MWRA will finish paying off about $2.1 billion in long-term bonds.5 Because this old debt is coming off the books, MWRA can issue around $2.1 billion in new bonds without a shock to water and sewer rates for households.
Time to Complete Sewer Separation: 15 Years
From MWRA’s CSO Control Plan Progress Update, March 2007.
Boston Water & Sewer Commission separated 355 acres of combined pipes in 9 years.6 This includes time to design and then construct. It’s reasonable to plan for the same amount of time in Cambridge for sewer separation. An additional 5 years should be added for planning and construction of stormwater wetlands. Therefore, sewer separation and Green Stormwater Infrastructure can be completed in 15 years.
Sewer Separation is the Answer
Sewer separation in Cambridge is feasible in terms of technical achievability, cost/affordability, and the ability to meet water‑quality and permit requirements within a reasonable timeframe. Cambridge has done it before in the Huron / Concord neighborhood which sends stormwater into the Alewife Stormwater Wetland.
A fifteen-year project with investment on the order of $100M is well within the capabilities of the MWRA. CSOs can be eliminated through sewer separation. Stormwater can be biologically cleaned by stormwater wetlands. Stormwater wetlands can also reduce flooding.
From the Second Stipulation of the Harbor Court Case. https://www.mwra.com/media/file/031506bhpqrpdf Page 3. “Upon completion of the long-term CSO control plan and with results that demonstrate performance parameters are as predicted, the stipulation makes the Authority responsible for only those CSO outfalls which it owns and operates.” ↩︎
MWRA’s August 2023 letter to EPA regarding its Update to the Financial Capability Analysis for variances. https://www.cambridgema.gov/-/media/Files/publicworksdepartment/combinedseweroverflows/Reports/cam_csoplanning_realtimecsopublicnotificationevaluationreport_final20250829.pdf Page 162. “The unit cost per acre has been updated using sewer separation construction costs provided by the Boston Water and Sewer Commission (BWSC) for recent construction contracts in South Boston and East Boston. Based on the average cost per acre from BWSC contracts, adding a 50% contingency given the significant uncertainty by which stormwater can be conveyed to the receiving waters, the average cost is estimated to be $510,000 per acre.” ↩︎
MWRA Annual Report November 2024, Secured Bond Debt Service chart, page 2: https://emma.msrb.org/P11811316-P11388424-P11828155.pdf ↩︎ Note: MWRA has a budget for the debt service on expiring bonds. That debt service budget can be used to pay for funding of sewer separation and Green Infrastructure. ↩︎
Hybrid meeting via Zoom orin-person at: Just A Start 430 Rindge Ave, Cambridge, MA 02140
Sewage elimination plans in Alewife Brook and in the Charles and Mystic rivers. MassDEP sent MWRA back to the drawing board. But MWRA has not changed direction.
What do you want to see in the new plans?
Presentations and Q&A from your friends at:
YOU CAN HELP. GET INVOLVED. BE HEARD. EAT FREE PIZZA.
Deer Island Wastewater Treatment Plant and digester domes peeking out from behind the clouds. Shot from a plane out of Logan, Thanksgiving 2025. Photo credit: Kristin Anderson
In the 1990s, households and businesses in Greater Boston paid for the Boston Harbor cleanup with sewer rate increases that enabled borrowing. Now those old long-term loans are finally being paid off, freeing up room in the MWRA’s budget so new projects can be financed without another shock to water and sewer rates.
Between 2024 and 2031, MWRA will finish paying off about $2.1 billion in long-term bonds.1 Because this old debt is coming off the books, MWRA can issue around $2.1 billion in new bonds without raising water and sewer rates for households and businesses. This is happening just in time to fund sewage pollution elimination projects for Alewife Brook and the Charles and Mystic rivers.
While it may appear less expensive to dump untreated waste into our waters, this is only so if the analysis excludes health impacts,2 damage to the environment, and the burden on the wider community. But MWRA is under regulatory and legal obligations. So financing the new sewage elimination plan, aka: the long term Combined Sewer Overflow control plan, is not optional. It is required.
MWRA can clean up the sewage in the Alewife, Mystic, and Charles — and do it without raising rates.
Wondering why the question mark? Read our recent letters to the MWRA Board of Directors to find out:
November 2025 Letter to MWRA Board regarding the updated sewage elimination plan. December 2025 Letter to MWRA Board regarding financing of the sewage elimination plan.
Amazing news. This week MassDEP told Massachusetts Water Resources Authority to halt its plans. Those plans would increase the amount of sewage at Alewife Brook, the Charles River, and the Mystic River. MassDEP said MWRA’s plans are not “consistent with the federal Clean Water Act or the Massachusetts Surface Water Quality Standards.” Thank you, MassDEP.
MWRA Must Finish the Job
Projects from the first Alewife Brook Sewage Control Plan were finished in 2015. The result was that 7 CSO outfalls were eliminated and Cambridge separated 283 acres of combined sewers. A beautiful 3.4-acre stormwater wetland was created to receive stormwater from separated sewer pipes. Half the work is now done.
But there is more work to do. Sewage continues to flood into public parkland, bike paths, roads, yards, and homes. The second half of the work must be done.
MWRA must fund the completion of the work. It must require that Cambridge and Somerville work to end Alewife Brook sewage pollution. The good work of the first Long Term Sewage Control Plan must not be abandoned. The cities and MWRA must follow the goals and methods of that plan and finish the job!
A Sensible Plan for “Virtual” Sewage Pollution Elimination
Here is Save the Alewife Brook’s sensible and affordable approach to the problem, achieving “Virtual” Sewage Pollution Elimination. Our plan follows the goals and methods of the first Long Term Sewage Control Plan. It ends sewage pollution in the brook, making it comparable to MWRA’s most expensive plan: a $1.25 billion 32-foot-wide tunnel, big enough to drive a truck through, meant to be constructed under Alewife Brook. Our plan is estimated to cost around $400 million. This includes dredging. It is a fraction of the cost of MWRA’s plan.
With a million households in the MWRA’s system, and 35% of the flows from non-residential customers, the estimated cost to fund this plan using MWRA bonds is $4.24 per quarterly household sewer bill.
$4.24 – that’s the cost of a cup of coffee and a donut.
This week, on 11/13/2025, the Somerville City Council voted unanimously to pass a CSO Funding Resolution. This decision sends a message to the State Delegation that MWRA must provide funding for the updated CSO Control Plan. The Resolution was sponsored by Councilor Ben Ewen-Campen and co-sponsored by Councilor-at-Large and Vice President Wilfred Mbah.
The message is clear. Massachusetts Water Resources Authority must provide financial support to Cambridge and Somerville. This funding is needed to finish the work started three decades ago in the first Long Term Sewage Control Plan, to end sewage pollution at Alewife Brook.
Councilor Ewen-Campen, Sponsor of the Resolution
Councilor Ewen-Campen stated, “We’re being asked to spend an impossible amount of money to burden rate payers, to do a project that is not good enough. So what is the solution? It is extremely straightforward: The MWRA needs to pay more. They need to get much more actively involved in funding this plan right now, the Alewife Brook plan.”
Councilor-at-Large and Vice President Mbah, Cosponsor of the Resolution
Councilor-at-Large and Vice President Mbah said, “MWRA has proposed a revision to the Water Quality Standard to avoid making required investments. A Water Quality Standard Downgrade would roll back decades of progress that has been made to clean up our rivers. It means more pollution and four times as much sewage by 2050 due to climate change. We cannot sit here and watch.”
Councilor Clingan
Councilor Clingan said, “People used to swim in the Mystic River over by the boathouse. I grew up in West Somerville. When I was a kid, it was cleaner. I used to fish at Alewife Brook… I’m happy to support this.”
Historical Precedent
The City Council’s request has historical precedent. Projects from the first Alewife Brook Long Term Sewage Control Plan were funded by MWRA through a Memorandum of Understanding and Financial Assistance Agreement. The costs that MWRA agreed to cover changed over time, going from $34.8 million in the year 2000,1 to $60 million in 2008,2 to $70.3 million in 2012,3 to $112 million in 2019.4 Significant sewer separation in Cambridge was completed because of MWRA’s funding. 7 CSO outfalls were closed and the Alewife Stormwater Wetlands was created in the first plan. That excellent work never would have happened without the MWRA agreeing to provide financial assistance. Now the MWRA needs to step up to help the cities finish the job to end sewage pollution at Alewife Brook.
Watch the video of the City Council discussion here:
On March 7, 2025, advocates from many watershed and community groups formed the Coalition to End Sewage Pollution. These organizations include the Mystic River Watershed Association, the Charles River Watershed Association, Alewife Study Group, Green Cambridge, Save the Alewife Brook, and others.
The Coalition works together represent over 100,000 people. We feel our concerns have not been heard by staff at the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority, Cambridge, and Somerville. In particular, there is deep disappointment that sewage project planners have not been transparent about the process used to evaluate sewage elimination alternatives. The project planners have not evaluated the elimination of CSO regulators. In the Recommended Alternatives, project planners have not seriously evaluated meaningful sewer separation and associated green stormwater infrastructure. Project planners have not achieved levels of CSO control that satisfy public health criteria, despite a state-issued Water Quality Variance that requires them to do so.
The Governor’s Biodiversity Conservation Goals for the Commonwealth Report, published in August 2025, specifically calls on the state–including, presumably, the MWRA and the EEA Secretary–to “significantly reduce or eliminate combined-sewer overflows (CSOs).” The current proposal does not come close to eliminating remaining CSOs in Boston rivers. Instead, it proposes dumping considerably more sewage into our beloved water bodies on an annual basis.
The Coalition to End Sewage Pollution has created the Shared Principles and Shared Goals document, available for download here. This community-based plan must guide the project planners in the selection of the Preferred Alternative CSO control plan that will be submitted at the end of this year.
Massachusetts Water Resources Authority is expected to say that eliminating sewage pollution will not improve water quality. Nonsense.
Our strategy is simple.
Register for the meeting now!
Login to the meeting tonight at 6 pm.
Make your voice heard, if the meeting presenters allow it.
Please use the chat feature during the meeting – if the presenters allow it. Raise your hand to speak during Q&A.
Tell a personal story if you have one. Explain why ending sewage pollution is important to you, if you have kids, live, walk, or bike along Alewife Brook.
Demand an End to Sewage Pollution by 2050.
Ask MWRA for a plan that includes: 1. Complete Sewer Separation by 2050. 2. Green Stormwater Infrastructure to reduce flooding and clean the water. 3. Underground Sewage Storage Tanks. 4. Most importantly: A 25-year level of control for the year 2050*
* A 25-year level of control is what engineers often refer to as “virtual” combined sewage elimination. It means that there are no sewage discharges, except in a really big storm that occurs roughly every 25 years. Today’s “25-year storm” has a 4% chance of occurring in any given year, statistically expected once every 25 years. That means around 6 inches of rain in 24-hours, according to the most current rainfall model (NOAA Atlas 14).
Ending Sewage Pollution at Alewife Brook means
MWRA MUST PAY ITS FAIR SHARE!
Please attend tonight. Thursday, September 25th at 6 PM via Zoom
Please. We are four years into planning. Please come to the meeting Thursday night at 6 pm to show your support.
Ending Sewage Pollution at Alewife Brook means
MWRA MUST PAY ITS FAIR SHARE!
Although the Boston Harbor Cleanup Court Case is now closed, the Court is still supervising the remedy. That remedy is the Long Term Sewage Control Plan. This is because Massachusetts Water Resources Authority has not fulfilled its obligation to the Court. At Alewife Brook, Somerville’s Davis Square / Tannery Brook sewage outfall is dumping an illegal volume of raw sewage. The amount of sewage dumped there violates the Boston Harbor Court Case. Additionally, Federal Clean Water Act law is being broken. Cambridge’s Alewife MBTA sewage outfall is also dumping an illegal volume of raw sewage. It also violates the requirements of the Boston Harbor Court Case.
The Legislature created the MWRA to upgrade the region’s deteriorating sewer system and to address non-compliance with federal environmental standards. Yet MWRA continues to use Alewife Brook as an open sewer.
We live in the Commonwealth, which means that Massachusetts values public welfare. The State should not shift the burden of the cost of its sewer infrastructure onto its most vulnerable Environmental Justice neighborhoods by dumping hazardous raw sewage into densely populated and flood-prone neighborhoods, public parkland, public roads & bike paths, and residents’ homes & yards.
MWRA can afford to pay.
MWRA has the financial ability to pay for projects to end sewage pollution at Alewife Brook. And in the Charles River, too. There is a funding mechanism in place for sewer infrastructure, through the rate payers. There are over a million households that use the MWRA’s sewer service. And 35% of the sewage flows are non-residential – think: businesses.
A 40-year tax-free bond that MWRA uses to fund projects would have a 5.5% interest rate. To fund a $100 million sewer bond with 65% allocated to residential flows, the wholesale cost per household would be around $4.05 annually.
Math: Residential share of the bond = $100,000,000 x .65 = $65,000,000. The annual payment for a 40-year bond at 5.5% interest = $4,050,822.32 per year. The per-household annual cost = $4,050,822.32 / 1,000,00 = $4.05 Note: Cost increases will vary from community to community.
Great news! At the urging of Chair Councillor Patty Nolan, the Health & Environment Committee of the Cambridge City Council voted unanimously to push forward Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) legislation. The new legislation will soon go to City Council for a final vote!
Thank you to the Health & Environment Committee’s Chair Patty Nolan, Councillors Wilson, Siddiqui, Azeem, and Sobrinho-Wheeler for pushing forward legislation to end sewage pollution. Thank you also to Vice Mayor McGovern and Councillor Zuzy for their participation and support.
Thank you to Emily Norton and Julie Wood from Charles River Watershed Association. Thank you to Patrick Herron from Mystic River Watershed Association.
Thank you especially to Cambridge’s excellent City Engineer Jim Wilcox, who shares his 15 years of deep knowledge of combined sewer projects in the city.
Here’s what the legislation will do, if passed by the City Council:
It asks the City Manager to…
Work with the newly formed Coalition to End Sewage Pollution.
Create a Combined Sewer Overflow Commission.
Provide a cost-benefit analysis of a 25-year level of CSO control.
Improve stormwater regulations.
Include green stormwater infrastructure.
Improve public outreach regarding sewer infrastructure planning.
Why is this important?
The Massachusetts Water Resources Authority has not taken seriously feedback from watershed advocates. Despite enormous public outcry, the MWRA refuses to include feedback from the public in their sewage pollution plans. The amount of sewage that is dumped into Alewife Brook is illegal and MWRA knows it. But MWRA wants to continue using Alewife Brook as an open sewer, despite having the financial ability to fix the problem.
The collaborative planning process between Cambridge, Somerville, and MWRA is ongoing. This local legislation is separate from that effort. It creates another avenue for Cambridge to create it’s own a path towards community health by ending sewage pollution.
What’s next?
1. MWRA, Cambridge, & Somerville will host their big public Sewage Pollution Planning Meeting on 9/25. This is the last public meeting that they will hold before submitting their sewage pollution plans to EPA and MassDEP.
Please register for the big public Sewage Pollution Meeting now. September 25, 2025 | 6 pm | on Zoom: Register here
2. We expect Cambridge City Council to deliberate on the newly proposed legislation. The vote from the Health & Environment Committee will happen as early as September 29th.
The Presentations.
You can watch the video of the Committee’s hearing here on Combined Sewer Overflows from September 9th, 2025.
The Committee listened to a presentation from City Engineer Jim Wilcox. Emily Norton and Julie Wood from the Charles River Watershed Association had an awesome presentation. Patrick Herron from Mystic River Watershed Association was amazing! Lastly, Kristin Anderson & Eppa Rixey from Save the Alewife Brook presented.
City Engineer Jim Wilcox said, “The crown jewel of the CAM 004 [CSO sewer separation project from twenty years ago] was the construction of the Alewife Wetland. This wetland was constructed in the Alewife Reservation as part of sewer separation work. We need to demonstrate that we’re not increasing flooding… the Alewife Wetland serves two purposes. One is it provides what’s called stormwater detention, which is control of flows [meaning reduction of flooding]… It also provides treatment of stormwater through the plants and soils. This is a four acre installation,… a $12 million component of the CAM 004 [Huron and Concord Ave area ] sewer separation project.”
The 3.4 acre Alewife Stormwater Wetland reduces flooding and improves storm water quality. Note: there are many more acres of state land available near Alewife Brook for more constructed Stormwater Wetlands. Photo credit: MWRA
Emily Norton, Executive Director of Charles River Watershed Association stated, “It is not legal to dump sewage in our rivers.”
Patrick Herron, Executive Director of the Mystic River Watershed Association said, “Imagine if you have just used the toilet and you live in a combined sewer area in Cambridge, you flush the toilet and whatever happened in that toilet arrives at Alewife Brook in the condition that it left. It’s not treated…. There are real consequences to this… We would support one of two outcomes: complete sewer separation OR a 25-year level of control.”
Eppa Rixey, Steering Committee Member from Save the Alewife Brook said, “We don’t see Cambridge committing to sewer separation in the Long Term Sewage Control Planning process.” Cambridge needs to include sewer separation in the Long Term Sewage Control Plan.
The Roundtable Discussion
Chair of Health & Environment Committee Councillor Patty Nolan said, “It’s a public health threat, in addition to a calamity and an economic disaster when that flooding occurs… It’s an existential threat that affects our lives across so many different domains. We need to keep that in mind as we think about ways to do this… How can we not address this when this is something critical to our future and livability as a city?We’re Cambridge. We can solve this. And if we can’t, then who can? We look forward to hopefully having the Coalition work together with both the Council and the City Staff as we move forward, understanding this will supplement the work that’s being done.”
Slowness of the Project Progress
With the Long Term Sewage Planning process now in its fourth year, Councillors at the meeting expressed concerns. They believe the City needs to move faster to end sewage pollution.
Cost Concerns were raised
Vice Mayor McGovern said, “What are we doing at the State level to push our State Representatives and State Senators to figure out what they can do, to figure out how to get more money?”
Councillor Cathie Zusy asked, “Will we [Cambridge] be paying the $30 million [for the CSO tank at Bellis Circle / Sherman Street] or will MWRA be paying for it?”
Cambridge’s City Engineer Jim Wilcox replied, “that is part of the cost-sharing discussion with MWRA.”
Charles River Watershed Association’s Executive Director Emily Norton said, “I respect that MWRA tries to keep rates low. But how much do we value clean water? How much do we value not having toilet paper and tampon applicators going into our basements? How much do we value being able to swim in the Charles River? Our Cut the Crap campaign is also directed at MWRA. People want to see this. Let’s have a conversation about how we pay for it. There are creative ways to raise funds.”
Councillor Patty Nolan said, “Cambridge has been spending $30 to $50 million each year on sewer infrastructure and stormwater control.”
Neighborhood construction concerns came up.
Councillor Azeem said, “The neighbors feel that [sewage pollution] is a negative impact already. So maybe the neighborhood would be willing to put up with disruption in the short run, if it meant that [sewage pollution] would become less of a problem in the future.”
Cambridge City Engineer Jim Wilcox said, “When we do these sewer separation projects, it’s not just doing the sewer separation work. We also have to look at the condition of the other utilities that are in the street, particularly water utilities, gas utilities. So it’s not just sewer separation work, it’s also other work that needs to be done at the same time.”
Councillor Wilson said, “That health conditions have developed from not handling this sooner is a concern to me… In terms of timeline, where is the level of urgency when working with our capital partners [MWRA & Somerville]?”
Vice Mayor McGovern said, “I know the concerns around doing too much construction and too much upheaval in neighborhoods. And I know construction is never a pleasant thing. But it’s necessary. And I’m glad that we’re a city that is continuing to invest in infrastructure improvements. I, too, want to be on record saying, how can we move more quickly?”
Thank you to all of the members of Save the Alewife Brook who participated by providing written and spoken comments for the Health & Environment Committee meeting:
Suzanne Egean Beverly, Ann Stewart, Gwen Speeth, Heather Hoffman, John Tortelli, Ann McDonald, Rob Moir from The Ocean River Institute, Susan Callanan, Christopher Logan, Eric Grunebaum, Marina Goreau Atlas, Lois Josimovich, Lori Stokes, Melanie Abrams, Reva Stein, katherine dander, MARCIA CIRO, Peggy Lynch, Meredith Olsen, Elizabeth Thomason, Silvia Dominguez, Martha cleveland, Carlee Blamphin, Amy Cohen, Patty Hnatiuk, Naomi Dworkin, Mark Paglierani, SUSAN GOULD, Janine Hart-Hueber, Alida Castillo, Darci Hanna, John Tortelli, Rob Vandenabeele, Trudi Goodman, Carolyn A White, Kathryn Goldenoak, Richard Rabin, Elaine Lyte, Elizabeth Jochnick, Anna Cavallo, Holly Pearson, Ilana Blatt-Eisengart, Sue Gill, Liana Laughlin, Resa Blatman, McNamara Buck, Andrea Landman, Lois Grossman, Marcia Ciro, Ellen Mass, Nate Mendes, Joy Hackel, Eric Mooney, Candace Esslinger, Sahba Salarian, Michelle Gulen, Elizabeth Merrick, Jordan Weinstein, Elaine Campbell, Kristin Anderson, Michael Behizadeh, Meryl Becker
The Health and Environment Committee of the Cambridge City Council will meet on Tuesday afternoon, September 9th. They will discuss ways to improve the city’s Sewage Pollution Control Plans. For Alewife Brook, a meaningful plan means a 25-year level of control* for Cambridge’s Combined Sewer Overflows (CSOs). Cambridge’s CSOs dump the most raw sewage into Alewife Brook during rain storms.
You can help! Please send a written comment by email or come to the meeting in person or via streaming.
Create your email to City Council here:
Tell the Council your personal story. Explain why ending sewage pollution is important to you. Ask the Council for action to End to Sewage Pollution by 2050. Ask them for a plan that includes a combination of:
Complete Sewer Separation by 2050.
Green Stormwater Infrastructure.
Underground Combined Sewage Storage Tanks.
Engineera 25-year level of control for the year 2050*
* A 25-year level of control is what engineers often refer to as “virtual” combined sewage elimination. It means that there are no sewage discharges, except in a really big storm that occurs roughly every 25 years. Today’s “25-year storm” has a 4% chance of occurring in any given year, statistically expected once every 25 years. That means around 6 inches of rain in 24-hours, according to the most current rainfall model (NOAA Atlas 14).
Anew report was published by the Commonwealth last week, on 08/21/2025. It calls for an End to Sewage Pollution, through elimination of combined sewer overflows (CSOs) and sanitary sewer overflows (SSOs). The new report calls for sewer separation, treatment plant upgrades, and green stormwater infrastructure.
Governor Healey signed Executive Order No. 618, which called for nation-leading biodiversity goals. To meet this charge, the Commonwealth published a 25-year plan this week. The report calls for elimination of Combined Sewer Overflows (CSOs).
Goal #1: Protect
Protect people and wildlife from pollution. Eliminate CSOs, SSOs, and stormwater runoff to protect public health through:
Increase investment. Ensure waters are swimmable and fishable. Ensure adequate streamflow for fish and wildlife. Encourage greywater recycling in new construction.
Goal #2: Restore
Restore fish passage habitats to good health by 2050. Nature-based solutions including Green Stormwater Infrastructure have immediate benefits to climate resilience. Reestablish river herring (Alewives) and other migratory fish to their historic ranges. Environmental health is community health.
Goal #3: Sustain
Restore habitats and water quality through innovative and dedicated funding mechanisms. Increase access to nature on public land with a focus on Environmental Justice communities.
Goal #4: Connect
Nature in the Neighborhoods: support community-led efforts and ensure that all people have a connection to nature. Ensure equitable access to nature.
Governor Healey is calling on Massachusetts Water Resources Authority, Cambridge and Somerville to end Combined Sewer Overflows.
Graphic from the State’s Biodiversity Report, page 20.
Six untreated CSO outfalls are at Alewife Brook, in the Commonwealth’s most densely populated urban area with persistent sewage flooding. The sewage flooding causes severe digestive illness in Environmental Justice communities.
August 8th, 2023: Area residents jogged and pushed baby strollers through sewage floodwater on the Alewife Greenway. Photo by David Stoff.
Herring photo from the State’s Biodiversity Report, page 20
The report calls for commitment to investments over the next five years, and with achievable goals by 2050.
Thank you to Governor Maura Healey & Lieutenant Governor Kim Driscoll
Please send an email to the State House to End Sewage Pollution.
Do you live near Alewife Brook? Do you use the Alewife Greenway Path or the Alewife Brook Reservation state park? Do you live, work, commute, or play near any of the other 35 Combined Sewer Outfalls in the MWRA’s system that discharge untreated sewage into the environment?
Please ask legislators to report favorably on House Bill 1031 and Senate Bill 608. Your personal stories are the best testimony. You can add your local legislators at the State House to the email. The deadline for comments is July 1st, 2025. So please do this today.
House Bill 1031 and Senate Bill 608 are identical. This law would require all CSOs in the MWRA’s sewer service area to end the dumping of untreated sewage during storms as large as a 25-year event, by 2035 at the latest. That is the effective elimination of CSOs, also referred to as “virtual CSO elimination.”
Save the Alewife Brook Goes to the State House!
David Stoff and Gene Benson are all smiles at the State House. Stoff’s Poop Emoji costume was on loan from the Charles River Watershed Association.
Testimony at the State House hearing on 06/17/2025.
Save the Alewife Brook’s Eugene Benson, Kristin Anderson, and Paige Gromfin provide testimony at the State House hearing.
Somerville’s Michael Lonetto provides testimony at the State House hearing.
Save the Alewife Brook’s David Stoff provides testimony at the State House hearing.
Mashpee Wampanoag Hartman Deetz testifies at the State House hearing.
Mystic River Watershed Association’s Patrick Herron and Charles River Watershed Association’s Emily Norton provide testimony at the State House hearing.
Why is this legislation necessary?
Improvements as a result of the Boston Harbor Cleanup have stalled. Climate change threatens to make sewage pollution four times worse by 2050. We have seen that the sewage polluters are planning to do the bare minimum. The bare minimum would allow untreated sewage to continue to be dumped into Alewife Brook in rainstorms. The state must step in to require ending sewage pollution in the Greater Boston area.
What does this legislation do?
House Bill H.1031 and the identical Senate Bill S.608 address the sewage pollution crisis in the Greater Boston area. It gives the MWRA and the cities of Cambridge, Somerville, Boston, and Chelsea 10 years to end untreated sewage pollution. The polluters can either install CSO treatment facilities or engineer solutions to eliminate sewage dumping in up to a 25-year storm. This is what MWRA calls a “25-year level of control.” The MWRA has done it before, in South Boston, so it is doable.
What is a “25-year storm?”
Today’s “25-year storm” has a 4% chance of occurring in any given year, statistically expected once every 25 years. That means around 6 inches of rain in 24-hours, according to NOAA Atlas 14 data.
This legislation would require a solution where there is no sewage pollution in up to a storm that is twice as big at the 05/22/2025 nor’easter, OR construction of a CSO treatment facility to treat the sewage.
What is a CSO treatment facility?
A CSO treatment facility treats combined sewer overflows during storm events. It reduces pathogens with partial treatment (chlorination and then dechlorination), removes some solids, and somewhat improves water quality. It is not nearly as comprehensive as the treatment at the Deer Island treatment plant. But it is better than no treatment.
There are currently four CSO treatment facilities in the MWRA’s sewer system. Cambridge has a CSO treatment facility near Magazine Beach. The newest is MWRA’s Union Park CSO treatment facility, constructed in 2007 at a cost of $55 million. Union Park includes a 2.2 MG underground detention tank, with a public park above the tank.
Great news! On 06/16/2025, the Cambridge City Council advanced a vision of the Alewife MBTA Station redevelopment. That vision includes as much Green Stormwater Infrastructure as possible and underground sewage pollution storage. The goal is to ensure the redevelopment plays a central role in significantly decreasing raw sewage discharges into Alewife Brook. The Policy Order and its message to the Governor, the MBTA, and other state agencies and authorities is supported by key local and regional groups: Mystic River Watershed Association, Green Cambridge, Alewife Study Group, Cambridge Sewage Overflow Working Group, and Save the Alewife Brook.
What does it mean?
Cambridge urges Governor Maura Healey and the MBTA to immediately amend the Request for Proposals (RFP) for the redevelopment of the Alewife T Complex. The Council calls for collaboration between the Commonwealth, the city, MWRA, MBTA, DCR, DPH, and the developer.
The City Manager is asked to work to ensure that any future zoning relief for the development aligns with city and council goals. Those goals include addressing CSOs, providing housing, and prioritizing a commuter rail stop.
What happens next?
The Cambridge City Clerk will write to the Governor, MBTA, MWRA, DCR, DPH, and Cambridge’s State House delegation, to recommend that the redevelopment includes as much green stormwater infrastructure as possible and a major underground storage tank to eliminate sewage pollution.
Cambridge students at the Fayerweather Street School and at the Rindge Avenue Upper Campus School have been studying Combined Sewer Overflows. Thanks to the kids for doing their homework and speaking up for the environment and public health.
Cambridge students Sean Mullan, Dylan Fox, and Julian Shabry-Lichter urge a doubling of the size of the Alewife Stormwater Wetlands.
Will Hausman of Belmont speaks out against sewage on the Alewife Path.
Arlington’s Saylor family speaks out about the cancer cluster near Alewife Brook.
Thanks to the Cambridge Sewer Overflow Working Group for their amazing vision and for working tirelessly on this policy order.
Eric Grunebaum, Cambridge Sewer Overflow Working Group, urges Green Stormwater Infrastructure to connect remaining green and blue spaces of the Great Swamp.
Ann McDonald of Save the Alewife Brook & Cambridge Sewer Overflow Working Group lives next to Alewife Brook near two CSOs.
Gwen Speeth of North Cambridge explains explains why including sewage mitigation at Alewife T rebuild is a WIN-WIN-WIN-WIN!
Thank you to over 40 Cambridge, Arlington, Somerville, and Belmont residents who spoke out in unanimous support:
Eppa Rixey, Michael Lonetto, Gwen Speeth, Niels Seidler Kahn, Ella Hausman, Will Hausman, Julia Shabry-Lichter, Mackey Buck, Michael Rome, Ann McDonald, Ann Tennis, Dylan Fox, Kristin Anderson, Michael Behizadeh, David White, Russell Bartash, Nonnie Valentine, Eric Grunebaum, Laura Saylor, Isaac Saylor, Ellie Saylor, Lewis Weitzman, Beth Melofchik, Cynthia Hibbard, Suzanna Schell, Marina Atlas, Rebecca Gatti, Heather Hoffman, Jessica Kinner, Eppa Rixey, Daniel Heller, Kari Sizemore, Lisa Birk, Lucy W, Melanie Abrams, Peter Kroon, Ruth Ryals, James Cornie, Sarah Block, Suzanna Schell, Linda Moussouris, Alida Castillo
Thank you to the Mystic River Watershed Association, Green Cambridge, Alewife Study Group, Councilor Patty Nolan, and Cambridge DPW for meeting to discuss the Policy Order.
House Bill 1046 ~ An Act to Eliminate Combined Sewer Overflows in Massachusetts Waterways
Sponsors of An Act Relative to Combined Sewer Overflows
Come to the hearing, either in person or online. When it’s your turn to speak, please ask the committee to issue a favorable report on H.1031.
You will have three minutes to speak. If you have a personal story, those are most compelling. Let the committee know that you support House Bill 1031, as well as Senate Bill 608 and House Bill 1046.
Tell the Committee we need the state to end the dumping of sewage pollution.
House Bill H.1031 and the identical Senate Bill S.608 are realistic, outcome-oriented, and consistent with current technologies and procedures.
The key language is: “Beginning on January 1, 2035 in MWRA service areas there shall be no untreated Combined Sewer Overflow in any 25-year 24-hour storm event or a smaller storm event.”
The 25-year standard has already been achieved at outfalls on the Boston Harbor such as Fort Point Channel. Only a few outfalls violate this standard on the Charles and Mystic Rivers and the Alewife Brook.
Recognizing that some CSOs may need to discharge in large storms to prevent sewer backups for some time, this legislation requires that, in 10 years (2035), all CSOs in the MWRA sewer service area either:
1. Have the treatment across the system now provided at only five CSOs;
or
2. CSOs only activate during 25+year storms, and not during smaller storms (five CSOs along the beaches in Dorchester Bay already have 25-year level of control)
Sponsors of An Act to Eliminate Combined Sewer Overflows in Massachusetts Waterways
House Bill H.1046 is a little different. It calls for all CSO discharges in a Massachusetts waterway to be eliminated by December 31, 2050.
5:30 pm Monday, June 9 at City Hall in Central Square and via Zoom
Cambridge supporters, please be there. Please stand up and speak out.
If you live outside of Cambridge, but have experience with raw sewage flooding, the stench in the park, or boating downstream in Mystic River, please let the good folks on Cambridge City Council know what it’s like.
You will only get 1 or 2 minutes to comment during Public Comment Period. Please prepare your statement in advance.
This Policy Order is a request to the Governor and MBTA. Please be kind when you ask the Councilors to vote in support.
What is the “Ending Alewife Sewage” Policy Order #3 about?
The Policy Order is about the redevelopment of the Alewife MBTA Station parking garage. The Alewife MBTA station demolition and reconstruction is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to address problems with transit, regional sewer infrastructure, and affordable housing.
The Ending Alewife Sewage Policy Order asks that the MBTA’s Request for Proposals from developers (RFP) be rewritten to ensure that it includes planning and space for major upgrades to the existing sewer infrastructure.
The RFP must include space for Cambridge and Massachusetts Water Resources Authority to upgrade existing gray sewer infrastructure, including an underground sewage storage tank with the goal of eliminating sewage pollution in our brook. And there must be space for Green Stormwater Infrastructure, including at least 3 acres for a stormwater wetlands.
The Policy Order asks for collaboration between the MBTA, MWRA, DCR, DPH, the City of Cambridge, Green Cambridge (an abutting landowner), and local residents and other stakeholders.
Note: The Policy Order does not ask for money for this work from the MBTA or from the private developer – it asks for needed space and collaboration of the state authorities and cities to End Alewife Sewage Pollution.
Why do we need space for Gray Infrastructure?
Significant gray sewer infrastructure already exists at the MBTA Alewife site. Principally that’s “CAM401A”, the huge pipe next to the garage carrying 2/3rds of the sewage pollution that is dumped into the brook. There is also an ancient pipe under the garage. The infrastructure desperately needs to be upgraded by the city and by MWRA.
The Alewife Brook Branch Sewer, built in 1896 (not a typo!), runs under the MBTA parking garage. Cambridge’s Alewife MBTA combined sewer outfall, aka CAM401A, is not in compliance with the Boston Harbor Court Case.
A new underground sewage tank at Alewife could collect untreated sewage during rain storms and detain it until after the storm has passed. Then the sewage could be pumped to Deer Island for treatment.
Underground Tank in Central Square
Why do we need space for Green Stormwater Infrastructure (GSI)?
Cambridge has a lot of sewer separation work to do that is tributary to Alewife Brook. Sewer separation removes stormwater from the sewer pipes. After the stormwater is removed from the pipes, it has to go somewhere. That somewhere is a Stormwater Wetland, for cleaning and attenuation. Without a new Stormwater Wetland here, there’s no place to send the separated water.
GSI here would reconnect the separated areas of wetland and green spaces: the Alewife stormwater wetland, Yates Pond, and Jerry’s Pond.
Meeting Talking Points
Space and Collaboration. The Policy Order asks for space and collaboration, for the city to work with MWRA and other agencies and groups, so they are able to do the work needed there to End Alewife Sewage Pollution. It does NOT ask for money from the MBTA or from their private developer but it requires that this collaboration be integrated into the project before this precious and perfectly located public land is handed to a private developer.
Cambridge’s Alewife MBTA Sewage Outfall is not in compliance. In 2023, Cambridge’s Alewife MBTA combined sewage outfall (CAM401A) was responsible for 70% of the sewage pollution in Alewife Brook. It is not in compliance with the Boston Harbor Court Case.
Sewage Flooding. The area is historically called, “The Great Swamp.” It floods regularly, sending untreated sewage flood water into the parks, yards, and homes of area residents.
Community Health. 100% of the Alewife sewage pollution is untreated. Exposure to untreated sewage results in sickness.
The area is densely populated. 5000 people currently live in the Alewife’s 100-year floodplain.
Environmental Justice. Unhoused people have built multiple encampments in the Alewife Reservation. Camps get flooded out with sewage. Additionally, the state designates neighborhoods along the Alewife Brook as Environmental Justice blocks.
An incredible opportunity! Imagine the Alewife Stormwater Wetlands almost doubling in size, surrounded by beautiful new affordable housing where that horrible parking garage sits now. With connecting paths and trees. Swoon!
Please attend the Cambridge City Council meeting in person or via Zoom at 5:30 pm on Monday, June 9, at City Hall in Central Square. Speak up for Alewife Brook! Since the sewage that flows into Alewife Brook mostly comes from Cambridge toilets, feel free to speak-up, regardless of which town you live in!
Please sign up now for the meeting as a member of Save the Alewife Brook.
The policy order is here. It asks the MBTA to immediately amend its Alewife garage redevelopment RFP to include ending sewage releases into Alewife Brook as a priority, not as an afterthought.
Ending sewage pollution requires land and the 10-13 acres of the Alewife garage – state-owned land – are perfectly situated for green and gray infrastructure. The Policy Order asks for 3-acres of wetlands (green infrastructure) to hold and clean stormwater, as well as concrete tanks (gray infrastructure) to hold sewage that will later be released when there is sewer capacity to send it to Deer Island for treatment.
3-acres could be another stormwater wetland almost the size of the existing Alewife Wetland which was built to clean stormwater from the Huron/Concord neighborhood while also providing relief from heat, improved air quality, more habitat and better health and well-being.
This pivotal policy order would help shape the future of Alewife Brook and the health of our neighborhoods. Sponsored by Councillors Zusy, Siddiqui, Vice Mayor McGovern, and Councillor Wilson, this order urges Governor Maura Healey, the MBTA Board of Directors, and MBTA General Manager Philip Eng to take decisive action as the huge Alewife Garage site undergoes demolition and redevelopment.
Each year, tens of millions of gallons of untreated raw sewage is dumped into Alewife Brook and about 2/3rds of it flows right through MBTA land next to the garage. In 2023, 26 million gallons of raw sewage discharged into the brook — the highest volume in the entire Greater Boston area. The Alewife Greenway Path, a vital corridor for residents, is directly impacted, with raw sewage sometimes flooding into yards, homes, parks, and onto public walkways used by children, runners, and families.
The Policy Order recognizes the rare opportunity presented by the planned demolition and redevelopment of the MBTA Alewife Garage. This 10-13-acre site includes the two outfall pipes responsible for most of the area’s sewage discharges, making it the ideal location for green stormwater infrastructure and a major underground storage tank. These improvements would reduce sewage overflows, expand open space, improve air quality, and protect public health as a major new housing development is also anticipated at the garage site.
You can sign up ahead of time to comment via this form. The Agenda Item is “Ending Alewife Sewage, Policy Order #3.”
If you can’t make it to the meeting or by Zoom, it’s still worth dashing off a note to the Council before 5:30 at council@cambridgema.gov and CC the clerk at cityclerk@cambridgema.gov
Over 60 volunteers from Somerville, Cambridge, Arlington, and Boston showed up in the pouring rain on Earth Day 2025 for Save the Alewife Brook’s DCR Path Earth Day cleanup & Alewife MBTA Sewage Outfall tour. Then another dozen volunteers arrived to help after the rain stopped. It’s unbelievable how many people care so deeply about this Brook!
Using mad muscle and a hook on a rope, we pulled a shopping cart, bike, and bike trailer from the Minuteman bike path bridge.
Photo by Ann McDonald.
Amazingly, we also found a large fresh water mussel shell near the Brook.
Beth Melofchik & David Stoff discuss the find of a mussel shell. Photo by Charles Teague.
“Alewife Floaters are a species of freshwater mussel that as adults live embedded in the sand and mud, but as larvae have evolved an ingenious way to reach new areas of a river system: They hitch a ride in the gills of the Alewife herring (as well as related fish, such as the blue-back herring and the American shad). When its host fish were so abundant that they were a pillar of Massachusetts tribal sustenance, and fertilized soil for the early European colonists, the mussel must have been abundant, too. What does it do for a body of water to have such a species in it? Consider this: A single mussel can filter 15 to 20 gallons of water a day, capturing and cycling nutrients, structuring the stream bed as a habitat and forming the basis of a food web for other species. Mussel beds can revitalize an urban river.
Even now, when Alewife Brook is mostly bereft of its fish because of its quality, sometimes you see a Floater shell or two. Maybe you, like me for the longest time, assumed they were archaeological, or someone’s lunch dumped in the river. But no: They are evidence that despite the pollution, the shallowness, the channelization, the gunk that’s accumulated – some fish do make it through. And some Alewife Floaters hitch a ride. Nature is that powerfully resilient, that ready to come back. To provide ecosystem services, once we know to value them.”
Big thanks to the volunteers who came out in the rain for our DCR Park Serve Alewife Earth Day Cleanup:
Thank you,Arlington Select Board Member Diane Mahon!
Thanks also to: John Anderson, Renee Kelley, George Laite, Logan B, Melissa Mahoney, Jean Baptiste Brun, Paul Lipsky, Ben Flaumenhaft, Caroline Sherrard, Charles Teague, Anna Currin, Jennifer Ingram, Ulli and Steve Rapp, Alex Simmons, Michael Everman, David Mussina, Yawen Timurdogan, Maureen Urban, Daniel Place, Phillip Veatch, Han Chen, Shuo Cheng, Jean-Marc Guettier, Nathaly Herrel, Diandra Chamberlain, Andy Forbes, Rachel Zoll, Sunyoung Park, John Williams, Ken Domino, Jess Strzempko, Lindsey Leigh, Marian Miller, Amro Elbakri, Henry Kilgore, Eric Grunebaum, Alexa Wadsworth, Jimmy Johnson, John Tortelli, Suzanne Chiarito, Angelique Bradford, Tom Galow, Nancy Frost, Joel Snider, Sam Murphy, Maureen & Bazil Jackson, Bob Tosi Jr, Jennifer O’Brien Chang, Olivia O’Donnell, Michael Lonetto, Justin Kunimune, Gwen Speeth, Chris Logan, Sabrina Morais, Colleen Fitzgerald, David Bel, Dakota Tyson, Reva Stein, Cody Canning, Jen Thompson, Erica Tangney, Joann Keesey, Eleanor Wolf, Sparsh Chaudhri, Susan and Jeff Denham, Sam Pierce, Pauline Tran, Thais Pinheiro, Phil McHenry, Laurianne McHenry, Ivy Xu, Sonya Green, Bivianne Velásquez, Melissa McWhinney, Adam Lanman, Lauren Coffin, Susann Wilkinson, Gerri Strickler, Sydney Ross, Robin Shaw, Danny Balel, Elaine Campbell, Angela Poiré, Ann McDonald, Kristin Anderson, Eppa Rixey, David Stoff, Linea Rowe, John Green, Phil Mahoney, Mark Foster, Christine Metzler, Beth Melofchik, Gilbert Martin, Janine Hart-Hueber
Volunteers gather in the rain at Bicentennial Park. Photo by Jimmy Johnson.
Join us on Saturday morning, April 26th, for an Earth Day Alewife Greenway Path Clean-Up and CSO Tour. We will gather trash along the path next to the brook. While we’re there, we’ll provide a tour of the Combined Sewer Outfalls and the Concrete Sewage Death Channel.
We’ll discuss what we’re doing together, to make Alewife Brook fishable, boatable, and safe, for the enjoyment of all.
Free Save the Alewife Brook t-shirts and boat bags for folks who sign up for the clean-up, while supplies last.
Bring gloves, water, & garbage picker, if you have one. We’ll provide bags.
Meet at Bicentennial Park at Mass Ave and Boulevard Road at 10:00 am on Saturday, April 26th
Free T-shirts & boat bags for volunteers to help spread the word!
Participants take individual responsibility for their own safety, avoiding touching any suspect items.
We have people power! We will use that power for ending sewage pollution in our rivers. Please join Thursday night’s meeting and be prepared to make a statement. Feel free to introduce yourself as a member of Save the Alewife Brook. Explain in personal terms why you care about the Brook. You are welcome to use any of the points mentioned below. Or create your own!
Talking Points.
1. Public Health and Safety Concerns
The Alewife Brook should be safe for boating and fishing year-round. But it is severely polluted by hazardous untreated sewage and industrial waste.
Sewage pollution poses a serious health hazard to the 5,000 residents living in the Alewife Brook’s 100-year floodplain. There are documented cases of severe gastrointestinal illness after forced exposure to contaminated floodwaters. Sewage pollution is typically dumped into Alewife Brook many times every year.
Flooding regularly spreads hazardous sewage into parks, yards, and homes, endangering public health and safety.
2. Environmental Justice and Equity
Many affected neighborhoods are Environmental Justice communities, making this an issue of equity as well as public health. Sewage pollution has a disproportionate impact on already vulnerable populations.
Unhoused individuals living near Combined Sewer Outfalls are particularly vulnerable to the health risks posed by untreated sewage pollution.
3. Recreational and Ecological Impact
Our waterbodies must allow for healthy, resilient ecologies that maintain the biodiversity of fish, birds, reptiles, mammals, and other wildlife. The rivers shall flow, be free from sewage, and perform essential ecosystem functions.
Alewife Brook runs through historic public parkland. It features a popular multi-use path. However, its water is unsafe for recreational use due to pollution.
Persistent sewage odors from the brook and the adjacent sewer lines pose a serious problem. This is a detriment to public use of the historic state parkland.
Cambridge, Somerville, Belmont, and Arlington should improve stormwater that flows to Alewife Brook. This can be achieved with Green Stormwater Infrastructure (GSI). GSI naturally filters and manages runoff. Alternatively, the stormwater can be treated. This will help make Alewife Brook a “Class B waterbody”, suitable for boating and improving the habitat for fish, shellfish, and other aquatic life.
The concrete channel in Alewife Brook limits biodiversity and prevents ecological restoration efforts. Removing it could improve water quality, increase biodiversity, and provide additional flood storage.
Alewife Brook flows into the Mystic River, just upstream of the Paddle Boston canoe and kayak rental site, impacting water quality and creating health hazards in an area frequented by boaters of all ages.
4. Infrastructure Failures
Somerville’s Tannery Brook and Cambridge’s Alewife MBTA CSO outfalls (SOM 001A & CAM 401A) are not compliant with the Boston Harbor Cleanup Court Case.
The worst CSO outfall (CAM401A) is located near the Alewife MBTA station, discharging hazardous pollution through MBTA property. A large detention tank should be installed there to manage sewage from future storms.
The MWRA’s sewer system is unable to handle flows in today’s storms. The Alewife Brook Branch Sewer was built in 1896 and still operates today. The Alewife Brook Pump Station becomes overwhelmed during some storms. Deer Island can often not handle flows during many storm events. The MWRA relies on the CSO outfalls to provide hydraulic relief and additional capacity to their undersized regional sewer system. The MWRA must upgrade their regional sewer system.
5. Climate Change Exacerbation
Climate change is expected to worsen the problem. Heavier and more frequent rainstorms will increase sewage pollution volumes. These volumes could rise by two to four times by 2050. Plans to eliminate CSOs must continue to address anticipated future climate conditions.
Sewage pollution must be considered alongside other environmental hazards, including flooding. Solutions must not exacerbate other problems.
6. Actionable Solutions
Immediate measures should include fixing odor issues (“the stink”) to make parklands enjoyable for all residents.
All CSO outfalls must screen for floatables like toilet paper and other disgusting debris.
The Massachusetts Water Resources Authority should collaborate with the Army Corps of Engineers. They should dredge sediment from the brook’s concrete channel. This will improve water quality and navigability.
7. Accountability and Transparency
Residents deserve on-site, real-time notification while hazardous sewage is being dumped in the brook and for 48 hours afterward.
MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville must comply with existing environmental regulations.
8. In the Updated Long Term CSO Control Plan
Planners must develop aggressive strategies for the virtual elimination of sewage pollution to adapt to future storms.
Cambridge must prioritize sewer separation and implement Green Stormwater Infrastructure in its sewage pollution elimination plan.
Somerville should include a large CSO detention tank at Dilboy Field, as well as prioritizing sewer separation and implementation of Green Stormwater Infrastructure in the Tannery Brook sewershed.
The Massachusetts Water Resources Authority (MWRA) should develop a plan that includes cost for an Alewife CSO treatment facility.
A child rides her bike through untreated sewage flood water from Alewife Brook in 2023. Photo by Ann McDonald
Unable to attend the Listening Session Zoom meeting on April 3rd? Please provide a written comment to mgomez@somervillema.gov:
In a significant step towards addressing Somerville’s untreated sewage pollution, the Somerville City Council hosted Save the Alewife Brook to learn about long-time neglect at Somerville’s Tannery Brook CSO and the serious community health impacts of untreated sewage and flooding.
Council President Neufeld Introduces Tannery Brook CSO Order
On 3/13/2025, Council President Neufeld & Councilor Ewen-Campen sponsored an order for the Tannery Brook CSO outfall and invited us to present.
Councilor Ewen-Campen Calls for a Deeper Understanding
Councilor Ewen-Campen stated, “When there’s a big storm, sewage goes into the rivers, the Mystic, the Charles, the Alewife Brook. I hope that what everyone is able to do tonight, when we hear from this wonderful community group, is to get a deeper understanding of what that means. A lot of attention in our infrastructure work has gone into the Charles and the Mystic and the Alewife has been overlooked.“
A Unanimous Vote
The Council members voted unanimously in support of an order to have the Director of Infrastructure and Asset Management discuss the Tannery Brook CSO outfall with Somerville’s Finance Committee.
We look forward to engaging at the Finance Committee meeting with the Director of Infrastructure and Asset Management. And we hope to meet with the Mayor.
We thank Alewife supporter and Somerville resident Andy Visser for introducing us to the Council. And we thank the City Council for their time, compassion, and affirmative votes.
Thank you Madam President Neufeld, Councilor Ewen-Campen, Councilor Burnley Jr., Councilor Clingan, Councilor Davis, Councilor Mbah, Councilor McLaughlin, Councilor Sait, Councilor Scott, Councilor Strezo, and Councilor Wilson.
Click below to watch the Presentation:
Eugene Benson, Kristin Anderson, David Stoff Present to City Council
Over 300 Alewife Brook supporters attended the public Alewife CSO Sewage Pollution meeting on January 22nd. Another 100-200 people registered.
Thank you for your support. The State and Federal regulators were there. They work for all of us and they took note of your concern.
MWRA tried to silence us. So we fought back and won a seat at the table.
Massachusetts Water Resources Authority did not want the Watershed Associations to make 2-3 minute statements at this important meeting. We fought back with our “FRED: Let us speak!” campaign, which yielded 189 emails to MWRA’s Executive Director, Fred Laskey.
In response to those emails, MWRA’s contractor CBI suggested the creation of a new CSO Control Plan Advisory Board. We want an Advisory Board that allows the Watershed advocates a seat at the planning table.
Your Comments in the Poll and in the Chat Were Awesome.
Attendees were asked in a poll: What hopes and/or concerns do you have? Here are screenshots of poll comments:
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
meeting poll comment
A common theme in the chat was how long the process is taking.
The Proposals.
“If you can’t bedazzle them with brilliance, baffle them with BS!”
Above: A Proposed Minimum Plan, aka: 2050 Typical Year of Sewage Pollution Control. Sewer separation in Somerville is great! However, this plan fails because it was engineered to result in 26% more sewage pollution than what we have now. That is in average years and much would be worse during rainy years.
Above: Somerville’s proposal includes two stormwater wetlands in Davis Square. One wetlands is sited in a parking lot and the other on private property.
Replacing parking lots with Green Stormwater Infrastructure will get support from environmentalists and will make Davis Square incredibly beautiful. But taking private homes by eminent domain is not a serious proposal.
We need workable solutions.
Above: Somerville’s Mystic River Alternative where 100% of the CSOs are already treated.
Somerville’s Alewife Brook CSO outfall at Tannery Brook discharges untreated sewage pollution into parks, yards, and homes. The Tannery Brook CSO outfall is a serious health hazard.
We recommend that Somerville focuses resources on Alewife Brook.
Above: MWRA’s Storage Tunnel along Alewife Brook would have to be 32 feet in diameter to achieve “virtual CSO elimination.”
What was missing from the proposals:
A solution at the Alewife MBTA station for the Alewife’s worst CSO outfall.
Sewer Separation and Green Stormwater Infrastructure in Cambridge.
Upgrades to MWRA’s regional sewer system, which is often overwhelmed during storm events. For instance, on Sunday, 2/16/2025, Deer Island Wastewater Treatment Plant was overwhelmed and discharged “blended” untreated sewage.
A CSO treatment facility, which would not only treat sewage but also improve stormwater quality.
Alewife Brook Dredging Project, to improve water quality, reduce flooding, and make the brook boatable.
Football Fields vs. Swimming Pools of Sewage.
Cambridge and Somerville dueled over sewage volume metaphors to describe the size of CSO detention tanks. Cambridge’s metaphor made more sense and is easier to understand. It stated that a football field is 360 ft x 160 ft. At one foot deep, it can hold 431,000 gallons of sewage pollution.
It is easy to imagine a 23-foot deep tank under the Dilboy Park football field. That would hold almost 10 million gallons of untreated sewage pollution from Davis Square. This may be the size tank needed to achieve “virtual CSO elimination” for the Tannery Brook CSO outfall.
This seems like a large tank, but other cities are creating larger storage solutions. And Sewer Separation and Green Storm Water Infrastructure can reduce the size of a CSO detention tank at Dilboy Park.
Note: this idea has *not* been floated publicly by MWRA, Cambridge, or Somerville.
What we learned.
If no work is done, we expect to see upwards of 20.9 million gallons of untreated sewage discharged into the Brook annually on average by the year 2050. But weather will be more erratic in 2050, so there will be much more sewage pollution during rainy years.
The new plan must include either “virtual elimination”or a treatment facility for all Alewife CSOs.
Backsliding: Making a Bad Situation Worse.
The polluters – MWRA, Cambridge, & Somerville – presented their modeling numbers for sewage pollution control. They altered the “Typical Year” volume of sewage pollution that they agreed to in Federal Court*.
The result is a 26% increase of sewage pollution.
In the slide above, the “Prior Typical Year” for Alewife Brook shows the CSO discharge volume of 9.9 million gallons. The Typical Year CSO volume of 7.29 million gallons is the court mandated annual permitted volume.
The purpose of the Updated Long Term Control Plan is to improve conditions, not worsen them. Note that many years have more rains than in a “typical year.” In the future, the weather will be more erratic, with more wet years.
Planning for the minimum level of Alewife CSO control ensures failure. And it will lead to at least 26% more sewage pollution than what we have today.
Footnotes:
* Table 3-1 from MWRA’s most recent 2023-cso-annual-report , which shows that Previous Typical Year CSO volume is 7.29 million gallons:
** The CSO control requirement in the original Long Term CSO Control Plan [7.29 MG] is also used for the wasteload allocation for Alewife CSOs in the Harbor Pathogen TMDL. This substitution should not be allowed under the Clean Water Act’s “Anti-backsliding” rules. (CWA section 303(d)(4)(A)).
Four decades since the start of the Boston Harbor Court Case and dumping of millions of gallons of untreated sewage continues at Alewife Brook. But a new plan is being developed. It is exciting that we have the opportunity now to solve the problem.
We pay our sewer bills.
At this Wednesday’s Public Sewage Control Planning meeting, there will be talk about projects andaffordability.
We support needed investment, even if that means an increase in our sewer bills.
Our strategy is simple.
Login to the meeting on Wednesday night.
Let them know that we pay our sewer bills and we support needed investment for solving the Alewife sewage problem.
Because of area flooding, we demand either 1. “Virtual Elimination,” meaning: no sewage discharges for up to a 25-year storm; or 2. Treatment for all Alewife sewage pollution.
Questions in the chat.
Please bring your own awesome questions to ask in the chat. Find a way to personalize your question. Try to relate your experience with the brook, the park, or the path. Or feel free to use any of these questions:
1.
Can you please use your brilliant and beautiful engineers and consultants to create a plan to put an end to Alewife Brook sewage pollution? We’d like to see Alewife Brook as clean and pretty as your dazzling smiles!
2.
Can you please study the health impacts of Alewife Brook’s untreated sewage pollution flooding on the affected neighborhoods?
3.
This is an Environmental Justice issue. Will you please create a plan to end untreated sewage flooding into Environmental Justice neighborhood parks, yards, and homes?
4.
Did you know that there is enormous public support for more Green Stormwater Infrastructure? Can we get more of it, including another stormwater wetland?
5.
Are you ready to become superheros? Oh, yeah? Well, then, deliver a plan that includes an engineered solution to achieve “virtual elimination,” which means no sewage discharges for up to a 25-year storm!
6.
Which is cheaper: CSO treatment for all Alewife Brook sewage discharges or an engineered solution to achieve a 25-year level of CSO control? We’ll be happy with either solution.
Great news! The Town of Arlington has taken action to protect the community and environment from the harmful effects of Alewife Brook sewage pollution. Under the leadership of Selectboard Chair Steve DeCourcey, Vice Chair Diane Mahon, and Town Manager Jim Feeney, the Town of Arlington has called upon Governor Healey to coordinate efforts between the MBTA, MWRA, DCR, and DEP to ensure that Combined Sewer Overflows (CSOs) and flood mitigation are an integral part of the MBTA’s Alewife Station redevelopment plan1. The Town also reached out to MBTA General Manager Philip Eng to consider the health, safety, and environmental needs of surrounding communities in the project’s design2.
Town of Arlington Calls for Green Solutions
The Town of Arlington is urging Governor Healey and the MBTA to address untreated sewage pollution and flooding in the Alewife T Station redevelopment planning process. They propose several environmentally friendly solutions to the Alewife’s sewage flooding problem:
1. CSO storage under the Alewife site 2. Inclusion of an adjacent stormwater wetland 3. Sewer separation 4. Prohibition of new connections to combined sewers
A Watershed Moment
While the MBTA’s plan to redevelop Alewife Station presents an amazing opportunity to provide transit-based housing, it also poses a significant risk.3 The project could exacerbate the already critical CSO problem, particularly concerning Outfall Number CAM401A. This single CSO, located feet away from the proposed development site, discharged over 20 million gallons of untreated sewage in 2023, exceeding the permitted annual total for all Alewife Brook CSOs.
Please join Save the Alewife Brook at Thursday’s in-person Monthly MBTA Board Meeting. We will respectfully ask the good folks at the MBTA to support Arlington’s call for a Greener Alewife MBTA Station. To ensure community involvement in the process, we ask for the formation of an MBTA Alewife Development Advisory Committee.
The Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection issued a new Water Quality Variance for Alewife Brook. The new Water Quality Variance still allows discharges of untreated sewage into the Brook. However, MassDEP’s Water Quality Variance now includes some measures to reduce the harmful effects of untreated sewage pollution.
Thanks to your comments and MassDEP’s hard work, the Alewife Brook Water Quality Variance now requires:
1. A Study on Installing Onsite Real-time CSO Notification to protect people from unknowingly walking through sewage flooding. We asked for a red-amber-green light at each CSO and where the Brook floods onto the Greenway path.
2. Odor Control. MWRA, Somerville, and Cambridge shall implement Best Management Practices for odor control for their Alewife sewer systems.
3. “Floatables” Control studyfor all Alewife CSOs. Somerville must determine how to fix their CSO to screen out or clean up toilet paper and other hazardous human waste products.
4. Fair and Just Financial Capability Analysis to make improvements at the local level. Massachusetts Water Resources Authority will not get away with submitting their “system-wide elimination” cost of billions of dollars. They don’t need to separate every sewer pipe throughout Boston to solve the problem for Alewife Brook. There are viable solutions for the Alewife and MWRA knows it!
5. Acknowledgement of Climate Change. Incorporation of Climate Change Impacts in planning, with future storm event reporting to be based on updated rainfall data from the latest NOAA Atlas .
6. Green Infrastructure must be considered by Somerville, MWRA, and Cambridge.
Thank you to the awesome folks at MassDEP who spent 14 months working on the 2024 Alewife Brook Water Quality Variance, including: Susannah King, Catherine Coniaris, Areeg Abd-Alla, Eric Worrall, Catherine Vakalopoulos, Kathleen Baskin, Kevin Brander, and Lealdon Langley.
We hope that this is the last Alewife Brook Water Quality Variance. Our community deserves a safe Alewife Brook and an End to Untreated Sewage Pollution.
Thank you to the Mystic River Watershed & Charles River Watershed Associations for their major and ongoing contributions. Donations accepted here:
A child riding her bike through Alewife sewage flood water on 9/19/2023. Photo by Ann McDonald.
There is a long history1 of Alewife Brook flooding during rain storms. Alewife Brook flooding occurs because of its topography and because of urbanization. The area is relatively flat and has been heavily developed with impervious surfaces like pavement and buildings. This results in a reduction of natural flood storage.
The urban stormwater drainage system is designed to handle limited, small-size storms2. When we get larger or more intense storms, there is flooding. When Alewife Brook floods, there is likely untreated sewage in the floodwater.3. Flooding is bad enough. Sewage flooding is many times worse and a serious health hazard.
2023 Flood Events
We have documented that Alewife Brook flooded at least 5 times in 2023. It is possible that more flooding occurred. But based on photographic evidence,4 and confirmed with USGS water gage data5, we know of at least 5 times.
In these 2023 storms, sewage-contaminated flood water covered parts of the Alewife Greenway. The Greenway is a popular multi-use path on State Parkland for walkers, joggers, students, and cyclists. The Alewife Greenway connects residents from Somerville, Medford, Cambridge, and Arlington to the Alewife MBTA Station and the Minuteman Bikeway.
August 8th, 2023: Area residents jogged and pushed baby strollers through sewage floodwater on the Alewife Greenway. Photo by David Stoff.
USGS Water Gage Data & Rainfall in 2023
The table below shows the 5 flooding events in 2023 that were documented with photos and gage data. There were also documented CSO sewage discharges on each of these flood dates. According to the MWRA, total Alewife CSO sewage discharges in 2023 were over 29 million gallons6.
Flooding
Max Water
Max Water
Daily Rainfall
Date
Height (feet)
Flow (cfs)
(in) ↟
Mar 13-14
3.54
94.80
2.54
Aug 8
4.10
149.25
1.33
Sep 18-19
3.81
103.83
1.52
Dec 11
3.26
93.83
1.75
Dec 18
3.60
108.75
1.68
↟ Daily values do not fully capture rainfall intensity.
We made a huge splash at this year’s HONK! parade, once again doubling the number of our supporters. Youth members handed out hundreds of fish stickers to child spectators along the way. Hundreds of petition signatures were collected from Somervillians and Cantabridgians. And we handed out 1000 flyers!
STOP DUMPING SEWAGE INTO ALEWIFE BROOK!
photos by Jimmy Johnson
1000 Flyershanded out to spectators 457 Stickers handed out to children 256 Petition Signatures 77 Environmental Activists from Somerville, Cambridge, Arlington, Belmont, Medford, and Watertown 77 Save the Alewife Brook t-shirts 50 GHOST FISH signs 18 Closed Streets 15 Youth Activists, handing out stickers to children 4 Strollers& 1 Walker 3 Yucky Poop signs 2 Miles of Marching 1 Mermaid in Mourning
photos by Ann McDonald
Thanks to Sarah at Puppeteers Cooperative and to everyone marched, carried signs, handed out flyers and stickers, chanted, and to everyone who came out to support us at the HONK! Parade, from Davis Square to Harvard Square.
Alida Castillo, Amber Fisher, Ann McDonald, Bartholomew Singer, Beckett Hardesty, Beryl Minkle, Bhaskar Brownstein, Brian McBride, Brian McKinnon, Brook Edwards, Chandran Seshagiri, Chandreyee Das, Charles Teague, Damien McClain, Danny Gromfin, David Stoff, Elaine Crowder, Elise Hopper, Emma Imamovic, Eppa Rixey, Eric Grunebaum, Gary Von Colln, Gwen Speeth, Haakon Chevalier, Jacob De Remer, Jamie Trent, Jimmy Johnson, Joel Snider, John, John Boutin, Julia Denham, Kelly Cartagena Rusch, Kent Lydecker,Kevin Buckley, Krista Snell, Kristin Anderson, Lani Hardesty, Larry Hardesty, Libby Saw, Liliana Gheorghiu, Lina Haddad, Linea Rowe, Lisa Birk, Macky Buck, Maeve Whitty, Magdalena De Remer, Marcus (Smitty’s artist friend), Mark Jewell, Matt Potenza,Matthew De Remer, Michael Hardesty, Michael Rome, Mick Potenza, Mirian Barrientos, Nayu Shrestha, Nick Carr, Pooja Usgaonkar, Sam Pierce, Sandy Durmaskin, Sarah Jensen, Smriti Shrestha, Susan Denham, Sylvie Fisher, Tara Kovalik, Uma Gage, Victoria De Remer, Victoria Gethers, plus everyone who showed up on the spot, and did not sign up in advance.
On Saturday, September 7th, Save the Alewife Brook’s Ann McDonald and Kristin Anderson kayaked into Alewife Brook from the Mystic River to get a look at current conditions and see if the Brook was navigable by water. The plan was to paddle from the Mystic River all the way to Cambridge’s only urban forest at the Alewife Stormwater Wetland. We knew there had not been a CSO sewage discharge in several weeks but were still cautious about touching the water and sediment.
The Department of Conservation and Recreation recently finished their impressive debris cleanup effort in the Alewife Brook from Route 2 to Broadway Bridge. Though their Engineering Department was focused on addressing flooding, removal of the debris “dams” means it is now possible to get small boats through. Our adventure would simply not have been possible before DCR’s amazing cleanup work.
Still, we encountered three major obstacles on our voyage: a nearly impassable smelly CSO sewage blob under the Broadway Bridge, downed trees in the water behind Dilboy Park, and a massive amount of CSO sediment.
The Sewage
A blob of sewage, comprised of “floatables” from Davis Square toilets, was stuck under the Broadway Bridge behind Dilboy Park.
This blob of smellysewage “floatables” from Davis Square toilets was recently freed from Somerville’s Tannery Brook CSO debris snag during DCR’s debris removal. When we put our paddles into it, nothing seemed to move. It was stuck under Broadway Bridge, wedged between some large logs. We need to end the dumping of untreated sewage into the Brook.
The Swan
Behind Dilboy Park: The curious Sunnyside Swan greeted us peacefully. Photo by Ann McDonald.
The Brook behind Dilboy Park at Sunnyside Avenue is quite beautiful. This section of the Alewife Brook sustains many species of wildlife. The Brook here is a natural channel – not trapped in concrete. We saw painted turtles sunning themselves on logs and several schools of swimming fish.
It appears that a storm felled a few large trees into the water there. So, with great difficulty, we navigated the Brook at Dilboy Park. The downed trees should be removed before they turn into dams, restrict water flow, and threaten more flooding.
We saw some trash in the water here, too, including a bike, an umbrella, and a plastic pink flamingo. We hope to return to collect this debris with the community canoe.
The Sediment
The largest obstacle we encountered on our voyage was the massive volume of sediment trapped between the concrete walls of the channel. In 2023, suspended solids from CSO sewage discharges contributed over 16 tons of new sediment to the already clogged Alewife Brook.1
Navigating the concrete channel, south of Mass Ave.
The trees along the brook are gorgeous, making the paddling enjoyable in the densely covered stretch between Henderson Bridge and Route 2. But sediment levels here are extremely high, and the concrete channel does not sustain wildlife. You might encounter the odd duck but, despite waterfowl swimming on the surface, pretty much nothing can grow underneath in the concrete. That is why we call it “the concrete death channel.”
Dredging & Concrete Channel Removal
The Department of Conservation and Recreation’s Alewife Master Plan2 includes stream channel restoration, as shown above. Removal of the sediment, by eliminating historical contaminants, would provide an immediate improvement in water quality. Removal of the concrete channel would increase wildlife habitat and provide needed flood storage.
According to the 2003 Alewife Master Plan2, funding opportunities for dredging and concrete channel removal include the US Department of Transportation (USDOT), the US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), the US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), the US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), and the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS). State sources for funding such restoration may also exist, including through DCR and MassDOT, as part of their stormwater management responsibilities, because DCR’s Alewife Brook Parkway and MassDOT’s Route 2 are both state highways that contribute runoff to Alewife Brook.
Paddling under Route 2. Photo by Ann McDonald.
Beyond the Route 2 culvert, we navigated many fallen tree dams, making progress difficult as we continued upstream in the Little River towards Little Pond.
Ann McDonald and David White at the landing spot. Photo by Kristin Anderson.
We beached at Cambridge’s only urban forest, by the Alewife Stormwater Wetland.
After washing our hands well, we enjoyed lunch at Revival Cafe. Photo by Ann McDonald.
Heading back to Alewife Brook from Little River, under the Minuteman Bike trail. Photo by Ann McDonald.
Behind Dilboy Park: Removing a downed tree branch with a handsaw to clear the way for kayaks. No dogs were harmed in this video.
Paddling back out to the Mystic River under the magical and historic Mystic Valley Parkway Bridge. Photo by Jimmy Johnson.
Thank you to East Arlington’s Good Neighbor George Laite, who helped us to get the kayaks into the water at the Lower Mystic Lake.
Footnotes:
Suspended solids calculation according to the MWRA’s 2001 Notice of Project Change for CSO Long Term Control Plan for Alewife Brook, EOEA #10335. Download available here.
Hopes were high that something great would come from the meeting. This month we found out what!
There were rumblings that something was afoot this spring when Charles “Chuck” Green of DCR’s engineering staff came down to the Brook. Chuck came by to catalog stream snags on a GPS device. Things went quiet for months. But on August 12th, Chuck was back! He brought a crew from DCR’s subcontractor, New England Disposal Technologies, a hazardous waste management company.
DCR Cleanup 2024. Photo by Ann McDonald.
DCR Cleanup 2024. Photo by Ann McDonald.
DCR Cleanup 2024. Photo by Ann McDonald.
DCR Cleanup 2024. Photo by Ann McDonald.
DCR Cleanup 2024. Photo by Ann McDonald.
DCR Cleanup 2024. Photo by Ann McDonald.
DCR Cleanup 2024. Photo by Ann McDonald.
DCR Cleanup 2024. Photo by Ann McDonald.
DCR Cleanup 2024. Photo by Ann McDonald.
DCR Cleanup 2024. Photo by Ann McDonald.
DCR Cleanup 2024. Photo by Ann McDonald.
The NEDT crew are phenomenally hard workers. They worked on clearing debris from the brook for almost three weeks, from August 12th to August 30th, filling more than six 40-cubic-yard dumpsters of debris. Using a boat, a backhoe, a bulldozer, chainsaws, and a wood chipper, they cleared the channel obstructions from the culvert at state Route 2 all the way down the Alewife Brook channel to Broadway.
DCR’s contractor NEDT removes downed trees in the Alewife Brook, August 2024. Video shot by Ann McDonald.
Along with the woody snags, the crew removed tires, bikes, a slew of traffic cones and, of course, another safe; this time with a crowbar in it! Removing these debris dams should help reduce flooding in smaller storm events.
Somerville’s Smelly Tannery Brook CSO
Nowhere are the results more dramatic than at Tannery Brook, the site of Somerville’s Alewife Brook CSO that discharges raw sewage from Davis Square. This was the smelliest debris dam in the Brook! The odor has been so bad here that a single whiff of it induced nausea.
Toilet paper hung from branches at Somerville’s Tannery Brook CSO.
Tannery Brook cleanup. Photo by Ann McDonald.
Toilet paper hung from branches at Somerville’s Tannery Brook CSO.
Tannery Brook cleanup. Photo by Ann McDonald.
Hard Work Leads to Amazing Results
It took a lot of work. Contributions came from the DCR commissioner and the agency’s engineering staff. There was also pressure from Save the Alewife Brook and State Representative Dave Rogers to make this clean-out a reality.
We expect the benefits to include reduced sewage flooding during small storm events. Plus, we now have a clear stream that fish and small boats can navigate!
Fish are now free to swim from below the Route 2 culvert into the Brook. Video by David Stoff, August 27, 2024.
THANK YOU!
to the Healey Administration, DCR Commissioner Brian Arrigo, DCR Chief Engineer Rob Lowell, DCR’s Charles “Chuck” Green, & NEDT workers.
Thanks also to Representatives Dave Rogers & Sean Garballey.
And thankyou, dear reader, for your continued public support! This wouldn’t be possible without you.
The folks who donned hazmat suits and went into Alewife Brook have our special thanks, and Save the Alewife t-shirts, too! Photo by David Stoff.
Charles “Chuck” Green of DCR’s engineering. Photo by Ann McDonald.
On August 8th, 2024, Save the Alewife Brook provided an “Alewife Brook CSO*s 101” class and walking tour to students participating in the local Biodiversity Builders program. We explained the basics and some of the details of Alewife Brook’s Combined Sewer Overflows**. Our course materials are available for download below.
Biodiversity Builders is an environmental education initiative that provides paid summer internships to high school students in the area. The program, organized by Jean Devine of Belmont, educates students on restoring local ecosystems through native plantings and promotes advocacy for nature-based solutions to combat Climate Change.
Biodiversity Builders students and members of Save the Alewife Brook next to Cambridge’s worst CSO: CAM401A.
Do you live in the Alewife Brook Watershed?
Our CSOs 101 class began at the Alewife Showcase Pollinator Garden , where we presented the Mystic River Watershed Association’s map of the Alewife Brook Watershed. Rain that falls within the black-bordered outline on the map drains to Alewife Brook. Interestingly, all students in the class live within the Alewife Brook Watershed – some students live in Cambridge, others in Belmont, and some in Arlington.
The students learned that untreated sewage in Alewife Brook is particularly alarming because the Brook floods regularly. Last year, it flooded multiple times, sending untreated sewage flood water into our State park and into Environmental Justice neighborhoods. Unaware of the sewage discharges, neighbors continued to jog, cycle, and push baby strollers through contaminated sewage floodwater.
Next, we toured the Commonwealth’s CSO, MWR003, and discussed how it was reconstructed in 2015 to discharge larger volumes of untreated sewage than it had before. This CSO functions as cheap hydraulic relief for the Commonwealth’s downstream sewer system which has systemic problems and lacks adequate capacity during storm events.
We also visited CAM401A, Cambridge’s worst CSO, located next to the MBTA’s Alewife Station parking garage. In 2023, this CSO discharged over 20 million gallons of sewage pollution. The 2023 discharge from CAM401A significantly exceeded the permitted annual total for all the Alewife Brook CSOs of 7.3 million gallons.
Finally, we discussed both immediate and long-term achievable solutions to the problem. The class concluded with a walk through Cambridge’s beautiful Alewife Stormwater Wetlands. This engineered wetlands is a large green stormwater infrastructure project that was part of the first CSO control project that was completed a decade ago. It serves to mitigate flooding by storing stormwater and enhancing water quality of what eventually flows into Alewife Brook. The students enjoyed identifying native plantings and wildlife there.
We would love to present our Alewife CSOs 101 Class to your students, of any age. Please feel free to get in touch with us about our free classes by emailing us here.
* CSO = Combined Sewer Overflow, where the overflow from combined storm and sanitary sewers discharge sewage (human and industrial wastes) into public waters. ** Six CSOs dump untreated wastewaters into Alewife Brook. One is from Somerville, one is from the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority, and four are from Cambridge.
In August 2024, the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection (MassDEP) and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) may issue a water quality variance for Alewife Brook to allow CSO sewage discharges to continue through 2029. Water quality variances for Alewife Brook have been issued for the last 25 years, since 1999.
Discharge of sewage into public waters is not permitted under federal and state water quality standards, with some limited exceptions. The proposed draft water quality variance has multiple flaws and must be improved to protect the health of our community.
Alewife Brook is a “Class B” waterbody. That means it should be safe for human contact. It should support healthy fish communities. There should be no untreated sewage in it. However, Cambridge, Somerville, and the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority (MWRA) dump untreated human and industrial sewage from their Combined Sewer Overflows (CSOs) into Alewife Brook during rainstorms.
WHAT WE TOLD DEP & EPA IN OUR WRITTEN COMMENTS ABOUT THE VARIANCE:
Granting the variance would undermine Environmental Justice principles, which call for enforcement of environmental standards and protection of environmental justice neighborhoods from environmental harms.
MWRA, Somerville, and Cambridge should not be awarded a new variance if they have failed to meet the requirements of the current variance. MWRA fails to adequately maintain its sewers to prevent odors. Somerville’s combined sewer outfall (SOM001A) has failed to meet discharge and floatable controls requirements. Cambridge’s CSO behind the Alewife T parking garage (CAM401A) continues to fail to conform to the hydraulic models.
If MassDEP grants the variance, it must require the polluters to act now to address CSOs, and not allow them to delay action further, until the new Alewife CSO Plan is approved and implemented. MassDEP must also add add the following conditions to the Variance so that CSO discharges do not get worse:
1) A prohibition on new hook ups to the combined sewers in Cambridge and Somerville that contribute to the CSOs in Alewife Brook, as well as a prohibition on more than de minimis increases to current flows to those combined sewers.
2) Adequate notification of the presence sewage in and around the brook. People using the Alewife Greenway path and abutters of the brook require timely, clear warnings when CSOs are discharging into the brook, and for at least 48 hours afterwards (e.g., red light when discharging and for 24 hours after discharge ends, yellow light for 24-48 hours after discharge ends, and green light if no discharges for more than 48 hours).
3) Improve accuracy of CSO metering and modeling, so Cambridge can understand why their worst CSO, CAM401A is failing, and how they can fix it.
4) MWRA must implement an odor control program for all their Alewife sewer infrastructure.
5) Cambridge, Somerville, and MWRA must deploy Green Infrastructure to capture and clean stormwater, and prevent it from activating CSOs. The use of green infrastructure can enhance neighborhoods, especially those with little green space or trees.
6) Require Cambridge, Somerville, and MWRA to provide separate financial analyses from for their Alewife CSOs, and explore the use of subsidies for low-income households or a tiered-rate system to cap cost increases for ratepayers who might struggle to pay higher rates. This is consistent with longstanding Environmental Justice principles that Environmental Justice communities should not bear the burden or costs of pollution that are beyond their control.
7) Provide reports and online sewer maps to advocacy groups.
The public using the Alewife Brook Greenway and abutters of the Brook need much clearer warning when there are active CSO discharges, and for at least 24 hours after a discharge has ended (e.g., red light when discharging, yellow light for 24 hours after discharge ends). Subscriber-based notifications are insufficient for those who may be using the greenway. It is imperative to add requirements for MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville to enhance notification by installing warning beacons or similar, highly visible signage when the outfalls on the Alewife Brook are discharging… MassDEP should add a condition requiring Cambridge and Somerville to limit future increases in sewage flows to current combined sewers discharging to the Alewife Brook/Upper Mystic during the term of the variance. This could take the form of a prohibition on new hook ups to the combined system,… Save the Alewife Brook has documented instances of failures of floatable controls at SOM001A.Odor control has also been an issue at manholes along the Greenway Path. MassDEP and EPA must commit to better enforcement of these measures.
We are deeply concerned that the proposed variance is failing to protect a valuable natural resource and is not delivering continued, meaningful progress. As drafted, the Tentative Variance is inadequate as it allows for continued pollution without requiring substantive corrective actions during the variance period… We do not support the Tentative Variance as written… the ultimate goal should be nothing less than complete or functional elimination of the CSO discharges… The current financial analysis is inadequate for determining the economic feasibility of CSO elimination… Combined Sewer Overflow is an Environmental Justice issue. Environmental Justice (EJ) is a stated priority for the federal government and the Healey-Driscoll administration.
MWRA Advisory Board: Alewife’s not worth fixing.
In their comments to MassDEP, the MWRA Advisory Board make it clear thatFred Laskey‘s MWRA wants to avoid any investment to end dumping of untreated CSO sewage into Alewife Brook:
“…spending an additional $100 for a $1 incremental benefit would make no sense from a public policy view.”
“Performing [analysis needed for the updated Alewife Brook CSO Control Plan] would be extremely expensive and may ultimately be unnecessary.”
“CSO number CAM401A is right next to a small piece of property that is owned by Green Cambridge in the Alewife Reservation. And it’s also immediately adjacent to the MBTA property. We’re very concerned that encampments of unhoused people are being flooded during CSO events. There has been an unhoused person encampment next to the MBTA garage. We think that encampment was empty when it was flooded by the combined sewer overflow last week. However, there are many encampments in the Alewife Reservation that were occupied and possibly exposed. We would like to ask that the warning system that our partners have proposed includes an alert that be provided directly to the Cambridge Health Department, so that the Health Department could send people to the Alewife Reservation to move encampments before they are flooded by sewage outflows.”
“We are smart people who have great resources. We have People Power in Somerville and we are not in compliance. Somerville needs to do a hard think about doing intense Green Infrastructure.”
“I’m an Arlington resident. My home abuts the Alewife Brook which has 6 Combined Sewer Outfalls dumping untreated sewage and industrial waste into the brook. I’m here today to testify in opposition to the proposed variance.
I’ve participated in regulatory actions about the Alewife for over 20 years. My expectation has always been that DEP would act to protect the health of our community and enforce the Alewife’s existing Class B water quality standard rather than waive it.
The law encourages consideration of site-specific conditions. The proximity of untreated sewage discharges to a densely populated and heavily used area – here on the Alewife and in the Charles at CAM 005 – and the evidence of routine contact with the discharges ought to be sufficient for DEP to use its best professional judgment and require dischargers to meet a water quality standard that protects safe human contact.
The waters of Massachusetts are held in trust for the citizens of the Commonwealth. Using them as sewers prioritizes short-term economic benefits for a few over their value to us all in the future.”
Gathering to discuss the CAM002 CSO, which predates the historic Mass Ave bridge. Volunteers received t-shirts, boatbags, and Kolsvart Swedish Fish. Photo Credit: Arthur Prokosch
Eighty Save the Alewife Brook volunteers met for an Earth Day Clean-up on Saturday, April 13, 2024. We collected trash along the entire length of the Alewife Brook, visiting all six of the Alewife’s Combined Sewer Outfalls, from the Alewife T Station to Mystic Valley Parkway.
David Stoff near Wald Park, fishing for shopping carts. Photo by Ann McDonald.
David Stoff brought his boat out to help fish shopping carts out of the brook. The Department of Conservation & Recreation helped remove a plastic barrel in the brook. That barrel had been there for years.
Vincent Baudoin pulled three shopping carts out of the brook. Photo by Ann McDonald.
Boat meets band. Photo by Clare Nosowitz.
If only you could have seen the expression on one young volunteer’s face when we told her that we had a boat to collect trash in the brook! She was excited for two reasons: because she wanted to clean up the brook and because boats are fun. Alewife Brook should become a boatable brook for the enjoyment of all.
Sunnyside’s Native Plant Meadow
Sunnyside’s Native Meadow. Photo by David White.
The cleanup extended from the Alewife T station downstream to Sunnyside Avenue near the Mystic River. There the neighbors have established a native plant meadow. As can be seen from the sky, the weather was very unsettled for this event.
Thanks to the Department of Conservation & Recreation!
Thanks to Matthew Perry, Kevin Hunter, and Chris from the Department of Conservation & Recreation for coming out to help with our Earth Day Cleanup.
Photos by Ann McDonald.
Thanks to the Volunteers from Cambridge, Arlington, Somerville, Belmont, Medford, Boston, Carlisle, & Spencer!
Adam Auster * Amanda Hope * Andy T * Aneil Tripathy * Ann McDonald * Annie Thompson * Arthur Prokosch * Ben Baron * Beth Melofchik * Betsy Lenora * Betty Widerski * Brad Johnson * Brian Graham * Christine Metzler * Clare Nosowitz * Constance Martin * Cynthis Stillinger * David Lough * David Stoff * David White * Diane Connor * Dillon Herring * Doug Brown * Elaine Campbell * Ellen Mass * Ellen Zimmermann * Emma Walter * Eppa Rixey * Eric Cao * Gilbert Martin * George Laite * Gwen Speeth * Hayley Sutherland * Jamie Trent * Jared Robinson * Jason Wadsworth * Javier Matamoros * Jay Bryan * Jen Clay * Joann Keesey * Joe Poirier * Josh Pieper * Kathleen Fizgerald * Kate Wolfe * Kathleen Fitzgerald * Ken Hjulstrom * Kendra Martin * Kristin Anderson * Lilli Smith * Loren Bernardi * Lynn Rosenbaum * Mark Foster * Megen McLaughlin * Melissa McWhinny * Michelle Gulen * Morgan Herring * Nancy Frost * Nelson Tetreault * Nina Paynter * Nuala Barker * Octavia Wadsworth * Pasang Lhamo * Paul Lipsky * Philip Thompson * Pooja Usgaonkar * Robert Collins * Robert Jones * Robin Shaw * Sadie Martin * Scott Levine * Shaina Blitt * Silas Poirier * Sonya Green * Stacy Cleth * Steve Rapp * Susan Denham * Sulchamchi Bedi * Talia Shire * Ulli Rapp * Veronique Bailly * Vincent Baudoin & Family
Thanks to BABAM! for bringing the party with their brass & beat!
The Boston Area Brigade of Activist Musicians played at Bicentennial Park.
Thanks to Kolsvart for supporting us with their generous donation of delicious Swedish Fish from Sweden!
Elimination of all Combined Sewer Overflows (CSOs) to End Sewage Pollution
Separated Sewer Systems to keep Sewage out of Stormwater
A Safe, Beautiful, Fishable Brook for the Residents and for Wildlife
New Green Infrastructure on State Land for Stormwater Cleaning
New Grey Infrastructure to Reduce Flooding in the Face of Climate Change
Email Legislators & the MWRA
2,555 signatures
Share this with your friends:
During some major storm events, the Alewife Brook floods into the parks, yards, and houses of area residents in Environmental Justice Communities. The flood water contains hazardous sewage that is discharged from the active CSOs owned by Cambridge, Somerville, and the MWRA. Climate change, with its wetter rainy seasons, more intense storms, and sea level rise, is expected to increase the severity and frequency of these events.
Furthermore, the MWRA’s sewer infrastructure is failing to meet capacity during many rain events, causing hazardous sewage pollution discharges. In fact, the rate of sewage discharge is increasing exponentially with increase in rainwater, making this a Climate Change Emergency.
Therefore, we demand that the cities of Cambridge, Somerville, and the MWRA completely stop discharging sewage pollution into the Alewife Brook. We also demand that the Commonwealth of Massachusetts invest in urgently needed improvements to the Amelia Earhart Dam and to the Draw Seven Park along the Mystic River so the area is resilient to the effects of flooding due to Climate Change.
Add your nameand email address to our Petition Comment Email shown below.
Send a Comment to MassDEP
This petition is now closed.
End date: Apr 22, 2024
Signatures collected: 266
266 signatures
Dear MassDEP,
The health of our community and the multiple environmental justice neighborhoods along the Alewife Brook depend on your protection.
Protect our brook, our park, and our homes from pathogens in the sewage flood water by enforcing the existing Class B (boatable and fishable) Water Quality Standard – the standard that ensures that contact with the waters of the Alewife Brook is safe. Please use the Department’s regulatory authority to require that out-of-compliance CSOs in the Alewife Brook and Charles River meet existing goals. Make sure that MassDEP is a forceful advocate for Supplemental Environmental Projects for all out-of-compliance CSOs in the Alewife Brook and Charles River in Federal Court proceedings.
There must be real scrutiny of the documentation MWRA has already provided for the cost of CSO elimination. MassDEP must require MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville each to provide a separate financial analysis explaining why they say they can’t afford to eliminate sewage discharges. These independent analyses should include costs for various alternatives, such as local CSO treatment, CSO detention tunnels and tanks, and Green Stormwater Infrastructure.
The public has a role in protecting the waters of Massachusetts. As the hearing on Tuesday, April 9, 2024 demonstrated, there is keen interest if the public is provided meaningful opportunities for participation. A single meeting and hearing is inadequate. Ongoing robust public participation must be part of the variance, particularly regarding the performance assessment of CSO controls based on “typical year” modeling. The community must have a seat at the table when compliance is reviewed so that actual measured data and human experience inform that assessment. That court-ordered performance goals remain unmet after 20 years is ample evidence of the need for public scrutiny.
Thank you for all you do to protect us and our environment.
–> To the 100 people who attended last Tuesday’s Alewife Sewage Hearing, held by the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection
–> To the good folks at MassDEP for hosting this special session and taking public comments for more than two hours
–> To the dedicated civic leaders who were there to offer support for a safe, boatable and fishable Alewife Brook
There were powerful statements from Alewife supporters in Cambridge, Somerville, Belmont, and Arlington about the need for a safe neighborhood, park, and brook. We sent a strong message for Environmental Justice and Community Health.
Local meteorologist Dave Epstein has predicted 2-5 inches of rain tonight, Wednesday, March 6th.
When we receive just less than an inch of hard, fast rain, we experience untreated sewage pollution discharges into Alewife Brook.
When we receive more than a couple of inches of hard, fast rain, the Alewife Brook floods over its bank and onto the Alewife Greenway path. This might occur around midnight tonight, depending on local precipitation.
Avoid any floodwater near Alewife Brook tomorrow and Friday. This water may be contaminated with raw sewage, which can cause illness.
Passage of our CSO bill would be a major step in reducing sewage pollution — not just in Alewife Brook, but throughout the Boston metropolitan area.
Thank you!
Our thanks to all of you who helped make this happen, including those who spoke in favor of the bill at the committee hearing, or wrote to the committee, or watched the hearing on the bill, or spoke out in any forum to support ending sewage pollution. A shout out to our partners at the Mystic River Watershed Association, the Charles River Watershed Association, and the Massachusetts Rivers Alliance, who all made strong statements in favor of the bill at the committee hearing.
Massive thanks go to RepresentativesDave Rogers& Adrian Madaro, who are the original sponsors of the legislation and helped get it out of committee, as well as all the other legislators who signed on as co-sponsors. We are grateful also for all that our legislators will do as they continue to push the bill forward through the remainder of the legislative session.
CSO Bill Sponsors Representatives Dave Rogers & Adrian C. Madaro
Sean Garballey, Steve Owens, Patricia Jehlen, Judith Garcia
Rady Mom, Lydia Edwards, Nick Collins, Sal N. DiDomenico, Bruce E. Tarr
Finally, thanks to the Co-Chairs of theJoint Committee on Environment and Natural Resources, Senator Rebecca Rausch and Representative Daniel Cahill, who recognized the harm being done by CSOs and the need for strong legislation, and who led the committee to report the bill out with a favorable vote.
Senator Rebecca Rausch & Representative Daniel Cahill
The bill has a long way to go to become law. Getting a new law enacted is a drawn-out process. The next step for the bill will be a referral to another committee, most likely the House Ways and Means Committee.
We will keep you updated and let you know when and how youcan help move it forward for a cleaner Alewife Brook and an end to sewage pollution!
In 2023, 27.8 Million Gallons of untreated sewage pollution was dumped in Alewife Brook by the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority, Somerville, and Cambridge.1
So what does that number mean? A way to visualize 28 millions gallons is to imagine a 6-story building the size of a football field full of sewage pollution. Imagine if all the toilets, sinks, showers, hospital drains and industrial process water in Cambridge and Somerville emptied into the Alewife Brook for a day. That would be 28 million gallons. The sewage dumped into the brook in 2023 was four times worse than the polluters’ authorized discharge amount of 7.29 million gallons per year.2
Because of Climate Change and aging infrastructure, the sewage pollution in the Alewife is worse now than it was three decades ago before a dollar was spent, and before any projects were begun to improve conditions as part of the Boston Harbor Cleanup Court Case.3
It’s not just sewage pollution – it’s sewage pollution flooding.
Last year, Alewife Brook flooded three times, overtopping its bank and releasing untreated Combined Sewer Overflows of human and industrial wastes onto the Alewife Reservation. When Alewife Brook floods, CSOs have been dumping untreated sewage into the Brook. Area residents from Somerville, Cambridge, and Arlington were seen bicycling, jogging, and pushing baby strollers through untreated sewage flood water on State Park Land.
August 8th 2023
Area residents biked, jogged, walked, and pushed baby carriages through untreated sewage pollution after the Alewife Brook flooded the popular Alewife Greenway path.
September 19th 2023
A child rode her bike through Alewife sewage flood water and subsequently got stuck in the muck so she and her bike fell into the sewage.
December 18th 2023
CSO sewage flooding in Cambridge inundated a homeless encampment on MBTA property behind the Alewife T parking garage, just feet away from Cambridge’s worst CSO. If we allow untreated sewage pollution to continue, this scene may well be a view of the future for the other 5000 people living in the Alewife’s 100-year floodplain.
Thank you to the hundreds of Alewife Supporters who registered & attended the 2023 Public CSO meeting on 11/15/2023.
We appreciate the support received from the many residents in Somerville, Cambridge, Arlington, Belmont, Medford, and beyond!
Areeg Abd-Alla, Melanie Abrams, Jonathan Agger, Kristin Anderson, John Anderson, Penny Antonoglou, Marina Atlas, Sarah Bell, Andrew Bellows, Eugene Benson, Loren Bernardi, Leiran Biton, David Boyer, Leah Broder, Ray Brown, Douglas Brown, Seth Bryant, Jonathan Burgess, Linda Burgess, Scott Burgess, Laurette Burgess, Melissa Campbell, Tricia Carney, Alida Castillo, Jeffrey Chagnon, Monique Chaplin, Susan Chapnick, Stephen Clark , Stephen Clark , Ellen Cohen, Eileen Coleman, Keith Collins, Cathy Coniaris, Marja Copeland, Michael Cunningham, Katie Daehn, Andrew Dague, Matthew De Remer, Shawn DeRosa, Andrew DeSantis, Alina Dess, D Devney, Angela DiTucci, Andreae Downs, Sandy Durmaskin, Sandy Durmaskin, Erin Ellingwood, Ruth Faas, Michael Fager, Susan Fagerstrom, Kara Falise, Richard Falzone, Jim Feeney, Maggie Fellows, David Fichter, Peter Fiore, Lori Fitz, Ben Flaumenhaft, Chelsea Foster, Nancy Frost, Andrea Ganino , Jon Gersh, Kathryn Goldenoak, Alix Gordon, Michael Greenblatt, Andrew Greenspon, Caleb Groen, Karen L Grossman, Lois Grossman, Alice Grossman, Charlie Hagedorn, S. Hall, Greg Harris, Max Heller, Patrick Herron, Greg Hill, Andrew Hrycyna, Qumrunnessa Huda, Vladimir Jandejsek, Sue Janowitz, Mark Jewell, Liz Jochnick, Anju Joglekar, Isaiah Johnson, Kathryn Johnson, Kathryn Johnson, Jessica Kinner, George Laite, Kane Larin, Alexander Lee, Jennifer Letourneau, Marc Levy, Pasang Lhamo, Stephen Linder, Christopher Logan, Melissa Ludtke, Kristin MacDougall, Diane Mahon, Ryan Maloney, Peg McAdam, Michael McCord, Ann McDonald, Melissa McWhinney, Nabia Meghelli, Beth Melofchik, Sarah Merin, Elizabeth Merrick, Amy Mertl, Christine Metzler, Melissa Miguel, Beryl Minkle, Addison Minott, Tyler Mourey, Linda Moussouris, Noreen Murphy, Anna Muszynski, Jeffrey North, Clare Nosowitz, Tracy Olson, Emily Paulsen, Andrea Paulson, Stephen Perkins, Rebecca Persson, Paul Pinella, Helen Quach, Michael Quinn, Mike Rademacher, Amy Ramsay, Steve Rapp, Eric Reuss, McKenna Roberts, Wendy Robinson, Michelle Robinson , Marcela Rodriguez, Dave Rogers, Max Rome, Katie Ronan, Paula Rosenof, Mark Rosenthal, Ruth Ryals, Yaser Samerraei, Margaretta Sangree , Amy Schofield, A Hugh Scott, Talia Shire, Adam Shire, Lou Silvestro, Andrew Smith, Gwen Speeth, Brad Spitzbart, George Stephans, George Stephans, ann stewart, Cynthia Stillinger , Sam Stivers, David Stoff, Diane Stokes, Barbara Strell, Joanna Sullivan, Dana Sussman, Francis T, Megan Talkington, Penelope Taylor, Liz Thorstenson, Zhenyu Tian, John Tortelli, Charlie Trageser, Cambria Ung, Dan Vallee, David VanHoven, Peter Varga, Andy Visser, Rachel Wagner, Al Weiner, Barbara Weir, David White, Jane Whitmore, Julie Wood, David Wright, Jennifer Yanco, Marijane Zeller, Mike A
Andy Hrycyna has been focused on Alewife Brook CSOs and brought the 2023 CSO totals to our attention. You can take a deep dive into Andy’s awesome analysis here.
Footnotes:
Based on preliminary data reported to the state at the Commonwealth’s Department of Energy & Environmental Affairs’ CSO Data Portal. 1/15/24 ↩︎
From Exhibit B to Second Stipulation of the United States and the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority on Responsibility and Legal Liability for Combined Sewer Overflows, as amended by the Federal District Court on May 7, 2008 (the “Second CSO Stipulation”), the Long Term Control Plan permitted annual total for Alewife Brook is 7.29 MG. This really represents an annual average limit since there will always be variations from year to year. However, for the past nine years, the average annual discharges have been 18.4 MG – more than twice the permitted level. ↩︎
The following is an interactive map that is fairly complex with a lot of information. The six red dots are the six Alewife CSOs that discharge untreated sewage pollution into the Alewife Brook.
“1% Annual Chance of Flood Hazard” is a FEMA designation for the “100-year” flood area. That means that there is a 1% chance of flooding in any year, and a 1 in 4 chance of flooding during the duration of a 30-year mortgage. It is based on previous rainfall and flooding data and does not take climate change into account which will increase the risk.
Interactive CSOs Map with FEMA Flood Zones
Click on the “+” and “-” in the lower left corner to zoom in and out of the map. There is a legend to the right of the “-” symbol. The layers are also clickable and can be turned on and off.
Parade with us, along with musicians and puppeteers. March to demand a safe, clean, and restored Alewife Brook. It is so much fun!
Puppeteers Cooperative has created large, colorful fish puppets. Big Blue, the Goddess of Clean Water will lead our group. Wear a free t-shirt and carry a hand-made GHOST FISH in the parade.
MassDEP has proposed another “Water Quality Variance” to waive water quality standards for Alewife Brook for up to five years. The variance would allow Cambridge, Somerville, and MWRA to continue to dump untreated sewage from their Combined Sewer Overflows (CSOs) into the brook while they finalize their new Long Term Control Plan (LTCP) to control CSO discharges. The polluters were granted a three-year extension to submit that plan.
This public comment hearing is our chance to demand that DEP include protections for our community in the variance. We can’t wait for action until the new CSO control plan takes effect in 2027. DEP must require Cambridge, Somerville, and MWRA to reduce CSO sewage discharges NOW! DEP has not yet agreed to do so.
Whether you live in the floodplain, jog, commute, cycle, walk your dog, stroll with your kids, watch birds, or play your guitar on a bench along Alewife Brook, this Public Hearing is for YOU.
You’ll have up to 3 minutes to tell your story about why you love the Alewife, and why it’s important to you that MassDEP end the dumping of sewage in our brook.
Demand a safe, healthy, boatable Alewife Brook NOW!
Ultimately, we want an end to CSO discharges in Alewife Brook. We want to enjoy it as a brook and not see it used as an overflow sewer. Then no water quality variance would be required.
In the meantime, we demand that DEP include the following protections for the Alewife Brook community in the CSO Variance:
An on-site warning-light notification system for the Alewife Greenway, so we know when CSOs are discharging sewage into our park, sewage that often floods over the path
Green Infrastructure to capture stormwater and reduce CSO discharges NOW
Action NOW to address massive sewage discharge volumes at Somerville’s Tannery Brook CSO (SOM001A) & Cambridge’s Alewife T Station CSO (CAM401A) before the new CSO control plan goes into effect in 2027
Consequences for the polluters for their failure to meet Boston Harbor Clean-Up Court Case requirements for Alewife Brook CSOs
Massachusetts Environmental Policy Act (MEPA) review of the new draft LTCP before the plan is set in stone
A requirement that the polluters continue to work to eliminate sewage discharges in the Alewife Brook even if the Boston Harbor Court Case is resolved
Ongoing community involvement in variance decision making, with input from the Department of Conservation and Recreation and waterbody advocacy groups on how direct measures like sediment removal, channel maintenance, and habitat restoration can improve water quality and support boating, fishing, and other recreational uses of the Alewife
Requirements informed by actual volumes of sewage discharged, not based on hypothetical “Typical Year” modeling
For more information: Download MassDEP’s variance fact sheets here and here. And the full language of the proposed variance here.
Please register today. Come to the hearing. Ask MassDEP to protect our community’s health.
On March 21, 2024, the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection hosted a meeting at their headquarters in Boston where we talked about Alewife Brook Water Quality. The main topic was the issuance of a new Alewife Brook CSO ‘variance’, which would allow MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville to continue to dump untreated sewage into Alewife Brook until they have a new approved sewage pollution control plan.
Save the Alewife Brook Steering Committee members were psyched to meet at DEP HQ along with other river advocates from the Mystic River and Charles River Watershed Associations. Also present were folks from Cambridge, Somerville, and the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority.
What we talked about:
* Sewage Flooding in the Alewife Path. * Sewage Flooding in people’s homes. * Sewage Flooding that made people sick. * A solar powered on-site sewage warning system with colored beacon lights. * The need to improve conditions in the Brook now, before the new sewage pollution control plan goes into effect.
We were so grateful for the opportunity to meet with MassDEP. Thank you, MassDEP!
And we have some great news to share:
MassDEP has agreed to hold a special public hearing in early April for the Alewife.
You will be invited to come to that hearing and speak out for Alewife Brook.
The Brook needs you there, so MassDEP will continue to see that many people support ending the dumping of raw sewage in the Brook. Please plan to join us.
There is power in numbers! Stay tuned for details about the upcoming hearing.
Join us on Saturday morning, April 13th, for an Early Earth Day Alewife Greenway Path Clean-Up and CSO Tour. We will gather trash along the path next to the brook. While we’re there, we’ll provide a tour of the Combined Sewer Outfalls and the Concrete Sewage Death Channel.
We’ll discuss what we’re doing together, to make Alewife Brook fishable, boatable, and safe, for the enjoyment of all.
Zach Crowley, David White, Steven Nutter, Gwen Speeth, Brian Arrigo, Gene Benson, David Stoff in front of the flooded-out Alewife Greenway path. Photo credit: Kristin Anderson
DEPARTMENT OF CONSERVATION & RECREATION, SAVE THE ALEWIFE BROOK, & GREEN CAMBRIDGE Take A Tour of Alewife Sewage Pollution, Flooding, & Inequity
A Perfectly Stormy Day
A storm rolled up the eastern seaboard and into Boston on Monday, December 18, 2023. This was the day of our Alewife Tour with the new Commissioner of the Department of Conservation & Recreation, Brian Arrigo, and his Deputy Commissioner for Policy, Public Affairs, and Administration, Zach Crowley. The state-owned parkland along the Alewife Brook is managed by DCR, which is why we were so excited about meeting the new DCR Commissioner.
The weather made this an epic meeting, and a remarkable opportunity to offer DCR Commissioner Arrigo a “boots-on-the-ground” view of the flooding and sewage pollution problems of the Alewife, through the lenses of Climate Change and Equity.
We might have canceled the walking tour of the Alewife Combined Sewer Overflows, except the wind was dying down and we are rugged New Englanders, up for an adventure no matter the weather. Besides, it was a warm 60 degrees out and what’s a little rain?
What’s a Little Rain?
A little rain in the Alewife, even less than an inch of hard rain, can result in discharges of untreated sewage pollution into the brook. This storm was not so little. According to the official Boston storm report, rainfall totaled about 3.5”. This resulted in an estimated 1.2 million gallons or more1 of raw CSO sewage pollution into the Alewife Brook.
First Stop: The Hungry Great Blue Heron
Our hike began at Broadway and Route 16 (Alewife Brook Parkway). The Alewife Reservation greeted us with hard rain and a chance encounter with a gorgeous Great Blue Heron, long legs submerged, hanging out at the water’s edge. Looking lean and hungry, feathers unfluffed by the rain, our heron friend may have been wondering why there were no fish. The answer was just upstream.
Follow Your Nose to Somerville’s Tannery Brook CSO
The smell of sewage was noticeable as we walked northward towards Somerville’s Tannery Brook Combined Sewer Outfall (aka SOM001A.) Raw sewage from Davis Square had been discharging from the Tannery Brook CSO an hour prior. Toilet paper from a previous storm was hanging in the trees – a violation of minimum control measures required for compliance with Somerville’s NPDES permit.2
Somerville’s Tannery Brook outfall is the Alewife’s worst CSO. It is out of compliance, which is to say that it does not meet the goals set forth twenty years ago by the federal court, as part of the Boston Harbor Cleanup Court Case. 3
Third Stop: Sewage Flooding the Alewife Greenway
We followed the DCR Alewife Greenway Path towards the MBTA Alewife T station, past two more CSOs, flanking both sides of the Mass Ave bridge at Route 16. One of these CSOs had been discharging sewage during the storm, but we could not see the outfall because the water level was so high.
Soon the path became impassable. The brook overtopped its banks, completely covering the Greenway and sending sewage water all the way up to Boulevard Road.
At this point, we had not received CSO notifications from Cambridge, Somerville, or MWRA. But if the brook overflows its bank, we suspect that there is untreated sewage in the water.
Last Stop: Flooded-Out Homeless Encampment
We continued the hike towards Cambridge’s worst Alewife CSO, CAM401A. This CSO is located behind the Alewife T parking garage. It had been dumping raw sewage pollution into the brook before we arrived. On the other side of the brook, just feet from this CSO, we saw a flooded-out, abandoned homeless encampment on MBTA property. The scene was terribly depressing and apocalyptic. You have to watch the video below to believe it. There had been people living next to this Alewife CSO! What an unbelievable situation in one of the wealthiest cities in the United States.
The wooded area around Massachusetts Water Resources Authority’s Alewife CSO is another spot where folks who are lacking housing camp out.
These are the places that people go when they have nowhere else. And they are not safe places to be.
Needed: Concern, Determination, & Grit
Our new DCR Commissioner hiked with us for over two hours, in the wind and rain, to see sewage discharges and flooding because he wants to understand our perspective of the Alewife Reservation. This level of concern, determination, and grit is exactly what the Alewife Brook Reservation needs from the Commonwealth now.
Arrigo Announces $28 Million for Dam in the Mystic
In his first act for the Alewife, Commissioner Arrigo just announced a $28 million dollar investment to make Climate Resiliency improvements at the Amelia Earhart Dam and the Draw Seven Park, to protect a number of cities and towns in future storms from coastal storm surge flooding. This protection includes the Alewife.
We are grateful that the Healey Administration has chosen Brian Arrigo to head the Department of Conservation and Recreation and hope that the Commonwealth will work to make the Alewife Brook area a safe place to live for humans and wildlife.
Thank you to the over 200 supporters for coming out against sewage pollution at the November 15th CSO Meeting #3.
Many Somerville supporters came out! Cambridge was there! Arlington showed up! Folks from Belmont and Medford and Winchester were there! There is power in numbers and over 300 supporters registered for this meeting. Thank you.
Residents of Somerville and Cambridge care deeply about the Alewife Brook and want the sewage pollution to end. This is a regional issue that doesn’t end at the cities’ municipal borders.
MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville presented options they are considering for CSO control but there are no specific proposals yet. However, it is clear that Cambridge needs to finish their sewer separation work. And Somerville needs to be more aggressive about sewer separation work in the Alewife sewershed.
Cambridge has been doing amazing Climate Change research with Dr. Indrani Ghosh. Dr. Ghosh’s work shows more future rain, and a predicted increase of two to four times as much Alewife Brook CSO sewage pollution by 2050. And we will see drought years, as well as rainy years. The Brook smells really bad during drought conditions, when the CSO sediment is exposed to open air.
It is so important that Climate Change is being considered in the planning. We deeply appreciate that EPA required that.
Save the Alewife Brook and the Charles River Watershed Association made it clear that we want the planners to include larger storms in their Future Typical Year modeling. This could result in less sewage pollution.
MWRA CAN FIX THE PROBLEM!
Massachusetts Water Resources Authority’s representative Jeremy Hall proposed several effective approaches to addressing the Alewife CSOs. Mr. Hall stated that the most aggressive approach to the CSO problem is what they call “conveyance.”
Conveyance is system pipe and facilities upgrades and improvements. This would help address the fact that the MWRA’s regional sewer system is already failing to meet capacity. It will need to be upgraded to meet future demands. The state needs to start planning NOW for the future! The densely populated and flood-prone Alewife neighborhoods should not be used as an open sewer just because MWRA wants to save money.
Jeremy Hall also presented the CSOstorage option and used the Union Park CSO Detention and Treatment Facility as an example. The Union Park storage tank exists on a 1.3 acre site. It includes a CSO treatment facility and a 2.2 million gallon CSO storage tank. And it is situated right next to an MWRA pump station. Similarly, the Alewife’s Dilboy Park is located next to the MWRA’s Alewife Brook Pump Station. Dilboy Park is 22.65 acres and is located on State land.
A BOLD GREEN STORMWATER INFRASTRUCTURE PLAN!
The Charles River Watershed Association and Somerville Environmentalists successfully rallied for a more bold Green Stormwater Infrastructure plan to reduce flooding and sewage pollution, along with all of the community benefits of GSI.
MYSTIC RIVER WATERSHED ASSOCIATION ASKS FOR COMPLETE CSO ELIMINATION!
Patrick Herron, Director of MyRWA, closed the meeting by asking that the planners set a goal of CSO elimination.
Addendum & Planning timeline
The Massachusetts Legislature created the MWRA in 1984 to manage and modernize the Boston metropolitan area water and sewer system, for the preservation and improvement of the health, welfare and living conditions of the citizenry. The MWRA has done wonderful work for Boston Harbor, but has completely failed in the Alewife sub-watershed. Because the Alewife has been neglected for so long, it will require additional investment and effort to fix the problem.
Be prepared to hear excuses about why Massachusetts Water Resources Authority, Somerville, and Cambridge can’t fix the problem of untreated sewage pollution and flooding in Alewife Brook.
Cost.
MWRA is going to threaten us with the cost of fixing the Combined Sewer Overflows. Will it be expensive? Yes. But there exists once-in-a-lifetime Federal Infrastructure funding for CSO control! MWRA should apply for some of that Federal Infrastructure money, now.
Equity.
We need an equitable tiered-rate system for our water bills to help pay for solutions, so folks who can’t afford to pay won’t have to. Clean water is a human right! The MWRA needs to stop making struggling folks pay for their hazardous pollution – they can’t afford it and exposure to untreated sewage is making people sick. We should not have to walk through untreated sewage to get to the T on rainy days!
No More Flooding & Sewage Pollution.
They are going to threaten us with more flooding and sewage backups in our basements in the streets if the CSOs are closed. But it’s not true if they fix the problem!
A Holistic, Systemic Approach.
The CSOs in the Alewife are part of a system. They’re connected. Cambridge, Somerville, and MWRA must work together.
MWRA’s regional sewer system is too small for the volume it needs to handle, due to increased wastewater from development and increased precipitation from Climate Change.
Somerville is not in compliance with the Clean Water Actand they are not in compliance with their Variance Permit. Somerville needs to take bold action to solve the problem of untreated sewage pollution in the Alewife Brook because their CSO is the worst of all six.
Cambridge must finish their good work to complete their Alewife watershed sewer separation, add Green Stormwater Infrastructure, and reduce flooding.
The Solution.
Separate the sewer systems to keep sewage out of stormwater.
Grey Stormwater Infrastructure – a CSO treatment facility for the Alewife to eliminate untreated sewage discharges, underground CSO storage tanks to collect combined sewage, and regional sewer system upgrades.
Green Stormwater Infrastructure to retain rainwater and not waste it. Rainwater should be used to help plants to grow, reduce heat islands, improve air and water quality, and improve community health.
The Alewife Brook has the largest volumes of untreated combined sewage pollution discharges in the Greater Boston area. It is flood-prone and runs through densely populated neighborhoods, with 5,000 people in its 100-year flood plain, in multiple Environmental Justice communities. EPA’s EJ Screener rates the Alewife in the 90th percentile for wastewater impacts nationwide.
Our Secret 3-Point Meeting Strategy
1. DEMAND THAT SOMERVILLE COMPLIES WITH THE CLEAN WATER ACT!
Somerville is not in compliance with the Clean Water Act and its permit for sewage discharges into Alewife Brook.The city must end the harm it is doing to Environmental Justice communities that are affected by contaminated sewage pollution from Davis Square.
Somerville violates the Clean Water Act in three ways:
The city failed to meet the level of CSO control required by the Federal court;
the “Typical Year” discharge is in excess of the volume and frequency authorized by the variance;
Somerville’s Engineering Department failed to keep monthly maintenance reports for the Tannery Brook SOM001A CSO (sewage from Davis Square). This is a permit violation.
2. MWRA MUST UPGRADE ITS SEWER SYSTEM AND PROVIDE A TREATMENT FACILITY FOR ALEWIFE BROOK!
During many storms, the MWRA’s sewer system is too small to handle the flow to the wastewater treatment plant at Deer Island. As a result, raw sewage is being discharged to Alewife Brook. The MWRA must invest in upgrading sewer infrastructure to protect Environmental Justice communities from harmful untreated sewage bacteria which is making people around the Alewife sick.
3. CAMBRIDGE MUST COMPLETE SEWER SEPARATION IN THE ALEWIFE WATERSHED!
Cambridge must finish the job they started 30 years ago! Separated sewer pipes join combined sewers just before the flow hits the Alewife CSOs, meaning millions of gallons of sewage from massive new development is getting dumped in the brook. Cambridge is one of the wealthiest cities in America, yet the city sends untreated sewage pollution to flood the parks, yards, and homes of their Environmental Justice Community neighbors.
Please join us on Sunday, November 5th at 7 pm to discuss the new Alewife Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) Control Plan. The third public CSO planning meeting will be November 15th. We are very excited to strategize about it with you!
What would you like to see in the new Alewife sewage pollution control plan?
An end to untreated sewage pollution!
Less flooding!
Combined sewer separation!
Green stormwater infrastructure including: constructed wetlands, rain gardens, bioswales, & tree trenches!
Removal of illegal sewer hook-ups and replacement of broken sewer pipes that allow groundwater in!
CSO storage, as in underground CSO holding tanks!
A local Alewife CSO treatment facility!
Improved conveyance, meaning increasing the capacity of MWRA’s sewer pipes and pump stations, which aren’t big enough even to handle current storms… as well as adding a second sewage treatment plant in the Boston area!
Bring your ideas to our meeting this Sunday, and help us to strategize in advance of the next big CSO planning meeting on November 15th!
Alewife Sewage Pollution Control Public Meeting #3 Wednesday, November 15th at 6 pm Zoom REGISTER HERE
Please. We really need you to come to this important meeting. The EPA and Mass DEP are listening! Your voice matters.
Add event to calendar
The EPA and DEP are listening.
Demand an End to Untreated Sewage Pollution! Less flooding! A safe and healthy environment for all animals, including humans!
Sewage Pollution Control Plan Options Include A Combination of These:
Combined sewer separation.
Green stormwater infrastructure including: constructed wetlands, rain gardens, bioswales, & tree trenches.
Removal of illegal sewer hook-ups and replacement of broken sewer pipes that allow groundwater into the sewer system.
Storage, as in underground CSO holding tanks.
A local Alewife CSO treatment facility.
Improved conveyance, meaning increasing the capacity of the MWRA’s sewer pipes and pump stations, which aren’t big enough even to handle current storms… and adding a second sewage treatment plant in the Boston area!
Support House Bill 886 ~ An Act Relative to Combined Sewer Overflows A Sensible, Achievable, and Necessary Response to Raw Sewage Being Dumped into our Waterways through Combined Sewer Outfalls
Register to speak about the second to last bill, H.886. The deadline to register to testify, either in person or virtually, is Monday, October 23rd at noon. So please register right now!
Come to the hearing, either in person or online! When it’s your turn to speak, please say that you want the committee immediately to issue a favorable report on H.886, and express your concerns that CSOs are contaminating Alewife Brook. If you have a personal story, those are most compelling. You will have only three minutes to speak, so you’ll need to be concise.
We need state legislation to end sewage being dumped in our waterways because MWRA has told us it has no intention of going beyond the bare minimum federal law requires them to do.
H.886 is realistic, outcome-oriented, and consistent with current technologies and procedures:
Recognizing that some CSOs may need to discharge in large storms to prevent sewer backups for some time, this legislation requires that, in 10 years, each of the CSOs then in the MWRA sewer service area either:
1. Have the treatment across the system now provided at only five CSOs;
or
2. Ensure that CSOs only activate during 25+year storms, and not during smaller storms (five CSOs along Dorchester Bay already have 25-year level of control)
For more information about this legislation, watch the public CSO briefing for legislators (organized by the Charles and Mystic River Watershed Associations), on October 19th:
at 11 am gather at the Day Street Parking Lot in Davis Square, Somerville ending in Harvard Square, Cambridge, at around 1:30 pm
Parade with Save the Alewife Brook, musicians, and puppeteers. Join us, to demand a safe, clean, and restored brook, for all species who live in and around the Alewife Brook.
Governor Maura Healey’s first budget includes $100,000 for the Alewife Brook. Funding will go through Mystic River Watershed Association for a hydraulic and dredging study.
Construction of the Alewife channel with a crane dredge, circa 1909. From the Department of Conservation and Recreation, courtesy Massachusetts State Archives.
Why do we need a study of the brook?
A dredging and hydraulic study is needed to find solutions to the problems of flooding and poor water quality in the Alewife Brook. It is the first step needed to attract State and Federal Funding to address these problems.
In 2022, the EPA wrote to MWRA, asking the agency to work with the Department of Conservation and Recreation to remove sediment from the brook. According to EPA: “the channelized nature of Alewife Brook, as well as the amount of sediment in the Alewife constructed channel, takes up flood storage capacity.”
Currently, water quality remains poor even on dry weather days when a lack of CSO and stormwater discharges should mean better water quality. Dredging sediment would improve water quality by removing contaminants and reducing bacterial counts in the water on dry weather days.
Thanks to our Awesome Alewife Lawmakers!
Dave Rogers, 24th Middlesex (East Arlington & North Cambridge)
Dave Rogers, his Chief of Staff Kira Arnott, and his Aide George Armstrong worked with Save the Alewife Brook and Mystic River Watershed Association to craft the Alewife Brook budget amendment.
Representatives Sean Garballey (Arlington) and Christine Barber (Somerville) co-sponsored the request in the House Budget. Senator Pat Jehlen (Cambridge & Somerville) submitted it for the Senate Budget. We also want to thank Alewife area Senators Cindy Friedman (Arlington) and Will Brownsberger (Belmont) for supporting funding for the Alewife.
Thank YOU & thanks to EPA!
Honestly, this wouldn’t have happened without EPA’s recommendation and without your interest in a safe and healthy Alewife Brook. Thanks everybody!
Plans for dredging and removal of Alewife Brook concrete channel, page 43 of the MDC 2003 Alewife Master Plan Courtesy Massachusetts State Archives
Michele Barden EPA Region 1 5 Post Office Square, Suite 100 (06-1) Boston, MA 02109
RE: NPDES MA0103284, Part I. B. 2. b.(8)
You can’t dump untreated sewage into Alewife Brook without telling us. There are too many of us living too close to it.
The Alewife Greenway/Bike path is a vital community transportation corridor. The Alewife Brook flooded over its bank and into the path after the downpour on August 8th, 2023.
No one using the path knew that millions of gallons of untreated sewage had been discharged into the water they were walking, jogging, and pushing baby carriages through.
The existing public Combined Sewer Overflow notification system is a failure.
People using the Alewife Greenway path need to know whether a particular CSO is discharging. They need to know immediately if the discharge has made using the Alewife path unsafe. They also need to know when an elevated level of risk has passed.
Technology has matured enough to allow an enhanced public notification system that operates in real-time. As an example, CSO Event Indicator Lights are required on the Potomac River [1].
A similar system should be required along the Alewife.
Our experience is that Massachusetts’ Sewage Notification Law is inadequate to protect us. EPA must expand on the public notification requirements in the Draft Permit to offer our community real protection.
[1] NPDES Permit No. DC002l 199 Part B, Sec.III, (h) Public Notification (1)
Sewage-contaminated Alewife Greenway. Shot at 3 pm on August 8th, 2023 by David Stoff.
This is not Alewife Brook – it’s the Alewife Greenway under sewage flood water!
The public has a legal right to know when hazardous, untreated sewage is discharged into Alewife Brook because it is a serious health risk, especially during flood events. But residents are not informed. On Tuesday, August 8th, 2023, folks had no idea they were walking through water on the Alewife Greenway path that was contaminated with hazardous human and industrial waste.
The Sewage Pollution Notification System is NOT working.
Neighbors using the Alewife Greenway pushed baby carriages through untreated sewage water.
What Happened?
It rained fast and furiously on Tuesday, August 8th. We witnessed an intense burst of heavy downpours. Arlington Conservation Commissioner David White measured 2 1/2” of rain in 2 hours at his house. Many local streets were flooded. This type of storm is becoming the new normal due to Climate Change.
Cambridge, Somerville, and Massachusetts Water Resource Authority’s inadequate combined sewer systems were quickly overwhelmed by stormwater and dumped millions of gallons of untreated human sewage into the Alewife Brook. The brook overflowed its banks and flooded the Alewife Greenway, a popular transportation corridor that runs through multiple Environmental Justice Community neighborhoods.
Neighbors, unaware of the sewage discharge, jogged, pushed baby carriages, and rode bikes through the contaminated water.
The law is being abused.
Although state and federal law requires that the public be notified when sewage is dumped into the brook, the existing warning system failed. Residents were not notified in a way that prevented their exposure to untreated sewage.
Our neighbors had no idea that millions of gallons of untreated sewage had been dumped 500 feet upstream of the water they were wading through.
The Massachusetts Sewage Notification law requires local Boards of Health to post Public Health advisories after being notified of a sewage discharge. A physical sign must be posted to warn the community. By 1:00 PM Tuesday, public email discharge notifications from MWRA and local sewer operators had been issued. Yet there was no warning posted.
Public Health Advisory.
Where’s the required Public Health Advisory? The answer is: nowhere. State regulators are not enforcing the law.
There are overlapping State and Federal Public Notification requirements. In addition to the State law, the National Pollution Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit for the Alewife sewers also requires that the public be notified when sewers overflow.
The public must be provided with same-day, on-site notice of sewage discharges. This is standard practice elsewhere and should be afforded to our community.
Our neighbors deserve to know!
Out of frustration Save the Alewife Brook’s David Stoff posted this sign to warn neighbors about the sewage.
he State of Massachusetts, through its agency the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority, unfairly uses Alewife Brook poor water quality to justify not spending money to end sewage pollution.
How does this make any sense? Well, it doesn’t. So here’s an analogy which might help the reader to better understand the MWRA’s poor thinking on the matter:
Imagine that it’s a rainy day and the city of Cambridge is driving a car on Route 16. Cambridge comes to the stop light at Mass Ave, rolls down the window, and throws a bag of stinky diapers onto the side of the parkway. MWRA is driving in a car behind them, sees Cambridge’s pollution and thinks, “Hey, why should I pay to properly dispose of my stinky adult diapers when I can just toss them out the window? There’s already some pollution here!”
This is how the Alewife Brook’s poor water quality has been weaponized by the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority. The MWRA’s spurious argument against investment in improving public health conditions in the Alewife has been that the Brook is polluted and eliminating untreated sewage pollution will not yield a great enough improvement in water quality.
The Alewife Brook Concrete Open Overflow Sewer. Photo courtesy of MWRA.
Contaminated Sediments accumulate and compound the problem over time.
Stormwater Runoff
Stormwater Runoff includes fertilizer, oil, pesticides, bacteria and other pollutants.
The major causes of poor water quality in Alewife Brook are combined sewer discharges (which contain untreated sewage), stormwater runoff, stormwater outfalls (which may also contain sewage), and accumulating contaminated sediments. The sediment contamination comes from sewage, stormwater, and discharges from local industry. It accumulates in the Alewife Brook’s concrete channel, and compounds the problem over time. Further upstream, pollution from Belmont flows from Winn Brook to Little River to Alewife Brook.
These factors all contribute to poor water quality, but their relative importance is not clearly understood. Some observations can be found in the MWRA water quality report of 2014.1 Figure 4-9 of that report shows that the CSO and stormwater control work performed from 1989-1991 and from 2000-2014 has significantly reduced E. coli counts in all conditions, especially in heavy rain.2 But on average, wet weather level counts are about ten times those of drier conditions. Dry weather counts are down some but are still above the violation threshold. It does not appear that stormwater is the only problem, rather that it is more complicated, and improvements are needed in many areas.
3
Solutions to Improve Alewife Brook Water Quality
Sewer Separation
The cities of Cambridge and especially Somerville need an aggressive plan to separate stormwater from sewage.
Virtual Elimination of CSOs (25-year Level of Control) or a CSO Treatment Facility
The MWRA needs to come up with a plan to achieve what they call “Virtual Elimination of CSOs”, using alternatives including underground stormwater storage tanks on State land. Alternatively, the MWRA could build a CSO treatment facility for the Alewife CSOs to treat the sewage before it is discharged into the brook.
Green Stormwater Infrastructure
The cities of Cambridge and Somerville, the Department of Conservation and Recreation, and the Department of Transportation, need to use GSI to biologically improve stormwater water quality before it enters the brook.
Dredging, Dechannelization, Bank Restoration
In 2022, the EPA wrote to MWRA, asking the agency to work with the Department of Conservation and Recreation to remove sediment from the brook. Currently, water quality remains poor even on dry weather days when a lack of CSO and stormwater discharges should mean better water quality. Dredging sediment would improve water quality by removing contaminants and reducing bacterial counts in the water on dry weather days.
Because the Alewife is such a small and slow-moving river, nothing more than a narrow concrete channel in some places, it has accumulated several feet of CSO-contaminated sediment. During most conditions, the sediment lies beneath a foot of water. During last summer’s drought, however, there were only a couple of inches of water above the sediment in places, and the stench was unbearable. High bacterial counts likely exist because the sediment contributes to the poor water quality.4
Alewife Brook dechannelization and restoration sketch from the Department of Conservation and Recreation’s 2003 Alewife Master Plan.
Footnotes
1 “Summary of CSO Receiving Water Quality Monitoring in Upper Mystic River/Alewife Brook and Charles River, 2014”, MWRA Report 2015-06. https://www.mwra.com/harbor/enquad/pdf/2015-06.pdf 2 Note that the vertical graph scale is logarithmic with each marker being ten times greater than the one below it. 3 The dotted line shows the state geometrical mean standard for recreation of 33 counts/100 ml.The state single sample limit is 235 counts/100ml. It is that later standard that is used in determining the water quality grades. 4 Ibid.
On May 17th, students from Cambridge’s Fayerweather Street School rallied to end the sewage pollution that is destroying our environment. They marched from their school to the Alewife Brook, where the 3rd & 4th Grade students leading the year-long watershed project had installed an educational public art exhibit.
Students also wrote letters to state legislators asking for their support of pending CSO bill House.886, and Representative Steve Owens was at Fayerweather to hear the speeches and singing, which preceded the students’ march to the river.
Photos courtesy of the Fayerweather School
Students Produced Powerful Messages
The signs that students carried on their march said:
Be the Solution, Not the Pollution!
This Stinks, Literally!
Stop the Sewage!
Fight for the Fish!
Save the Alewife Brook!
Make the River Clean Again!
Make the World a Better Place!
No More Sewage in the Alewife Brook!
Students Created Educational Environmental Art
The students installed an art exhibit near Cambridge’s worst Combined Sewer Outfall, CAM401A, behind the Alewife T parking garage. This space is owned by Green Cambridge, who generously offered it to the Fayerweather Street School for their inspiring project.
Thank you, Fayerweather Students!
Following the Fayerweather Street School’s March and Art Installation, Save the Alewife Brook has received many new signatures for our Petition to End Sewage Pollution.
On Saturday, April 22, 2023, Save the Alewife Brook volunteers met for an Earth Day Clean-up and environmental tour. We collected trash near three of the Alewife’s Combined Sewer Outfalls.
The event began with a reading of Governor Maura Healey’s message to the volunteers. We distributed t-shirts and Kolsvart Swedish Fish. We then began the clean-up at Cambridge’s CAM401A, which is one of the worst sewage-spewing CSOs in the Alewife. It is located behind the deteriorating MBTA parking garage.
In 2021, the CAM401A CSO discharged over 21 million gallons of untreated sewage pollution into Alewife Brook. We stopped for a moment to reflect on this. Greg Harris from Green Cambridgeand Friends of the Alewife Reservation was one of the Earth Day volunteers. He talked about the potential for replacing the deteriorating parking garage with Green Stormwater Infrastructure. There could be a stormwater wetlands there! A stormwater wetlands would clean and slow down stormwater during large storm events.
We proceeded to clean up trash in the area and on the other side of the path over by MWR003, the MWRA’s Alewife CSO. In 2021, the MWRA discharged over 6 million gallons of untreated sewage pollution from that CSO. Here we met Rene Morin from Department of Conservation & Recreation. Rene was there to make sure we had a great Earth Day / DCR Park Serve Day and dispose of the trash we collected, including any hazardous materials. Sadly we needed his sharps container for the multiple syringes we found in the area.
Guess what we found on Earth Day!
Volunteers found a discarded bra!
We then walked north along the Alewife Greenway towards Mass Ave, picking up trash along the path in Arlington. BABAM (Boston Area Brigade of Activist Musicians) marched up the path with us, playing protest songs.
GHOST FISH & BABAM
BABAM crossed the brook with us to Cambridge and played, while we picked up trash over by David Stoff’s GHOST FISH art installation.
It was a wonderful event – we made new friends! And Rene Morin from DCRhauled away two big truckloads of trash... and quite a few syringes that he picked up!
Thanks to the Volunteers!
Alex Simmons * Ann McDonald * Annie Thompson * Audrey Bennett * Beth Melofchik * Betty Widerski * Bob Tosi * Brian McBride * Claire Odom * Clare Nosowitz * Cody Casanave * Courtney Gurll * Daniel O’shaughnessy * David Stoff * Ed De Moel * Elizabeth Burke * Erin McLaughlin * Gene Benson * Greg Harris * Gwen Speeth * Harvey Fenigsohn * Ian Forsythe * Imanuela Costiner * Jennifer Ingram * Jessica Kinner * Joel Snider * Judy Lyons * Kate Schell * Kristin Anderson * Lida Junghans * Lizzie Linn Casanave * Luchy Roa * Maeve Whitty * Mark Jewell * Mark Paglierani * Marsha Turin * Meredith DiMola & Family * Michael Cerone * Michael Everman * Peter Frumhoff * Rebecca Behizadeh * Robin Johnson * Ruth Loetterle * Samantha Barth * Sara Billingsley * Shaina Blitt * Steve Forrest * Sumita Austen * Suzanne McLeod * Toby Karlsson * Vincent Baudoin & Family * Zach Forrest * Zoe Simmons
Thanks to the band!
BABAM (Boston Area Brigade of Activist Musicians)
Special Thanks to Department of Conservation & Recreation!
Matthew Perry for helping to set up the Alewife Park Serve Day and to Rene Morin, who removed two DCR truckloads of trash!
Save the Alewife Brook Steering Committee Members:
Gwen Speeth, David Stoff, Gene Benson, Kristin Anderson, David White
The Massachusetts Water Resources Authority, Cambridge, and Somerville have done it again, issuing a new press release about “progress” made in the Alewife Brook through their Sewage Pollution Control Plan. There’s been no progress for the Alewife! The untreated sewage pollution in the Alewife Brook has gotten worse, not better. And unless MWRA increases the capacity of its undersized regional sewer system, the problem of dumping untreated sewage into the Alewife will only get worse with climate change.
In their new press release, MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville continue to put forward the bizarre idea that because the Alewife Brook is already polluted, they should not have to stop dumping sewage in it1. The truth is that, over the decades, the brook has become badly polluted because its narrow concrete channel has accumulated more thanhalf a million cubic feet of CSO sediment containing human and industrial waste, including PCBs, PAHs, and heavy metals. The presence of this trapped sediment is one reason why water quality in the Alewife Brook can be awful even during dry periods when the MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville are not dumping untreated sewage there.
MWRA Unfairly Allows Too Much Untreated Sewage Pollution in Alewife Brook
The Alewife Brook is a tiny waterbody in comparison to the Boston Harbor, and the Charles & Mystic Rivers (which, by the way, MWRA also pollutes with nasty sewage!). Still, at least most of the Harbor and River sewage discharge is treated. 100% of the sewage dumped in the Alewife Brook by MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville is untreated. Compared to the rest of their system, MWRA unfairly allows too much untreated sewage pollution to be dumped into the Alewife Brook.
EPA Provided Guidance to MWRA in 2022
The Federal Environmental Protection Agency has already provided MWRA with guidance. But, according to their new press release, it appears that MWRA is not listening!
Provide real public participation in the early stages of planning and throughout.
Improve water quality.
Implement flood control measures.
Dredge and remove the Alewife Brook concrete sewage channel, which currently exacerbates area flooding.
Implement significant gray and green infrastructure work on DCR property, including at Dilboy Park.
Create an equitable funding structure so the costs do not fall upon lower income residents who cannot afford it.
Examine which MWRA sewer facilities are nearing the end of their life cycle and take advantage of opportunities for expansion of sewer system capacity.
Provide major upgrades to the MWRA regional system, including a new pump station, possible expansion or rebuilding of the Caruso Pump Station, the key connection point for the MWRA North System.
Consider the Environmental Justice communities along Alewife Brook and protect them from flooding.
MWRA Should Provide Economically Achievable CSO Elimination
If they cannot provide a “25-year level of control”2 of their sewage pollution, MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville should provide CSO treatment for the Alewife. That is the solution set forth in House Bill 886, filed by Representatives Dave Rogers and Adrian Madaro. We are staunch supporters of that legislation. It requires that, within ten years, CSOs must have treatment (which already exists for other water bodies) or stop dumping, except in very large, >25-year storms (as has been engineered elsewhere by MWRA).
It’s time for MWRA to step up and do the job for which it was created. For the Alewife, MWRA needs finally to fulfill its mandated goal of acting for“the preservation and improvement of the health, welfare and living conditions of the citizenry.”Cambridge and Somerville, for their part, need to deliver an ambitious plan to separate their sewers, reduce area flooding, and improve water quality.
Footnotes
There may be people at MWRA who understand the real situation, but its press release does not show that.
“25 year level of control” is what MWRA calls “economically achievable CSO elimination”. MWRA provided this level of CSO control to the recreational beaches in Dorchester Bay. See page 5, MWRA CSO Post Construction Compliance Monitoring Program.
Cambridge, Somerville, and the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority dump hazardous untreated sewage into the flood-prone Alewife Brook. Our federal and state governments have the authority to stop this dumping of pollution, yet they have allowed it to continue for decades. The brook is owned by the state*, so we need the state to work with us as a partner in funding and implementing solutions to protect and restore the brook.
That is why we are excited to announce the filing of two new state budget amendments requesting funding for the brook: Dredging and Flood Mitigation Study (#1019) & Update to theAlewife Reservation Master Plan (#1020). Thanks go out to wicked awesome Representatives Dave Rogers, Sean Garballey, & Christine Barber for filing these funding requests. Thanks also to Dave’s fabulous aides Kira Arnott & George Armstrong for their hard work and support.
Alewife Brook Concrete Sewage Channel has accumulated three feet of hazardous CSO sediment. The CSO sediment contains poop, PCBs, PAHs, & heavy metals. Photo courtesy of MWRA
* For clarification: The state owns the land beneath the Alewife Brook. But the water in the brook belongs to the people of the Commonwealth, held in trust by our government.
Alewife Brook, which borders Arlington, Cambridge, and Somerville, regularly overflows its banks, inundating residential areas that are home to multiple environmental justice communities. Untreated human and industrial waste discharged into the brook from combined sewer overflows exacerbates the public health threat from flooding. Climate change is making this situation worse. EPA recommends that Alewife Brook be dredged and its concrete channel removed to increase stormwater capacity and decrease surface flooding. Modeling and analysis of current hydraulic conditions is the required first step, urged by flood mitigation and river restoration experts. The hydraulic study will identify the specific actions needed to protect affected communities from sewage-contaminated flooding, providing the information required to secure federal and state funds for implementation of the measures identified. Given the protected wetland landscape, sediment depths, and storm water and sewage inflows, an acceptable study will cost at least $150,000 according to the multiple experts consulted. Funding would go to the Mystic River Watershed Association, which has a long history of work in the area.
Plans for Removal of Alewife Brook Concrete Channel, page 43 MDC 2003 Alewife Master Plan Courtesy Massachusetts State Archives
Twenty years ago, the MDC released the Alewife Reservation & Alewife Brook Master Plan, intended to improve the MDC-owned reservation and brook corridor. It envisioned restoring habitat, improving hydrological function, enhancing recreational and educational opportunities, and improving connections to other natural areas. Since then, a greenway and stormwater wetland were constructed, but climate change and widespread development have exacerbated both flooding and combined sewer overflow discharges of sewage into the brook. It is time to update the Master Plan to assess and reprioritize recommended projects based on current conditions. The update should result in Green Stormwater Infrastructure and Indigenous historical signage. Preliminary cost estimates for selected projects will allow DCR and the advocacy groups active in the Alewife area to secure funding to implement the improvements needed to protect and maintain this popular open space for the residents who live near the brook, those who depend on the park for recreation, and the thousands who commute through it daily, including multiple densely populated Environmental Justice Communities.
Plans for Removal of Alewife Brook Concrete Channel, page 42 MDC 2003 Alewife Master Plan Courtesy Massachusetts State Archives
The Rindge Ave Greenway Plan Proposed by Friends of Jerry’s Pond
Music * Bangladeshi Dance * Food * Arts & Crafts * Native American Fish Weir * Activities for Kids & Adults!
Meet your neighbors to celebrate the planned reopening of Jerry’s Pond! Meet members of the IQHQ team and community groups. Make art, see Audubon’s animals, remove invasives, weed native gardens, clean around pond.
Meet at Russell Field Parking Area 1:30-2:00 Music, Food & Art 2:00-2:30 Bangladeshi Dancing, Gathering & Intros 2:30-4:30 Projects & Activities 4:30-5:00 Back to Parking Area & Wrap Up
Sponsored by: Friends of Jerry’s Pond facebook.com/jerryspond Cosponsors: Mayor Sumbul Siddiqui, IQHQ, Mass Audubon Society, Green Cambridge, Mothers Out Front, Just-A-Start Inc., Devine Native Plantings, History Cambridge, Many Helping Hands 365, North Cambridge Arts, Cambridge City Growers, Highlands-Quad Neighborhood Association, Fresh Pond Residents Alliance, Save the Alewife Brook, Alewife Study Group
Join us Saturday morning, April 22nd, for an Earth Day Alewife Greenway Path Clean-Up and CSO Tour! We’ll be working to gather trash along the path next to the brook. While we’re there, we will provide a tour of the Concrete Sewage Death Channel and the CSOs. Come see GHOST FISH art and listen to Babam the brass band!
Free Save the Alewife Brook t-shirts for people who sign up for the clean-up, while supplies last.
Bring gloves, water, & garbage picker, if you have one. We’ll provide bags.
Exciting news! New state legislation, HD3316, has been filed that would greatly improve water quality in the rivers and streams throughout the Boston area as shown on this map. It would limit the dumping of untreated sewage pollution and potentially leading to the building of new treatment facilities.
This legislation would bring the same level of sewage pollution reduction in the Alewife that is afforded along the bay in Boston Harbor, which makes recreational swimming possible on Boston beaches. This is something that the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority and the cities can do, and this legislation gives them ten years to accomplish this for the Alewife Brook.
Huge thanks go out to Representatives Dave Rogers and Adrian Madaro for introducing this legislation and to Representative Sean Garballey, for co-sponsoring!
Dave Rogers Adrian Madaro Sean Garballey
We’d also like to thank the Arlington Select Board for supporting this legislation. Co-Chair Diane Mahon, in particular, deserves our gratitude for her continued leadership on this issue.
Diane Mahon
A Huge Improvement for the Alewife Brook!
If it passes, this law would eliminate untreated discharges from CSOs except in larger storm events – meaning 25-year storms or larger. That would be a huge improvement for the Alewife Brook! To make sure the reduction in untreated CSOs can be achieved , the legislation gives the CSO permittees a decade to either reduce or eliminate CSO discharges, or to add treatment facilities.
Which is Meant to Make You Think that Alewife Brook Sewage Pollution is a Good Thing
Annotated Slides by David Stoff
Meeting materials can be downloaded from the documents tab here.
By “occasionally, excess flow”, they mean 51 Million Gallons of Untreated Sewage Pollution was dumped in the Alewife Brook in 2021.
Remember …
When they say “Sanitary Wastewater”, what they really mean is hazardous untreated sewage.
When they say “sewer overflows can’t be eliminated“, what they mean is the money they saveby not fixing the problemis more important than you are.
When they say the stormwater is so dirty that it is a waste of money to eliminate sewage pollution discharges, what they mean is that they get to keep using the Alewife Brook as an open sewer until it’s so clean you could wade through it and not get sick.
The Alewife Brook and its parkland is owned by the people. It was established in 1893 by the Metropolitan Parks Commission, under the guidance of visionary landscape architect Charles Eliot. Charles Elliot’s intention was to preserve parkland connections for the public which would
“provide fresh air, scenic beauty, and opportunities for quiet repose – antidotes to the ills of urban life.”
Please join us 6 pm on Thursday night, 12/15/22, at the Alewife Sewage Pollution Planning Meeting #2 by registering here.
At this meeting, Cambridge, Somerville, and the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority will talk about the new Future “Typical Year” sewage pollution modeling which will be used for new sewer system infrastructure planning and future performance assessment. The new “Typical Year” modeling will include Climate Change Projections.
Climate Change will bring an increase in rainfall, and an increase in the severity and number of storms. Increased rainfall means an increase in Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) sewage pollution in the Alewife Brook. In fact, that increase appears to be exponential with an increase in rainfall. While Cambridge, Somerville, and MWRA should be commended for including Climate Change projections in the new “Typical Year” modeling – it’s not enough.
Why? Well, the “Typical Year” is basically an “Average” year. But modest increases above the average rainfall produce much greater CSO sewage pollution discharges. It is in the years when we experience “atypical” increases in rainfall that we experience greater amounts of CSO sewage pollution in the Alewife.
Actual CSO Discharge volumes in the Alewife Brook have often been way above the Typical Year modeled values since 2015 when Alewife CSO projects ended. Data from MWRA reports which we wrote about here.
The graph above shows the annual “Typical Year” rainfall along with actual rainfall, as well as “Typical Year” CSO sewage discharges and actual CSO sewage discharges for Alewife Brook. This chart goes back to 2015, when the MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville completed the last of their CSO projects. Note that Alewife CSO discharges increase dramatically with increase in rainfall; the actual annual average CSO discharges over this seven year period were 15.8 million gallons, while the modeled Typical Year value was only 6 million.
The new CSO modeling for Alewife needs to represent “atypical” years. By design, the new “Typical Year” model will not reflect the actual reality of Alewife CSO sewage pollution discharges unless it includes atypical year data.
Conclusion
Even with Climate Change Projections taken into consideration, a Future “Typical Year” based model would not represent the reality of sewage pollution in Alewife Brook. Atypical years need to be included in the discharge and compliance analysis for the Long Term CSO Control Plan.
Untreated sewage pollution has harmful health impacts on the 5000 people who live in the Alewife’s 100-year flood plain. Therefore, an End to Untreated Alewife Sewage Pollution must be engineered for the Alewife Brook. It is not enough to include Climate Change projections in the “Typical Year” model. Gray and green infrastructure solutions must be used to end untreated sewage discharges. At the same time, the Great Cities of Cambridge and Somerville should continue the good work of separating their combined sewer systems.
If you are not sure you can attend the Second Public Sewage Pollution Meeting on December 15, please send an email to City Hall and to the department heads at Cambridge DPW and Somerville DPW. Your voice needs to be heard and your city wants to hear from you.
Alewife Sewage Pollution Control Public Meeting #2 Thursday, December 15th at 6 pm Zoom Register Here
1. EXPRESS Gratitude for Addressing Climate Change
We thank Cambridge, Somerville, and MWRA for agreeing to include Climate Change Projections in the updated sewage pollution control plan. If applied properly, this is a huge win for the Alewife Brook!
2. CALL FOR IMMEDIATE ACTIONS
Because the great cities of Cambridge and Somerville, and the MWRA are asking for an additional 36 months for their planning work, we are calling for:
IMMEDIATE ACTIONS
An updated Alewife Master Plan, from Alewife T to Mystic River.
An hydrological, dredging, and dechannelization study to be completed in 2023. *
Department of Conservation and Recreation Maintenance work, including brook trash and fence removal.
Simple odor control.
3. CALL FOR IMPROVEMENTS IN NEW SEWAGE POLLUTION CONTROL PLAN
To date, we have collected 1000 petition signatures from good folks in Cambridge, Somerville, Arlington, Belmont, and Medford. The public demands the following improvements to the Alewife Brook sewage pollution problem:
INCLUDE IN ALEWIFE SEWAGE POLLUTION CONTROL PLAN
An end to untreated sewage pollution.
Separated sewer systems to keep sewage out of stormwater.
Green infrastructure on State Land to clean and detain stormwater.
Grey infrastructure to eliminate untreated CSOs. **
Necessary MWRA system-wide sewer upgrades.
Flood mitigation and control measures.
More extensive odor control.
* A hydrological, dredging, and dechannelization study will help determine important next steps. Sediment removal through dredging could improve Alewife Brook water quality and reduce flooding. Such a study will also lay the groundwork for applications of Federal and State funds to help restore the Brook.
In their 05/11/2022 letter to MWRA, EPA stated, “The channelized nature of Alewife Brook, as well as the amount of sediment in the Alewife constructed channel that takes up flood storage capacity (this sediment volume was estimated by USGS in 2005 to take up approximately 0.5 million cubic feet), exacerbates the flooding issue. MWRA has the technical staff and state public authority status to take a leadership role in convening additional agencies such as the Massachusetts Department of Conservation and Recreation (owner of the Alewife Brook and Mystic River Reservations) to start to identify potential projects.”
** Grey infrastructure might include a CSO treatment plant at the Alewife T, underground CSO detention tanks, and improved and accurate CSO volume and flow metering.
Alewife Sewage Pollution Control Public Meeting #2 Thursday, December 15th at 6 pm ZOOM REGISTER HERE
There’s quite a lot for Save the Alewife Brook to be thankful for on these last days of November in 2022. We are especially thankful that the public’s voice is being heard and that Climate Change projections will be included in the new plan to end untreated sewage pollution in the Alewife Brook.
Massachusetts Water Resources Authority
First of all, we are thankful to the MWRA, which was created in 1984 for the “preservation and improvement of the health, welfare and living conditions of the citizenry.1” MWRA has agreed to include the projected impacts of Climate Change on precipitation in their sewage pollution control modeling. Save the Alewife Brook deeply appreciates MWRA for including Climate Change in the new plan to end untreated sewage pollution. Thank you, MWRA. ❤️
Cambridge
We are thankful for the city of Cambridge’s forward-thinking work on Climate Resilience. We are grateful to Cambridge DPW for their work over the last few decades to separate the city’s stormwater from their sanitary sewage, and for their construction of the 3.4-acre stormwater wetland next to Little River. This beautiful public park serves as a model for the green infrastructure needed in the new plan to end Alewife Brook sewage pollution. We are especially grateful for Cambridge’s leadership in ensuring that Climate Change projections will be included in the new Combined Sewer Overflow Control Plan modeling. Thank you, Cambridge. ❤️
Somerville
We are thankful for the new fence that Somerville installed above the Tannery Brook CSO, (just north of Mass Ave), to replace the fence that had fallen into disrepair. The new fence will prevent children, adults, and pets from falling into the sewer outfall. The Tannery Brook CSO belongs to Somerville and contains Somerville sewage and storm water, but it’s located in Cambridge, and has access covers with MWRA’s logo on them. It’s quite confusing, which makes us doubly appreciative of Somerville’s responsiveness in replacing the safety fence. Thank you, Somerville. ❤️
Thank you!
To our dear supporters: Thank You! for your interest, support, and participation. We are nothing without you. <3
On November 21, 2022, Save the Alewife Brook sent a letter to Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection. This letter is in response to the 36-month extension that MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville have requested for completing the planning of the new Alewife Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) plan.
In our 11/21/2022 letter to MassDEP, we wrote:
“We don’t believe that the CSO parties have made a strong enough case for the requested three-year extension without taking immediate action. Nonetheless, if you determine that an extension is necessary, there are factors cited by the parties that have our support:
Including Climate Change projections in the typical year modeling used for CSO infrastructure planning and performance evaluation.
More extensive alternatives analysis.
Increased public participation with additional meetings.
MEPA Review.
Cambridge, Somerville, and MWRA preparing a common Updated Alewife CSO Control Plan.
We request that Cambridge, Somerville, and MWRA fund the updating of the Metropolitan District Commission 2003 Alewife Master Plan.[1] Specifically, we would like an Alewife Master Planupdate to be completed in 2023. The updated Alewife Master Plan should look at river restoration and dredging as envisaged in the 2003 Alewife Master Plan. It should also consider the recommendations in the EPA[2] technical analysis. The scope should encompass Alewife Brook from the Alewife T Station to the Mystic River.
An updated 2023 Alewife Master Plan is essential for timely application for Federal Infrastructure Law funds to address flooding and water quality issues, increasing Climate Resilience and mitigating negative impacts on the area’s Environmental Justice populations. An updated Alewife Master Plan would also help in developing the new Long-Term CSO Control Plan.
Please join us on Sunday, December 4th at 7 pm to discuss the new Alewife Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) Control Plan. The second public CSO planning meeting will be December 15th and we are very excited to strategize about it with you!
There is huge news about a new plan to make desperately needed improvements to the sewage pollution problem in the Alewife Brook. The Massachusetts Water Resources Authority has promised to include Climate Change projections in their planning of new area combined sewer infrastructure, in response to the Alewife Brook’s hazardous raw sewage pollution problem.
Including Climate Change projections in the planning of new sewer infrastructure modeling should be a huge win for water quality in the Alewife Brook and for the Environmental Justice Populations who are affected by it.
Local ACMI cable news reporter Jeff Barnd does a terrific job covering the Alewife sewage problem.
Thanks goes out to everyone who has stood up for Environmental Justice in the Alewife Brook. Note: we need to see you all at the Second Public CSO meeting, tentatively scheduled for December 15, 2022.
Over the summer, in 2022, Somerville, Cambridge, and Massachusetts Water Resources Authority held their first Alewife CSO Control Plan public meeting. At this meeting, Cambridge resident Ann McDonald asked, “When will the Alewife Brook not smell?” Save the Alewife Brook’s David Stoff has been asking this question since the 1990’s.
When you take a walk along the Alewife Greenway Path, the first thing you are likely to notice is the stench. What you are smelling is disgusting sewage vaporescaping from the area’s terribly old sewer system! Last year, that old sewer infrastructure was responsible for dumping 51 million gallons of untreated sewage into Alewife Brook.
On our recent tour of the MWRA’s Alewife sewer system, David Stoff asked MWRA’s Stephen Cullen about odor control on the Alewife Greenway, specifically at the Alewife Brook Sewer siphon near Bicentennial Park. As a result of Save the Alewife Brook’s inquiry, the MWRA sealed the siphon access with clear caulking. This solution worked! And it could be duplicated for all such sewer infrastructure along our popular public path.
The MWRA’s Alewife Brook siphon structure, near Bicentennial Park in Arlington. Photos by David Stoff.
A silicon seal on the MWRA’s sewer system keeps sewer vapors from escaping from the old sewer system.
The nauseating odor leaking from the sewer system causes a gag reflex, ruining many nice walks and picnics in our park. That odor dramatically diminishes the quality of life for everyone who lives near, walks, or rides a bike along the brook or over the Mass Ave bridge to and from Cambridge. It affects a lot of people!
A Few Words About Sewer Odor from Technical Advisor David White:
There are three primary sources of the bad odor along Alewife Brook: (1) leaks from the manholes of the sanitary sewer lines that run next to the brook (2) leaks from some of the Combined Sewer Outfalls which are open to the air (3) from CSO sewage discharges
The manhole problem can easily be fixed, although the sewer gas has to come out somewhere. The CSO sewer vapor problem is a little more complicated but doable. The CSO sewage discharges need to be reduced, treated, and eliminated.
Afterall, on our summer tour of the MWRA’s sewer system, MWRA kindly treated our group to sandwiches, potato chips, and soda at the Deer Island Wastewater Treatment facility, where there was no foul smell at all.
Why is there no smell at Deer Island? In response to public pressure, MWRA installed a sophisticated and modern odor control system at Deer Island. And, according to MWRA, a well-managed sewer system does not smell.
The weather should be good today. Take a three minute walk from Massachusetts Avenue, north along the Alewife Brook. And check out the kid-friendly Alewife GHOST FISH art installation and Somerville’s sewer outfall!
The Alewife Brook GHOST FISH hang from Somerville’s Combined Sewer Outfall.
Before there was a sewer outfall at this location (behind the Homewood Suites Hotel), there was a second brook that met the Alewife Brook. 19th Century Cantabrigians called it the “Tannery Brook“. The Tannery Brook was used to discard hog bodies and other tannery waste products which polluted the water. Nowadays, the Tannery Brook is (un)dead and buried in a pipe that is attached to the sewer outfall. In 2021, this sewer outfall dumped 17.98 million gallons of untreated sewage pollution from Davis Square into the Alewife Brook.
A century before Cantabrigians polluted the Tannery Brook, the Alewife Brook was known by the native people as the Menotomies River. And it was the best place to catch Alewife fish! So plentiful were the Alewife fish, that the fish were used mainly for agricultural purposes, to fertilize soil for growing crops. The colonial settlers sited a fish trap, which is known as a weir, at this location. The settlers likely sited their fish weir on the remains of the native Pawtuckeog people’s fish weir.
Can you see the GHOST FISH? Can you hear the Pawtuckeog people and the sound of their Menotomies River?
The native people and their lost river are here, too.
How to get to there:
Take the Alewife Greenway behind the Homewood Suites Hotel at Mass Ave and Rte 16. The brown “x” marks the spot of the Ghost Fish Halloween Installation. This is a three minute walk from Massachusetts Avenue.
I’m going to tell you a story. I have a point of view. I’m not hiding it. Depending on your point of view, this story is either history, or myth. It’s the story of the cleanup of Boston Harbor. Think it’s over? You can see the crown jewel, the Deer Island Treatment Plant, standing by the edge of the harbor. Deer Island is indeed a gem, but when it rains, the sewer systems feeding into it routinely spew out raw sewage by design. It’s one of the problems the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority (MWRA) was created to solve. There’s a name for it: Combined Sewer Overflow. How this problem is solved will show us a lot about what our “climate resilient” future looks like.
The Beautiful Swan
The MWRA has a plan to control the overflows from its sewers when it rains. This is how they describe it:
“Prior to 1988 treated and untreated sewer overflows occurred in every rainfall event approximately 100 times a year. The Long-term Control Plan is intended to reduce total discharges by approximately 87%, in a typical year [my italics] from 3.3 billion gallons to 400 million gallons, and 93% of the remaining 400 million gallons is to be treated at one of four of the MWRA’s upgraded treatment facilities.”
It sounds so good, but that narrative was merely aspirational. The MWRA’s control plan has cost $911 million to date. Its goal was to minimize, not eliminate, sewer overflows, and then to change state water quality standards to accommodate the untreated discharges. Last year the MWRA’s Final CSO Assessment Reportwas supposed to give regulators the green light to make these changes, but 16 outfalls failed even to achieve the level of control required in the plan. MWRA and two other communities who operate the sewers have been ordered to draft new control plans. Problem solved? Story over? Not really.
The Ugly Duckling
The ugly duckling is the Alewife Brook, a narrow 2-mile-long stream that emerges behind the T stop of the same name. The MWRA control plan allows for annual discharges of 7.6 million gallons of sewage to Alewife Brook. By way of comparison, the load for the 80-mile-long Charles River is about 8 million gallons. The MWRA says that in 2019 about 9 million gallons should have flowed into the Alewife Brook because it rained more than in the hypothetical “typical year” used in the control plan. MWRA’s actual discharge volume was monitored and was more than 23 million gallons. Yet the MWRA was in compliance with regulatory requirements. You knew that was coming, didn’t you?
This is possible because, for twenty-three years, the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) has waived water quality standards for sewer overflows from the MWRA. The numerical limits for bacteria, solids, color, turbidity, have been replaced with a narrative standard, another story if you will. MWRA is required to work toward meeting the level of control in the plan approved by the Federal Court based on a “typical year” which would have 46 inches of rain. While MWRA is working to meet this standard, Massachusetts will not hold them accountable for what would otherwise be a violation.
The Ratepayer Rebellion & the Myth of Affordable Control of Sewer Overflows
It costs money to fix sewers. MWRA frames the choice this way: spend about twice what it cost to build Deer Island to dig up and replace all the sewers within the district that combine sewage (what you flush) with storm drainage (what falls on the ground), or live with intermittent sewer overflows because that’s what’s affordable.
“Affordable” in the sense in which the word is used here has its roots in the “Ratepayer Rebellion” over the cost of the Deer Island Treatment Plant. Because it changed the way sewer overflows are regulated nationally, the story of the Ratepayer Rebellion deserves scrutiny. There are indisputable facts. In 1993 Senator Kennedy and MWRA Executive Director MacDonald testified before the Senate Appropriations Committee. Congress appropriated funds for the Boston Harbor cleanup. Beyond that, the line between history and myth blurs depending on who’s telling the story. The MWRA tells it this way:
Massachusetts was in the grip of a deep recession. With only 6% of the nation’s population, we’d lost 30% of the jobs. Cash strapped ratepayers could no longer pay the skyrocketing water bills necessary to complete the construction of Deer Island. The specter of community default loomed so the MWRA turned to Congress for help. Senator Kennedy himself made sure funds were appropriated to continue the Boston Harbor cleanup. After that scare, regulators saw to it that “affordability” was baked into federal law. Controlling sewer overflows would be affordable to both sewer operators and ratepayers.
In this telling, MWRA was responding to angry “ratepayers.” Would you feel differently about the story if you knew MWRA and other water utilities had been lobbying to change regulations for sewer overflows before ratepayers rebelled?
The story can be told another way. In this telling, citizens were working in a complex political arena with institutional players who had their own agendas. The deep recession was still there, but this story begins with busing — Boston’s wound that never heals. Did Stanley Forman’s photo already flash across your mind? The same Federal Court that had ordered busing to desegregate the schools now asserted control over the sewer system. A massive project was needed to comply with the court order. Resentment? You decide. MWRA knew that, unlike the other big project in town, the Central Artery, the cost of the Harbor cleanup would fall squarely on the backs of communities around Boston and not on the federal government. If MWRA took money from local aid to pay off its construction bonds, as state law allowed, public support for the Harbor cleanup, and for the MWRA itself, would evaporate.
So MWRA recast itself as the defender of citizens struggling with the burden placed on them by the Court. They went to Congress with the story of a second Boston Tea Party born of high water bills. They leveraged federal support for the Boston Harbor cleanup by claiming that lack of political consensus would cause the project to fail. Everyone in the country knew what that failure would look like because of a picture from an April day in 1976. They got their money. In the process, MWRA helped create what we’ve become — the “new” Boston, with the cleaner Harbor at its heart. It’s why, whenever activists (of which I’m one) meet with the MWRA, the conversation starts with something like “what you did with the Harbor was a miracle.” The miracle is not just cleaner water in Boston Harbor. It’s that their actions helped heal a wounded city. No one can take that miracle away. No one wants to.
But if you can see that these versions of the Ratepayer Rebellion are just different ways of telling a story, can you also see how the inexorable pull of a myth blinds us to a simpler, less emotionally satisfying, view of the Ratepayer Rebellion? That’s the history of a public utility acting to lower its costs. Always. The evidence for this is right there in the Alewife Brook.
How a Myth Hides a Subsidy
The Ratepayer Rebellion is why sewer overflows are treated differently than discharges from Deer Island. Controls for sewer overflows must be both cost effective, in and of themselves, and “affordable” for the communities implementing them. The sewage is the same though, and the affordable dollars spent controlling overflows are used to remove the same three pollutants: Bacteria, Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD) and Total Suspended Solids (TSS). Two big thick books, the Final Combined Sewer Overflow Facilities Plan and Environmental Impact Report (1997) ****** ***************, and The Notice of Project Change for the Alewife Brook CSO Control Project (2001), describe how these pollutants are to be removed from overflows to the Alewife Brook. From them are drawn the pollutant concentrations in the overflows, and the cost for removal by various control alternatives. The volumes and pollutant concentrations are a mix of metric and U.S. system units. I did a calculation to put a price on the Total Suspended Solids discharged to Alewife Brook in the 2019 overflows that were above the limits authorized in the MWRA’s control plan. These were arguably illegal.
Cost of Total Suspended Solids Discharged into Alewife Brook in 2019
Not treating sewer overflows is worth millions of dollars to MWRA.
In 2019 when the control plan failed to meet its target the excess sewage dumped in the Alewife Brook effectively generated $615,977 of free money for the MWRA. Not having to treat BOD will have generated about twice as much, while not treating Bacteria – nearly thirty times more. Not treating sewer overflows is worth millions of dollars to MWRA. If there’s a real story here, it’s the scale of these cost savings. This is why affordable control of sewer overflows to Boston Harbor is a myth. It only works because MWRA can avoid treating 7% of the sewage flowing to Boston Harbor in places like the Alewife Brook where treatment would be most expensive.
The MWRA prides itself on receiving no state appropriations. Really? Construction for the CSO control plan was substantially complete in 2017 and the MWRA capital budget zeros out construction funding for the program in 2024. It seems that MWRA intends to use untreated overflows to balance the books for a while.
If Massachusetts wanted untreated sewage overflows to end, they’d be taxed – not subsidized. Instead state regulators have granted MWRA a seemingly perpetual subsidy to pollute our rivers and streams. It gets very hard to tell if the Boston Harbor cleanup is the story of how hard-nosed choices about “affordable” pollution controls resulted in an undeniable environmental success, or a cautionary tale of how a large public utility rents Massachusetts’ waters for sewage disposal for pennies on the dollar in a successful effort to cut their own costs.
Back to the Beginning
There is an ongoing discussion about the “typical year” used in the computer model that is the heart of the MWRA Long-Term Control Plan. Nature is forcing our hand with more intense and frequent storms. These are hard to model. EPA argues that NOAA rain data that includes the effects of climate change must be used. For their part, MWRA stands by their legal obligation to achieve the level of control in a 2006 stipulation to the Federal Court, where they are still the defendant. If EPA wants the sewers to do better when it rains more, they’ll need to pay for it. It turns out that the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law has money to do just that.
The discussion about the “typical year” is a polite way of talking about how much untreated sewage will spill into Boston Harbor. It takes us back to the Boston Harbor court case, which the key to understanding whether what you’re reading is history or myth. You can believe the case was started by the Conservation Law Foundation, or that it started when a Quincy solicitor’s foot landed in a pile of human waste on Wollaston Beach. I believe it started in 1972 when the Clean Water Act became law. That’s when the citizens of the United States wrested control of the nation’s waters from polluters who thought they owned them, and could use them as they pleased.
The Clean Water Act created a permit program called the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES). Elimination is the promise of the Act. All the lobbying for regulatory changes, all the litigation by water utilities, all the arguments about what’s affordable, these all fail when you can say that there’s no path to eliminating a source of pollution. That’s when the promise is broken. That’s where we are with sewer overflows. MWRA would have us believe that the NPDES permit is a rental contract. But the waters of the United States belong to all of us, and we’ll get them back.
The fable of the Ugly Duckling
A fable is a story that teaches a lesson. The fable of the Ugly Duckling teaches us about how people make judgments. Every child knows that the beautiful swan and the ugly duckling are the same bird. Likewise the Boston Harbor is beautiful, and we want the story of how it got that way to be the same. The MWRA always tells a compelling story, backed up with their data. In this instance we’d do well to heed the squawks of the ugly duckling. The Alewife Brook teaches us how people living with sewer overflows experience them. The water smells. Your only park is degraded. You never let your kids play in the puddles. Every other nuisance is located nearby because there’s an open sewer in the neighborhood. Twenty-eight years ago I was at a permit hearing where a woman testified how sewage from the Alewife Brook flooded her home and made her sick. She was not alone. The officials in the room disregarded what she had to say. Their belief in a set of regulations required it. But those regulations are just the product of voices from the Ratepayer Rebellion. The voice in the room with you is subordinated to the echo of other voices because, in this myth, the money that’s saved is more real than some people’s lives. Is this the future you want?
The story of the Boston Harbor cleanup is still shrouded in myth, not yet a legend, because it’s ongoing. Actions we take now can affect the outcome. MWRA will need to recreate a political consensus it once enjoyed in order to secure more federal funding. The web of “affordability” regulations they’ve given us can be employed to implement any level of control for which there’s a political consensus. Our duty is to demonstrate some leadership for the rest of the country by putting the Ratepayer Rebellion behind us. We’ve subsidized enough computerized penny pinching. The Governor deciding that Massachusetts will require primary treatment, at a minimum, of any discharge from our sewers would do it. This would show that Massachusetts believes in the promise of the Clean Water Act and is willing to fight for it.
Let’s invest federal climate resiliency funds to change lives in the communities most affected by the work still left undone. In the places MWRA currently plans to use as open sewers. Adopting and enforcing water quality standards is a core function of state government. If we say sewer overflows require treatment to meet the Massachusetts standard, there’s nothing Clarence and his cabal can do about it. It’s something we can do right now.
On Sunday October 9, 2022, thirty supporters of Save the Alewife Brook marched in HONK! Fest from Davis Square in Somerville to Harvard Square in Cambridge.
Sara Peattie’s Puppeteers Cooperative marched with us, leading the way with a family of sea horses and the huge four-person puppet named Big Blue, the Goddess of Clean Water. Following the puppets was Kara Casey and her two water protectors, as the “Mermaid in Mourning”. The Mermaid was crying because she was covered in trash and other brook debris, dragging a long, clanking trail of bottles and cans. Following the Mermaid was a school of hand-made GHOST FISH swimming upstream, carried by folks in bright red shirts emblazoned with Alewife fish, chanting:
There were thousands and thousands of people along Mass Ave, as we marched into Harvard Square! What an amazing day for a parade – there was not a cloud in the sky! Everybody was out to see the bright and noisy spectacle. SAVE THE ALEWIFE BROOK distributed hundreds of stickers and collected more signers for our email petition to end Alewife Brook sewage pollution and flooding in the face of Climate Change.
Thanks to everyone who participated:
Cecily Miller, Sara Peattie, Kara Casey and family, Alida Castillo, Sue Janowitz, Ann McDonald, Crystal Maier, Maggie Starvish, Beth Melofchik, Gilbert Martin, Matthew De Remer & family, Cullen Malone, Gerda Brown, Thomas Close, Joel Snider, Veronique Bailly, Monique McNally and Barg, Gerda Brown, Sandy Durmaskin, Diane Martin, Paige Gromfin, Jonathon Forbes, Jean Devine, David Stoff, Gwen Speeth, Kristin Anderson, & The Mystic River Watershed Association.
SUNDAY OCTOBER 9, from 11 am to 1:30 pm March with us in the HONK! Parade, at 11 am gather at the Day Street Parking Lot in Davis Square, Somerville ending in Harvard Square, Cambridge, at 1:30 pm
Sara Peattie’s puppet Big Blue, the Goddess of Clean Water, will lead us in the parade.
Parade with us, along with musicians and puppeteers. Join us, to demand a safe, clean, and restored brook, for all species who live in and around the Alewife Brook.
Puppeteer Sara Peattie has created large, colorful fish puppets, and to lead the group, Big Blue, the Goddess of Clean Water. Wear a free Save the Alewife Brook t-shirt and carry a GHOST FISH when you join us in the parade.
RSVP here for the Parade:
SATURDAY OCTOBER 8 MAKE ART WITH US DURING THE HONK! FESTIVAL IN DAVIS SQUARE!
Join us anytime from noon until 4 pm at Elm Street Art in Davis Square. There will be a public arts station for folks of all ages to make their own Alewife fishes while brass bands play all over Davis Square.
Please invite your friends to join you! You can also help us get the word out to your neighbors about Save Alewife Brook and get more people involved.
GHOST FISH artwork by David Stoff
Cecily Miller from Arts Arlington has made this video to explain the HONK!Fest and Elm Street Art. More info about HONK!Fest here.
A Grand Day on the Alewife Brook Measuring Sediment Depth
July 9 2022. On the Alewife, Kristin Anderson of Save the Alewife Brook sets out to measure sediment depth.
The Environmental Protection Agency’s mention of dredging the Alewife Brook in its Response to the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority’s April 2022 Draft Scope for the new CSO Control Plan has revived the discussion about the role removing sediment from the Alewife Brook can play in restoration and flood prevention efforts. EPA recommends MWRA include dredging the Alewife Brook as part of the Alternatives Analysis for the new Control Plan.
Elimination of Combined Sewer Overflows and sewage pollution in the brook must be achieved through continued sewer separation in Cambridge and Somerville. But sewer separation means removing stormwater from the sanitary sewer system. Once it’s removed, that stormwater has to go somewhere, and that somewhere is the Alewife Brook. Increasing the amount of stormwater flowing to the Alewife Brook could increase the threat of area flooding. Therefore, flood mitigation measures must be taken alongside sewer separation. EPA suggests that one way to accommodate an increase in stormwater would be to increase the Alewife Brook’s storage and flow capacity by dredging the channelized portion of the brook.
The Time Has Come to Dredge the Alewife Brook to Increase Capacity and Prevent Flooding
In its Response letter, EPA quotes a 2005 United States Geological Survey study that estimated sediment volume in the Alewife Brook at approximately half a million cubic feet. In 1988, one of many moments when the idea of dredging the Alewife was floated, the Metropolitan District Commission (MDC – precursor of both MWRA and the Department of Conservation & Recreation) commissioned a study to determine what was in the sediment. This was necessary to determine how to dispose of the dredged material. When testing indicated that the material was toxic enough to require disposal at a Certified Waste Disposal Site, the MDC’s enthusiasm for dredging faded. If EPA are now endorsing consideration of dredging, then it may be an idea whose time has finally come.
Cruising on the Little River, July 9 2022
Our Measurements Suggest a Doubling of Sediment Since 1988
On a fine summer day in July, three members of Save the Alewife Brook set out to measure the depth of sediment at the 1988 testing sites. Equipped with a precision hand-crafted measuring tool – a 5-foot steel rod with a ruled scale ground onto it – and a hand-built canoe. We dropped the boat in at John Wald Park in Cambridge.
Sample Locations Map from 1988 Little River/Alewife Brook Survey, which includes sediment depth data from some of labeled testing sites.
It’s no surprise that the amount of sediment has increased since 1988, given three decades of sewage discharges, and infrequent removal of branches and trash. At the center of the Little River opposite MWRA’s CSO MWR003 (‘CCSO’ on the map), our tester measured a sediment depth of approximately 36 inches. That’s double the 18 inches recorded in 1988. Further upstream, adjacent to 20 Acorn Drive (‘AB03’), the sediment measurement was 48 inches. That’s an increase of 18 inches over the 1988 measurement.
We also measured sediment at two sites in the Alewife Brook not found on the 1988 map. Under the Pedestrian/Bikepath Bridge over the brook, sediment was 36 inches deep. At the canoe launch in Arlington, adjacent to Lafayette Street (the overlook marked by the boulder with the carved Snapping Turtle image), the sediment depth was 48 inches – that’s 4 feet of sediment in the narrow concrete channel!
We didn’t measure the site marked on our 1988 map just downstream of the Mass. Ave. Bridge (AB06A). None of the crew felt like dragging the canoe past the growing channel obstructions or measuring the sediment depth immediately downstream of two of Cambridge’s active CSO outfalls (CAM002 & CAM401B), what with the 1.5 million gallons of sewage pollution they dumped in this spot last year.
The stench emanating from this portion of our poor debris-strewn channel on that hot summer day undercut the (wildly misleading) claim of an 85% reduction in the volume of sewage discharged to the Alewife Brook since 1988 (the year our sampling map was made). In 1988 the sediment depth at AB06A was 10 inches. Eyeballing it from the banks, it’s clear that the sediment now catching and trapping branches and other debris is a great deal deeper.
Now is the time to consider dredging the Alewife Brook. Removing the sediment could provide immediate benefits in terms of capacity, flow, and improved water quality. Federal Infrastructure Law funds can get this done.
Save the Alewife Brook’s David White and David Stoff reel in the Alewife’s “catch-o-the-day”: a microwave oven!
The Boston Harbor Clean-Up worked wonders in the Boston Harbor and in the Charles River, but Massachusetts Water Resources Authority’s claim that they have achieved an 85% reduction of combined sewer overflows to the Alewife Brook is not consistent with their own data about the vast quantities of sewage actually discharged into our little brook in recent years.
In 2021 the sewer operators’ own websites (MWRA, Cambridge, Somerville) reported that over 50 million gallons of untreated sewage pollution was discharged into the Alewife Brook. That’s the same amount of sewage pollution as was dumped in the Alewife in 1994, before work began to try to fix the problem.
In 2021, over 50 Million Gallons of Untreated Sewage Pollution was Dumped into Alewife Brook.
So, why does the MWRA claim the Alewife sewage pollution problem is 85% better? MWRA’s 85% improvement assertion is based on their flawed computer modeling based on the “Typical Year” (a hypothetical “average” year). They have actual metered data that could be used to evaluate their progress, but they assess themselves using fanciful modeled results instead.
The MWRA’s Typical Year model results bear little resemblance to the current reality in the Alewife Brook because it is based on old weather data going back to 1949, with no acknowledgement of the dramatic changes in precipitation brought about by Climate Change. Increases in storm intensity & volume of rains are causing exponential increases in sewage discharges.
MWRA’s own chart below shows the actual volume of sewage pollution dumped in the brook vs. the MWRA modeledsewage volume. When you compare the actual volumes (gray bars) to the modeled volumes (blue bars), it becomes clear that the MWRA’s model is out of touch with reality.
This Chart Data was provided by MWRA to Arlington’s Select Board on 02/14/2022.
Note that, until their Alewife sewer separation work ended in 2015, actual sewage discharges decreased as a result of Cambridge’s excellent sewer improvements. The MWRA’s modeled data (blue bars) implies that these positive impacts from Alewife sewer improvements persisted, while the sad reality of exponential increase in actual sewage pollution (gray bars) is undeniable. Over the last seven years, there has been 250% more sewage pollution than the MWRA’s computer model admits.
Legalities, Legalities!
Why are the sewer operators using modeled data? There is a legal reason for the MWRA’s flawed modeling. As part of the Boston Harbor Cleanup court case, the sewer operators are required by law to reduce their sewage pollution discharge amounts by 85%. They use this computer model to show that they aren’t breaking the legal limit. If the model showed the truth over the last seven years, they would be out of compliance with the law!
So, whenever you hear the MWRA use the words “Typical Year” or “Average Year,” remember that they are not talking about the actual amount of sewage pollution. They are talking about flawed computer modeling that the MWRA created to fulfill a legal requirement of the Boston Harbor Cleanup court case.
Climate Change is Here.
The solution to the Alewife sewage pollution problem is – most urgently – treatment of all sewage discharges, continued sewer separation by the cities to allow for eventual elimination of discharges, and upgrades to the MWRA’s Northern Branch sewer system to handle increased flow to their Deer Island Treatment Plant. The MWRA must end the dumping of untreated sewage into our little brook! This will require significant new sewer infrastructure. MWRA will only invest in this infrastructure if we, the public, insist that they do.
The planning and assessment of new sewer infrastructure requires an honest look at the actual data. That is why the new Alewife CSO (Combined Sewer Overflow) Control Plan being drafted now must include forward-looking Climate Change projections. Climate Change is here – there are no more ‘Typical’ or ‘Average’ Years.
Help End Sewage Pollution!
Please come to the virtual sewage planning meeting Wednesday, June 29th at 6 PM. The Alewife Brook belongs to the people. Tell the MWRA that they must end the dumping of untreated sewage pollution in our little brook!
We need a strong show of support on Wednesday night. The MWRA must make major upgrades to their regional sewer system. Their sewer system reaches capacity during many storm events. This is when sewage pollution is dumped into our rivers and streams. The MWRA will not fix the problem if they think no one cares. Let them know you care!
Unable to attend the meeting? Send an email asking for an End to Alewife Sewage Pollution by clicking here. Just add your name to it and feel free to edit the email!
Meeting Talking Points:
On May 23, 2022, the EPA provided the following guidance to the Alewife CSO permittees (Somerville, Cambridge, MWRA):
Future climate change impacts to be incorporated into new sewer infrastructure planning and performance models.
Real public participation in the early stages of planning and throughout.
Improvement in water quality.
Flood control measures must be taken.
Significant gray and green infrastructure work on DCR property, including at Dilboy Park.
Sewer infrastructure upgrades.
Possible dredging or dechannelization of the Alewife Brook.
Funding for the work must be equitable and not fall upon lower income residents who cannot afford it.
Wide-ranging projects and major facility upgrades to the MWRA regional system, including possible expansion or rebuilding of the Caruso Pump Station, the key connection point for the MWRA North System. The Caruso Pump Station is known to be a flow restriction in significant storm events.
Adequately consider and protect the Environmental Justice communities along Alewife Brook.
We agree with the EPA on these points and demand that the great cities of Somerville and Cambridge and the MWRA follow the EPA’s guidance. These are our talking points.
You should be allowed to speak at the meeting, after the video presentation is shown. Please raise your hand and take a stand for the Alewife Brook!
We need you now! On Wednesday, June 29th, at 6 PM, Cambridge, Somerville and the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority (MWRA) are holding their first public meeting via Zoom to discuss Combined Sewer Overflows (CSOs).
The legal limit for sewage discharge in the Alewife Brook is 7.29 Million Gallons. In 2021, 51 Million Gallons of untreated sewage pollution was dumped in the Alewife Brook. The sewage pollution problem has been getting worse, not better.
Actual CSO Discharge volume in the Alewife Brook has been increasing exponentially since 2015 when work on Alewife CSOs ended (N.B. 2017 & 2020 were drought years).
The Alewife needs you now. Please register for this meeting today & let the MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville know it is NOT OK to use the Alewife Brook as an open sewer.
This is the first public meeting to discuss the creation of a new Long Term CSO Control Plan (LTCP) to keep untreated sewage out of the Alewife Brook, the Mystic River and the Charles River.
On June 8th, 2022, Arlington Town Meeting voted 197-1 to pass a Resolution for the Alewife Brook that states:
“Town Meeting declares the Alewife Brook to be a valuable natural resource deserving of equal commitment to rehabilitate and restore to the highest water quality standards feasible for wildlife, resident abutters, and recreation; and
FURTHER, that Town Meeting also resolves to encourage and support all Town officials in engaging the MWRA, Cambridge, Somerville, and the Department of Conservation and Recreation as well as state and federal regulators, legislators, and officials to garner the actions necessary to eliminate CSO discharges into the Alewife Brook and render the Brook a safe resource to live near and beautiful water resource to enjoy for the public.” Arlington Town Meeting 2022, Article 76
You can watch our Town Meeting video presentation here:
Thank you to Arlington’s Select Board & Town Meeting for their support!
Join us for our Community Meeting on Monday, June 20th at 7 PM
Please join us on Monday June 20th at 7 pm to discuss next steps at Save the Alewife Brook’s June Community Meeting. We will discuss the upcoming Alewife CSO meeting for the new Long Term CSO Control Plan. This first public meeting will be announced later this week and we are very excited to strategize about it with you!
In response the new CSO (Combined Sewer Outfall) control plan “draft scopes”, the EPA has sent letters to MWRA, Somerville, and Cambridge, addressing every single one of our concerns, which are described in our “Alewife Brook Path to Zero Sewage Pollution“.
What is a “draft scope”? A draft scope is framework for the planning of the new Alewife Brook CSO control plan to eliminate sewage pollution. It’s a plan to create a plan! Somerville and Cambridge and EPA have until December 31, 2023 to finish collaborating on a plan to make improvements to sewage pollution in the Alewife Brook. The draft scope documents are available in our document library here.
In the guidance letters, EPA asked Somerville, Cambridge, and MWRA for:
1. Future climate change impacts to be incorporated into new sewer infrastructure planning and performance models. 2. An improvement in water quality. 3. Realpublic participation in the early stages of planning and throughout. 4. Flood control measures. 5. Significant gray and green infrastructure work on DCR property, including at Dilboy Park! 6. Sewer infrastructure upgrades. 7. A tiered rate structure to pay for the CSO work, so that the burden doesn’t fall on lower income residents who cannot afford it.
We are absolutely psyched about the EPA’s response – it is clear that they are following Federal policy in response to our input. They are really listening!
After 20 years, your water quality campaign for watershed conservation is a great boon to the residents of the Alewife Upper Basin in Belmont, Arlington, Cambridge, Somerville and to the downstream Medford and Chelsea Creek communities, and for the protection of our Atlantic Ocean coast line as well.
We started our Friends of Alewife Reservation in 2000 to bring attention to watershed matters. Now 20 years later the group is with Green Cambridge. At that time, we did not have the scientific means to advocate for the area in the way you have now enlightened us in measuring the vast amount of pollution increase coming from fully discharging CSOs, or those that were not separated in 2013 by Cambridge. It is also true that today, there is the increased flow of dreaded pathogens coming through our towns and cities on the Mystic River watershed especially in the Alewife subwatershed of Belmont, Arlington, Cambridge and Somerville where, you point out in your reports and news briefs, much of Little River and Alewife Brook pollution comes from.
By galvanizing caring community members to note the great open space and benefits and dangers posed by the Alewife waters, and our green corridor to Boston Harbor and the ocean, you show foresight of our New England climate change future. By providing proper mitigation demands which are part of the Boston Reports and city agreements regarding adaptation measures to prevent the severity of climate change flooding. Greening the corridor would do that as will cleaning out the river and brook toxins, and provide habitat for our well-established animals, birds, insects.
The noted environmental firm Horsley and Witten provided my organization with an important Upper Basin report and spoke to the State House regarding the importance of the Belmont/Cambridge Forest which was removed for a developer. I hope you will sustain your outreach and ally with others who care about the urban wild, river, brook, ponds and increasing climate change, noting that the MBTA Alewife metropolitan transit artery is extremely low in water rise elevation, and the area is predicted to flood in 2050 by future climate specialists.
Well-established hazard warning signs in the River and Brook by Cambridge and Somerville may assist in alerting the public to the dangers in the water quality. I hope you will have better results than my then organization had in gaining municipal support and extracting the needed funds from federal, state and municipal sources. Cleaning up this section of the watershed will continue to bring safe recreational, educational benefits, and protect our health and diminishing species in this densely populated region so rich in floodplain. Wishing you the best.
Save the Alewife Brook (StAB) is working hard for dramatic improvements in and around the Alewife Brook. Planning will be starting soon for what may be a huge investment to clean up the brook and make environmental improvements!
The great cities of Cambridge and Somerville and the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority have prepared “Draft Scopes” for their combined sewer overflow (CSO) improvement plans. These draft scopes lay out how they plan to create a new joint Long Term Control Plan to control or eliminate sewage pollution in the Alewife Brook and other waterways.
We reviewed their CSO Draft Scopes and were alarmed by several things:
Climate Change projections were not included in the plans.
A regional approach was missing, which meant that there was no overall plan to include system-wide solutions to the problems, or to involve other communities.
Creative funding alternatives were not mentioned.
Because of these omissions, Save the Alewife Brook presented our own Alewife Brook CSO Plan Draft Scope to the Environmental Protection Agency and to the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection on April 28th, 2022.
The Save the Alewife Brook Path to Zero Sewage Pollution includes:
An overview of the sewage pollution problem and how it impacts area residents
A description of the Alewife’s CSO History from the 1800s to its present systemic failures
A call for CSO Elimination Planning and Performance Models that include climate change projections, and for improved water quality, green infrastructure, and flood mitigation
Details of Alewife CSO impacts on Environmental Justice Populations
Proposed schedule and public participation
Creative funding options
We welcome your involvement as we work to create a clean, attractive and healthy Alewife Brook. Soon we will be announcing public participation opportunities in the new Alewife plan.
On Saturday April 23rd, 2022, Save the Alewife Brook volunteers gathered along the Alewife Greenway for a trash pickup, CSO tour, and ended the event at the Ghost Fish Art Installation at Mass Ave and Route 16.
Save the Alewife Brook thanks the two dozen people from Cambridge, Arlington, Somerville, Medford, and Belmont who came out for the Alewife Earth Day Cleanup and CSO tour.
Save the Alewife Brook Earth Day Clean Up Volunteers show of their Alewife tshirts and their harvested trash.
The Trouble with MWRA’s Terrible Combined Sewer Outfall
We started with a walk and discussion of the MWRA’s Alewife CSO, MWR003, which discharged over 20 million gallons of sewage from Belmont and combined sewage from Cambridge. You can play the video below to hear this one minute presentation.
StAB’s Kristin Anderson discusses the MWRA’s Alewife CSO. Documentary film footage by J. Johnson from Forced Exposure Films.
We hauled a lot of trash! We even found a busted toilet (appropriate, haha) and the rusty hood from a car, a shopping cart, busted furniture, and lots of plastic bottles.
Gwen Speeth and David Stoff show off the huge pile of trash from the clean-up.
The best part of the CSO tour came at the end, when we got to David Stoff’s Ghost Fish art installation at Cambridge’s Historical CSO known as CAM401B. There is one Ghost Fish for every 2 million gallons of sewage that was discharged into the brook last year. That’s a big school of fish!
David Stoff’s Ghost Fish Art Installation
Many thanks to all the participants and donors: Shone Gibson, Joel Snider, Elaine Lyte, Candace Young, Loren Bernardi, Suzanne McLeod, Lida Junghans, Cythina Stillinger, Ann Stewart, Anne Thompson, Philip Thompson, Diane Martin, Ann McDonald, Michael Quinn, Sharon Taylor, Bode Taylor, Cole Taylor, Kate Schull, Ed de Moel, Jean Devine, Jim Eggleston, David Stoff, Jimmy Johnson, Gwen Speeth, Kristin Anderson, & Darbi Crash. Thanks also to George Laite from the East Arlington Good Neighbor Committee, for donating trash pickers and trash bags.
We have an opportunity now to promote our vision for a safer and more beautiful Alewife Brook. Please join us to discuss this on Sunday April 24th at 6 pm for Save the Alewife Brook’s April Community Meeting.
In 2015, the Massachusetts Water Resource Authority reconstructed and enlarged the Combined Sewer Outfall known as MWR003 in the Alewife wetland.1 This CSO was enlarged and functionality was added to it, to provide hydraulic pressure relief for the system downstream. Before the MWRA performed the work on this CSO in 2015, its annual discharge was about 60,000 gallons of untreated and undiluted sewage from Belmont, mixed with untreated sewage and stormwater from Cambridge. MWRA expected the reconstruction of this CSO would result in an increase of untreated sewage discharge of around 1 million gallons annually. But last year, in 2021, this CSO discharged 20 million gallons2 of untreated sewage and wastewater.
MWR003, the MWRA’s Alewife Watershed CSO, reconstructed in 2015.
Why did the MWRA design this CSO to discharge more sewage into the Alewife Brook?
This CSO is part of a larger sewer system that is tied to the Chelsea Creek Headworks, where it is screened before flowing to the Deer Island water treatment plant. The MWRA’s Chelsea Creek Headworks receives sewage flows from the following 17 municipalities: Everett, Somerville, Cambridge, Arlington, Burlington, Lexington, Malden, Melrose, Wakefield, Stoneham, Medford, Reading, Woburn, Wilmington, Winchester, Belmont, and Bedford, as seen in the map below.
This map of the Chelsea Creek Headwork Service Area was provided by the Massachusetts Water Resource Authority.
When flows from these municipalities are experiencing “high growth” during storm events, the Chelsea Creek Headworks runs out of capacity. There’s no room in the pipes because too much stormwater gets into the system. Upstream from the Chelsea Creek Headworks, the Alewife Brook pump station cannot handle the increase in flow because there’s nowhere for sewage to go. This is why the MWRA reconstructed their Alewife CSO, MWR003, made it bigger, and turned it into a relief valve for the rest of the system. The MWRA quite likes CSOs, the reasoning being that CSOs provide more capacity to their sewer system during storm events.3
The MWRA views CSOs as “additional capacity” to their sewer system. From MWRA 2018 Wastewater Master Plan.
The MWRA’s sewage pollution in the Alewife Brook is a feature, not a bug!
The systemic failures in the MWRA’s sewer system impact Alewife area residents.
The Commonwealth and the MWRA have known about the flooding problems in the area for decades now. They have known of the health problems that area residents have suffered following flood events, when raw sewage enters their homes. It is time for the Commonwealth and the MWRA to show that they care about the health of vulnerable area residents, in Environmental Justice communities. They must not design, build, and maintain their sewer system in a way that creates serious health hazards for residents!
It’s time to redesign the sewer system in the Alewife.
Constructed in 1951 and operational in 1952, the Alewife Pump Station is the oldest in the MWRA’s entire system.4 The MWRA’s Alewife Brook Sewer, still in use, was constructed in 1896 or 1897.5 In 1948, a larger sewer line was added to the Alewife and is known as the Alewife Brook Conduit.6 This infrastructure is all so old. Isn’t it time to install new, larger pipes and provide greater pumping capacity for the Alewife Basin?
The Commonwealth provides CSO sewage treatment facilities elsewhere throughout the MWRA’s system. For example, the MWRA has 6 CSO sewage treatment facilities: Prison Point, Cottage Farm, Somerville Marginal, Union Park, Fox Point, & Commercial Point.7
We are at a point in the CSO regulatory process when the MWRA must create a new Long Term CSO Control Plan. Now is the perfect moment for the Commonwealth to ensure that the MWRA redesigns and builds new sewer infrastructure that protects the health of the vulnerable populations who live near the Alewife Brook.
Join us Saturday morning, April 23th, for an Earth Day Alewife Greenway Path Clean-Up and CSO Tour! We’ll be working with Everywhere Arlington Safe Streets to gather trash along the path next to the brook. While we’re there, we can show you the CSOs you’ve been hearing so much about. You’ll know us by our new red Save the Alewife Brook t-shirts.
Free Save the Alewife Brook t-shirts for people who sign up for the clean-up, while supplies last.
Bring gloves, water, & garbage picker, if you have one. We’ll provide bags.
Arlington’s Award-Winning Town Engineer, Wayne Chouinard, also had a letter published about the CSOs:
In addition to being Arlington’s Town Engineer, Wayne Chouinard is also the Chair to the MWRA’s Wastewater Advisory Committee. We are very excited about his ideas for green infrastructure throughout the Alewife Watershed!
Note: Mr. Chouinard states that 90% of all MWRA CSO discharges are disinfected. But this is not true in the Alewife! Despite the amount of flooding, the MWRA continues to discharge hazardous untreated sewage into the Alewife Brook. After major flood events, this results in painful digestive disease in the area’s Environment Justice populations who risk a more adverse outcome to exposure to untreated sewage.
Last week, the Charles River Watershed Association, the Mystic River Watershed Association, and Save the Alewife Brook had meetings with the federal Environmental Protection Agency and the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection to discuss our recent letter to the regulators. This comes at a time when new plans are coming due to eliminate combined sewer overflow (CSO) sewage pollution.
We came away from the meeting with the EPA and their awesome new Regional Director for New England, David Cash, with a sense that the agency is compassionate toward the Environmental Justice populations in the Alewife flood plain. The EPA and DEP seem sincerely concerned about the hazardous health risks that area neighbors face, as the heavily polluted and flood-prone Alewife Brook is so densely settled.
Keep in mind that some of the folks from Save the Alewife Brook worked on the CSO problem 20 years ago. Back then, we wrote letters, letting everyone know about the illnesses we experienced after Alewife flooding brought sewage-contaminated flood water into our homes. And no one was talking about Environmental Justice back then. Save the Alewife Brook is happy to report that the regulatory agencies indicated that they are concerned about the health of the people and want to protect us. They care about the families who live along the Alewife Brook. We are so grateful to have been met with open ears and warmth from the EPA and MassDEP.
We also had a meeting with MWRA on Thursday of last week. There were many there from MWRA as well as from our advocacy groups. There was an open discussion with a frank exchange of views. However, a big disappointment was that MWRA did not want to update their modeling to reflect future climate change impacts.
New Draft Scopes for CSO Elimination Work
Friday, April 1st, 2022 was a big day in the Alewife CSOs regulatory timeline. It was the day that Somerville, Cambridge, and the MWRA were required to submit draft scopes for their new Long Term CSO Control Plans to the federal Environmental Protection Agency and the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection.
The initial takeaway from the MWRA’s scope is that they do not want to consider Climate Change in their plan!
The MWRA’S Climate Change Denial
We are very concerned about the climate change denial in the MWRA draft scope proposal.
Climate Change threatens to exacerbate the problems in the Alewife, with wetter rain seasons, more frequent and more severe storms, and sea level rise, all of which lead to more flooding.
But flooding is not the only problem that Climate Change will present. Climate Change also makes the sewage discharge problem exponentially worse. The volume of discharge is exponentially greater with increase in rainfall. This is why climate change effects must be included in MWRA’s modeling and CSO Plan.
What is the MWRA’s “Typical Year Model?”
There is a legal, regulatory requirement that the MWRA assess the performance of the CSOs in their system, and report back to the regulators. This allows the court and the government to ensure that their obligations to make improvements are being met.
The benchmark for this modeling is a Typical Year, which represents rainfall for average conditions. The Typical Year that they are now using is based on historical data that goes back as far as 1949! To truly represent current and future conditions, the model must be forward-looking and take into account the effects of climate change. The Typical Year approach also does not capture the fact that, when rainfall is above average, CSO discharges exceed in frequency and volume the limits set for a Typical Year, as discussed below.
The MWRA claims that they have reduced the amount of sewage pollution in their system by 85%, as part of the Boston Harbor Cleanup. This may be true for the Boston Harbor and its East Boston and South Boston beaches and the Boston waterfront. Truly, the MWRA deserves an enormous amount of credit for the miraculous, magical work they’ve done improving Boston Harbor water quality with use of the Deer Island Treatment Plant.
But a review of the actual volumes of combined sewage discharge in the Alewife shows that, in the last four years, the system has not met the Long Term Control Plan goals. And, frighteningly, the volume of discharge is increasing exponentially since 2016, and is exponentially worse with increase in rainfall.
Here is a chart from the MWRA that shows the actual annual amounts of combined sewage discharge (the gray bars), the aspirational modeled amounts of discharge (navy blue bars), and the required goal (the straight horizontal orange line). Up top, you can see the actual annual rainfall (light blue bars):
MWRA’s ‘Calendar Year’ metered [actual] data (gray bars) vs. modeled [hypothetical] data (navy blue bars), with LTCP goal (horizontal red line), actual rainfall (light blue bars), and modeled rainfall (horizontal yellow line). Note that: In the last four years, Alewife CSOs failed to meet the LTCP goal, except in drought year 2020. There is an exponential upward trend of actual CSO discharge volume since 2016.
The MWRA has been employing a model that uses historical storm data from before 1993, going backwards over 4 decades to 1949! The actual volumes of sewage discharge, in the gray bars, show that, since the last CSO improvements were completed in 2015, we are experiencing an exponential increase in sewage discharges. The hypothetical model, in the navy blue bars, obfuscates that alarming fact, by suggesting that the Alewife CSOs are performing well and generally below the LTCP goal. The 50 Million Gallons volume of sewage discharge in 2021 is the same amount of sewage discharge that the Alewife was receiving back in the 1990s, before any improvements were made!
If the MWRA does not acknowledge Climate Change in its new plan, we are likely to see a much worse situation in the future.
This is why the EPA and DEP must require the MWRA to adopt a forward-looking model that includes Climate Change projections and also properly considers large storm events.
————————————————————————————————————————-
“The Typical Year is a series of storms (93 storms with total precipitation of 46.8 inches) developed by the Authority in 1992 from a 40-year rainfall record (1949-1987 plus 1992) and approved by EPA and DEP that has served as the basis for development, recommendation and approval of the Authority’s LTCP, establishment of the Court-mandated levels of control, and assessment of system performance.“ P. 3, Footnote 1 from MWRA BIANNUAL COMPLIANCE AND PROGRESS REPORT AS OF JUNE 14, 2019
In the historical Annual Report of the State Board of Health, published in 1907, it was determined that the Alewife Brook was the most polluted stream in the Mystic River watershed. It advised the city of Cambridge to implement a solution: “separate the sewage from the storm water in these combined areas.”
from the 1907 State Board of Health’s Annual Report
This document reads like it was published yesterday. It states that during wet weather, the capacity of the metropolitan sewer system is reached, and “mingled sewage” overflows into the Alewife Brook. The report repeats three times that the combined sewers should be separated, as though its authors understood that their wise advice might be ignored.
Let’s consider what the northern branch of the metropolitan sewer system looked like in 1907. The system was a series of connected pipes that carried untreated sewage flows to be discharged in Boston Harbor, diluted by sea water and carried away by the tides. But, even before 1907, the amount of sewage that was deposited in Boston Harbor exceeded what the tides could carry away.
1874
There were warnings of the deleterious impacts of sewage pollution in the Alewife prior to 1907. An example is the State legislature’s 1874 law, enacted to allow the construction of tidal gates in the Alewife Brook in Somerville, at Broadway. Concern was expressed for the fish in the brook, as the indigent residents living at the Almshouse in North Cambridge had fishing rights in the Alewife. Note the comment, “Sewage not to be discharged into brook.”
1885
In the 19th century, germ theory was not widely accepted. Many still believed that disease was spread through “evil smelling vapours and gases in certain atmospheres”. And, by 1885, the smell from sewage in the Boston Harbor was so bad, that Boston’s Board of Health was quoted as saying,
“Large territories have been at once, and frequently, enveloped in an atmosphere of stench so strong as to arouse the sleeping, terrify the weak, and nauseate and exasperate everybody.
It has been noticed more in the evening and by night than during the day; although there is no time in the whole day when it may not come.
It visits the rich and the poor alike. It fills the sick-chamber and the office. Distance seems to lend but little protection. It travels in a belt half-way across the city, and at that distance seems to have lost none of its potency, and, although its source is miles away, you feel sure it is directly at your feet
The sewers and sewage flats in and about the city furnish nine-tenths of all the stenches complained of.
They are much worse each succeeding year; they will be much worse next year than this.
The accummulation of sewage upon the flats and about the city has been, and is, rapidly increasing, until there is not probably a foot of mud in the river, in the basins, in the docks, or elsewhere in close proximity to the city, that is not fouled with sewage.”
The resulting foul odor from the “sewage flats” was considered not only a grave health threat, but also an economic worry. By 1919, sewage pollution in Boston Harbor was so bad, that it forced the closure of its clam beds. As a result, in that year, the Massachusetts Legislature formed the Metropolitan District Commission, to oversee Metropolitan Sewerage.
1941
It was not until two decades later, in 1941, that the State legislature passed Chapter 720, as part of an Emergency Public Works program, and earmarked $3.8 million in funding for the creation of the area’s first water treatment plant at Nut Island, which would be completed a decade later, in 1952. Included in the scope of that work was the construction of a storm overflow conduit along the Alewife, which came to be known as the Alewife Brook Conduit. The Alewife Brook Conduit, constructed in 1948 and still in use today, increased capacity and provided hydraulic relief to the system during storm events by – you guessed it – discharging more sewage into the Alewife!
1985
In 1985, the Conservation Law Foundation won the famous Boston Harbor Cleanup Court Case, after the EPA partnered with them on the issue. Winning this landmark court case ultimately created billions of dollars of work, lasting decades, throughout the Boston Area. The work associated with the CLF’s lawsuit would be be incomplete 37 years later. To date, the results we’ve seen are a miraculous success for the beaches around Boston Harbor. However, the clean-up programs have not been successful for the flood-prone Alewife Brook.
2022 – Sewage Pollution Problem Accelerates Due to Climate Change
Despite the passage of the Clean Water Act four decades ago, the problem of sewage pollution continues to plague area residents: in 2021, more than 50 million gallons of combined sewage was discharged into the Alewife Brook. Somerville’s Alewife CSO is not in compliance with the law. And, if we analyzed and used the metered CSO discharge volumes in the Alewife Brook over the last four years, in order to assess performance, we’d determine nearly all of the Alewife CSOs are also not in compliance with the law.
The 1907 State Board of Health’s advice to separate all combined sewers has been ignored now for 115 years! Now, as it did in 1907, the sewer system in the area reaches capacity during many storm events, which results in more sewage pollution.
2022 MWRA chart shows actual sewage discharge volume in grey, actual rainfall in light blue, and the required LTCP goal in red. The grey bars show an upward trend of discharge, proving that the sewer system throughout the Alewife is failing.
The State’s sewer system in the Alewife serves Cambridge, Somerville, Belmont, Arlington, and Lexington. This regional sewer system is the responsibility of the Massachusetts Water Resource Authority (MWRA). Here exists clear failure and present danger to the Environmental Justice communities who live along the flood-prone Alewife Brook.
There are, today, 5000 residents living in the Alewife’s 100-year flood plain. During major flood events, the Alewife Brook overflows and its flood water enters the yards, parks, and homes of area residents. Climate Change predictions anticipate an increase in storm events and sea level rise, leading to more flooding.
But flooding is not the only problem that Climate Change poses in the Alewife. Climate Change will bring more inches of rainwater and faster rainfall, which will result in more sewage pollution. The volume of combined sewage discharge in the Alewife is exponentially worse with increase in rainwater. This is because there is only so much capacity inside the pipes. And once capacity is reached, the system is designed, sadly, to discharge sewage as a means of hydraulic pressure relief.
The Alewife pump station is now over-capacity in many storm events. Downstream, the Chelsea Creek Headworks becomes overwhelmed. Sometimes the water treatment plant at Deer Island reaches capacity. A regional solution at the state level is required to address this failing system.
Lack of awareness and cost stand in the way of getting this desperately needed work done. Folks are in absolute disbelief that untreated sewage from Somerville, Cambridge, and Belmont is discharged into the flood-prone Alewife Brook. We must use state and federal funds to modernize the Alewife sewer system. And if we don’t do this work now, it will cost even more money in the future. We have to stop kicking the can down the road.
The Commonwealth and the regulatory agencies must protect the health of Alewife area Environmental Justice communities by revisiting the 1907 State Board of Health’s solution to the hazardous sewage pollution in the Alewife.
The remedy is an Alewife Emergency Public Works Program that includes improving conveyance and capacity throughout the system in the Alewife and downstream, full sewer separation, elimination of all sewage pollution, and ample green and grey infrastructure to clean stormwater and reduce flooding in the area. We must prepare not only for the effects of Climate Change, but also for a growing population.
Thank you to Don Seltzer and Ellen Mass for their historical research contributions.
This post is dedicated to Christine Bongiorno, Sam Lipson, and the other Alewife area Directors of Health, as well as Marina Atlas, who is running for Belmont’s Board of Health.
Would you like to help flyer a neighborhood in Cambridge or Somerville that is connected to the sewer outfalls on the Alewife Brook?
Please help our grassroots effort in North Cambridge and West Somerville, hanging our “Please don’t flush when it rains” flyers. We will be visiting neighborhoods that are still hooked up to the 19th century combined sewage pipes that are polluting the Alewife Brook.
Thank you for offering to volunteer! We will get back to you shortly with more information.
It’s fun to walk around and explore new streets and meet new people! And the weather is so nice now. Please bring your friendly children and your awesome dog. You can check out the map that is linked at the button below. We will be flyering the “D37”, “D39”, and “D41” neighborhoods of North Cambridge.
On March 11th, 2022, the Charles River Watershed Association, the Mystic River Watershed Association, and Save the Alewife Brook came together to speak with one voice to the Federal Environmental Protection Agency and the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection. Together, we collaborated on the following letter about the decades-long Combined Sewer Overflows (CSOs) work; we commented on the history of that work and, more importantly, on the future of the CSO work.
Note that Save the Alewife Brook is a fiercely independent, growing, grassroots, environmental activist organization with supporters in Cambridge, Somerville, Arlington, Belmont, and Medford. Please sign our petition here: Email Petition to End Alewife Brook Sewage Pollution
Regional Administrator David Cash Environmental Protection Agency, Region 1 5 Post Office Square, Suite 100 Boston, MA 02109 david.cash@epa.gov
Commissioner Martin Suuberg Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection One Winter Street Boston, MA 02108 martin.suuberg@state.ma.us
Dear Regional Administrator Cash and Commissioner Suuberg:
We are at an important moment in the decades-long fight to eliminate combined sewer overflows (CSOs) in the Charles and Mystic Rivers, Alewife Brook, and Boston Harbor. The original Long Term Control Plan (LTCP) is coming to a close and the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority (MWRA), Cambridge, and Somerville are beginning to plan for future CSO control efforts. On behalf of Charles River Watershed Association (CRWA), Mystic River Watershed Association (MyRWA), and Save the Alewife Brook (StAB), we are reaching out to you and your respective agencies to highlight several important issues and opportunities as we move into the next phase of CSO control planning. We would welcome an opportunity to meet with you to discuss these topics in more detail. Briefly summarized:
Despite decades of investment in CSO-reduction projects, MWRA’s CSO discharges are still violating the limits set in the LTCP at more than a dozen outfalls, prompting MWRA to seek a three-year extension (until 2024) to achieve compliance with the court-mandated LTCP. The current LTCP must be fully implemented as close to schedule as possible such that all CSO locations meet or do better than the agreed-upon limits—anything less is unacceptable. MWRA must employ all possible tools at their disposal, including green infrastructure measures, to achieve compliance with the LTCP.
Because the LTCP does not consider increased precipitation caused by climate change or environmental justice, even if MWRA were in compliance with the existing LTCP—which it is not—it would not be a sustainable solution to CSOs. The effects of climate change and environmental justice considerations must be incorporated into future requirements.
As MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville begin the next phase of CSO control planning required by the Water Quality Standards variances, it is critical to incorporate robust public participation early and often in that process, including as the scopes of the plans are developed.
We expect the next phase of CSO planning to focus on eliminating CSO discharges into the Charles and Mystic Rivers and Alewife Brook—anything short of complete elimination prolongs the public health risks and environmental harm caused by CSOs.
CRWA and MyRWA both have long, successful histories of partnering with MWRA, EPA, and DEP to improve water quality and habitat conditions in our respective rivers, a task that is becoming increasingly urgent as our climate changes. The emergence of Save the Alewife Brook in the past year, as well as the increased focus on CSOs by residents and community groups throughout the Boston area, is clear evidence that many members of the public share these concerns and are similarly invested in the development of concrete plans to effectively eliminate the remaining CSOs as expeditiously as possible.
The Water Quality Standards variances for CSO discharges in the Lower Charles River/Charles Basin and Alewife Brook/Upper Mystic River require that MWRA and the cities of Cambridge and Somerville begin the next phase of CSO control planning. The first step is the submission of scopes and schedules for updated CSO control planning, which are due by April 1, 2022.
Concerns with the end of the LTCP/Post Construction Assessment phase
Much of the work required under the 1997 LTCP, as revised in 2006, has been completed and the success and failure of those measures has now been assessed. Substantial investment by MWRA and the cities of Boston, Cambridge, and Somerville has led to significant progress in reducing CSO activations and volumes. However, sixteen CSOs are violating LTCP limits under “Typical Year” conditions. An additional six CSOs are also violating their respective activation or volume limits, but MWRA states that the difference between actual performance and LTCP limits at those sites should be considered “immaterial.” Further, actual discharges in 2021, as compared to MWRA’s model, significantly violated the LTCP limits for many CSOs. There is clearly much work yet to be done under the existing LTCP, even before increased precipitation and environmental justice are taken into account.
It is disheartening, if not unexpected, to get to the end of the Post Construction Assessment phase with 22 outfalls still not meeting the LTCP goals. In requesting a three-year extension (until the end of 2024) to comply with its obligations under the LTCP, MWRA informed federal district court judge Richard G. Stearns that they believe they have solutions that can be implemented by the end of 2024 at six of the non-compliant outfalls (BOS003, BOS009, BOS014, CHE008, MWR205, and SOM007A/MWR205A). Of the remaining outfalls, MWRA, coordinating with the Boston Water and Sewer Commission, reports having conceptual ideas at four outfalls (BOS017, BOS062, BOS095 and BOS070/DBC) that they believe will bring the outfalls into compliance with the LTCP if they can be successfully implemented. There are six outfalls for which MWRA, Cambridge, or Somerville do not currently have a solution (CAM005, MWR201 [Cottage Farm], MWR018, MWR019, MWR020 and SOM001A) for achieving compliance with the LTCP. These six outfalls are all within the variance waters. Finally, there are six outfalls that are close to achieving compliance—they have not actually achieved compliance—for which MWRA deems exceedances to be “immaterial.”
CRWA and MyRWA have communicated to the court our position that MWRA must achieve full compliance with the LTCP by the extended deadline of 2024 and that as part of its compliance obligation, MWRA must conduct a thorough analysis of the role green infrastructure and real-time monitoring can play in achieving LTCP requirements and maintaining those requirements as our climate changes.
“Typical Year” vs. Reality
The current LTCP modeling and limits were based on the use of a typical precipitation year, consistent with EPA and DEP LTCP guidance. While that has been standard practice in the past, the reality is that our climate is changing and actual discharges are more frequently and regularly exceeding modeled control limits, and this trend will continue. The difference between actual activations and discharges in 2021 and LTCP limits requires a more detailed examination.
For example, the cumulative LTCP limits for the six remaining outfalls in the Alewife Brook were 29 activations and 7.29 million gallons discharged. Five of the six outfalls were predicted to meet the LTCP limits under typical year conditions. However, under actual 2021 conditions, there were 45 activations and 50 million gallons discharged. Only two outfalls in the Alewife actually met the LTCP activation limits in 2021. And while 2021 did bring a significant amount of rainfall, LTCP limits were also exceeded in 2018 and 2019. In fact, looking at actual conditions in the past four years, it was only in the drought year of 2020 that LTCP limits were met. Clearly the typical year model no longer reflects actual conditions.
Similarly, in the Charles River, in 2019, based on MWRA’s metering, the following sites had more overflow occurrence than what is allowed under the LTCP: CAM017, MWR018, MWR201 Cottage Farm, MWR023, CAM005, and CAM007. CAM007 and MWR023, both of which MWRA considers to be achieving the LTCP, had 1 and at least 3 more overflows than their respective LTCP limits. These differences were far more extreme in 2021; every CSO location on the Charles River, other than MWR010, exceeded LTCP limits. CAM005 had 9 reported overflows with a volume of 3.2 MG, compared to LTCP limits of 3 overflows and 0.84 MG. At Cottage Farm, there were 5 overflows with a total volume of 88 MG compared to LTCP limits of 2 overflows and 6.3 MG. Even locations that MWRA considers to be in compliance with the LTCP violated the limits: CAM007 had 4 activations and 1.4 MG of overflow compared to the limit of 1 overflow and a volume of 0.03 MG, while CAM017 have 5 overflows with a volume of 13.6 MG compared to limits of 1 overflow and 0.45 MG.
Given the significant differences between typical year expectations and actual conditions, we expect the EPA and DEP to ensure that MWRA’s next annual report, due in April of this year, provides the agencies and the interested public with the type of analysis of actual precipitation compared to the typical year that was included in the prior semi-annual progress reports. The agencies should also ensure that MWRA provides meter data scattergraphs and results of simulations of the most current hydraulic system model (Q4 2021) under actual 2021 precipitation conditions.
Accounting for the Impacts of Climate Change
The 2021 experience must also inform the CSO control planning process going forward. Whereas EPA’s 1999 CSO Guidance for Monitoring and Modeling is premised on a review of the historical precipitation record, the climate in Massachusetts, and specifically precipitation patterns, has changed significantly in the intervening years and is forecast to continue to do so. What may have been viewed as a static climate system in guidance from the 1990s is now clearly a dynamic one.
At a minimum, we expect EPA and DEP to require updated calculations for the typical year that account for current and projected climate impacts. It is no longer adequate to rely solely on a historical analysis of precipitation in planning for the future. We also question whether the typical year approach adequately captures the true impacts of climate change. In looking at the rainfall and CSO discharge data for the previous seven years, we observed that the magnitudes of the discharges in years in which rainfall was above average greatly exceeded the typical year value.
In January, NOAA released a paper titled “Analysis of Nonstationary Climate on NOAA Atlas 14 Estimates” (National Weather Service, Office of Water Prediction, Jan. 31, 2022), which stated that historical assumptions about the magnitude and frequency of extreme future events are not appropriate in the presence of nonstationary climate. Considering that many climate models indicate that the increasing trend in intensity and frequency of precipitation will likely continue in the future, using only statistics from the past observations could underestimate the precipitation frequency quantiles as well as their confidence limits, which could result in undersized civil engineering water resource infrastructure. (p. 6)
Results of some of the modeling in the NOAA report indicate that overall, the Northeast regional average 2-year 1-day estimates show an increase of between 5% and 22% by the end of the century, while the 100-year 1-day estimates show an increase of between 7% and 30%. (p. 22) EPA and DEP must provide updated guidance to MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville on considering likely future climate scenarios in their CSO planning simulations.
Environmental Justice Considerations
Since the 1990s—when EPA and DEP last released guidance on CSO control planning—consideration of Environmental Justice has emerged as one of the most important aspects of decision-making on a wide range of environmental issues. Going forward, CSO control planning must take Environmental Justice into account.
Most of the neighborhoods abutting the Alewife Brook, and the Lower Charles and Mystic Rivers are Environmental Justice neighborhoods according to the Massachusetts 2020 Environmental Justice Population maps published by the Massachusetts Executive Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs. In significant storms, the Alewife Brook has historically flooded Environmental Justice neighborhoods in Arlington, resulting in flood waters containing CSO discharges entering the homes of residents. The areas of Boston and Cambridge immediately downstream of the Cottage Farm discharge are also Environmental Justice neighborhoods and this section of the Charles—which is readily accessible by public transit—is used by many residents, including children, accessing the river through the multiple free or low-cost boating programs such as Community Boating. Environmental Justice is an important consideration in people’s ability to safely recreate in and along our rivers downstream of CSO discharges and must be factored into future CSO control planning.
Expectations Regarding Public Engagement
With respect to updated CSO control planning, we appreciate that the variances require a public participation plan, including ample opportunities for the public to be informed of plan development at critical junctures and opportunities for the public to provide informed comments on the CSO abatement alternatives and recommendations. At the outset, we request that EPA and DEP provide a similar opportunity for the public to offer comments on the proposed scopes and schedules that will chart the course for updated CSO control planning. This will help instill the public confidence and buy-in to the process that is necessary to ensure robust public participation moving forward. To that end, we would welcome a public workshop facilitated by EPA and DEP where MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville describe their proposed scopes and schedules and answer questions and receive feedback from interested parties. A robust public process is also critical to the Environmental Justice considerations described above.
We appreciate your consideration of these comments, recommendations, and requests, and look forward to working with you towards finally eliminating CSOs in the Charles and Mystic Rivers and Alewife Brook. As noted, we would welcome the opportunity to meet with you in the near future to discuss these issues in greater detail.
Sincerely,
Emily Norton, Executive Director Charles River Watershed Association
Patrick Herron, Executive Director Mystic River Watershed Association
Kristin Anderson David White Save the Alewife Brook
cc: Frederick Laskey, Executive Director, MWRA Secretary Kathleen Theoharides, Executive Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs Mayor Sumbul Siddiqui, City of Cambridge Mayor Katjana Ballantyne, City of Somerville Mayor Michelle Wu, City of Boston
At the March 4th, 2022 Massachusetts Water Resources Authority’s (MWRA) Wastewater Advisory Committee meeting, core activists from Save the Alewife Brook learned something awful about Belmont’s sewage.
In 2015, the MWRA reconstructed a Combined Sewer Outfall (CSO) known as MWR003 in the Little River/Alewife Brook. They did this as part of the 2006 Long Term Control Plan that closed the CAM004 CSO. However last year, MWR003 dumped 20 million gallons of sewage pollution into the Little River / Alewife Brook (although their model predicted 1 million for a typical year). The project also cost the MWRA rate payers $3.7 million.
The MWRA tied sewer trunks from Cambridge and Belmont into this CSO to provide “hydraulic relief” for their failing and over-capacitated system downstream. So now, when the MWRA’s Alewife sewage system is inundated with rain, Cambridge’s and Belmont’s sewage gets dumped into the Little River / Alewife Brook.
We think that as part of the original Long Term CSO Control Plan, this “solution” to the CSO problem was not much of a solution at all. The MWRA has basically shifted the problem around and not fixed the systemic problem of their failing sewage system throughout the Alewife.
Please join us on Sunday March 13th at 7 pm for Save the Alewife Brook’s March Community Meeting!
We’ll discuss the looming April 1st deadline, when Cambridge, Somerville, and the MWRA are required to submit the initial scope of their new Long Term CSO (Combined Sewer Overflows) Control Plan for the Alewife. We have an opportunity now to promote our vision for a safer and more beautiful Alewife Brook.
At the Final CSO Report meeting on February 17th, MWRA’s Executive Director Fred Laskey promised us, “We’ll give you whatever you want!” So let’s meet to discuss how we can hold the MWRA to their promise.
“We’ll give you whatever you want!”
– fred Laskey, Executive Director of the massachusetts water resources authority
Our Vision for the Alewife…
A Safe, Beautiful, Fishable Brook for the Residents and for Wildlife
Separated Sewer Systems to keep Sewage out of Stormwater
Elimination of all Alewife CSOs to End Sewage Pollution
New Green Infrastructure to Clean the Stormwater
An Additional Alewife Pumping Station Near Little River
New Grey Infrastructure to Reduce Flooding in the Face of Climate Change
Save the Alewife Brook is an environmentalist group that is trying to eliminate sewage pollution and flooding in a little brook on the border of Arlington, Cambridge, and Somerville.
The brook is named after the herring that used to live there. There used to be so many herring living in this brook, that the Menotomy Indians lived right next it, at the confluence of the Mystic River.
In the 1800s, colonial settlers started piping their poop and industrial waste into the brook and the rain water and tides carried it away to the Boston Harbor. Unfortunately, the cities of Somerville and Cambridge haven’t stopped doing this. Yes, we now have a water treatment plant. But, if we get an inch of rain, the poop and industrial wastewater goes into the Alewife Brook.
The fish can no longer survive in this brook. And we get flooding in this part of town. The people who live near that brook get the sewage in their homes during big flood events.
Very few people know that this is happening because the story was green-washed by corporations and consultants in 2015.
But it IS still happening and it’s getting exponentially worse because of Climate Change.
We want to alert people to this problem in a funny and light-hearted way. We don’t want them to feel guilty about it or feel like they’re being attacked. We want to launch a kind of a silly and WTH-sort of campaign with cartoon characters, posted on flyers and various swag.
The campaign slogan would simply be:
“Please don’t flush when it rains.”
And then there would be some combination of creative characters involved: a happy and helpful and not-so-smart toilet character a round herring alewife fish character a hooded merganser duck character a wise great blue heron character a cheerful and sweet rain drop character
The campaign will be humorous.
We want people to see the flyers and wonder, “what the hell?” and then have them go to our website for more info. Folks legit don’t know that this is happening.
We’d love to find a local artist who can do this work, someone from Arlington, Cambridge, Somerville, Belmont, Medford, or nearby. And we need it done quickly because we’re up against a fast-moving regulatory timeline with the EPA and MassDEP.
If you know an artist who can draw funny-looking characters, please have them email links to their artwork.
On February 17 2022 the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority (MWRA) hosted a public briefing to discuss their Final combined sewer overflow (CSO) Performance Assessment Report. This was based on their four-year CSO assessment, which looked at their system’s CSO performance from 2018 to 2021. This briefing was a requirement of the Federal Boston Harbor Clean-up court case.
There were 90 people logged in to this virtual meeting and almost all of them were community members who were interested in the Alewife Brook CSOs. The briefing began with PowerPoint presentation, where the MWRA gave an overview of their CSO program work and the results to date.
THE BIGGEST BOMBSHELLS?
Somerville’s Alewife CSO is out of compliance.
The MWRA has determined that Somerville’s Alewife CSO is not in regulatory compliance. This means that Somerville has failed even to live up to the terms and requirements of their permit to pollute the Alewife Brook. They are discharging far too much sewage and too frequently!
Based on the MWRA’s modeling results using a “Typical Year” approach, the model shows that Somerville’s CSO (SOM001A) is discharging 4.47 million gallons of sewage water compared to the regulatory goal of 1.67 million gallons. Note that the actual measured discharges for Somerville’s Alewife CSO were 18 million gallons of sewage water in 2021.
Somerville needs to separate their combined sewer system in Davis Square, eliminate that terrible CSO, and add green and grey infrastructure to clean their stormwater and reduce flooding. This work can be done on state DCR land all along the Alewife, including at Dilboy Park.
The MWRA cannot currently meet the area’s sewer needs when we have big rainstorms.
After the MWRA’s PowerPoint presentation, the public was allowed to ask questions and make comments. Arlington Town Meeting Member Patricia Worden said that she used to be a Cambridge resident and that she believes Cambridge can afford to close their Alewife CSOs. Worden also asked whether the sewer system can handle more sewer hookups required by future development. Then Gwen Speeth from North Cambridge asked the MWRA why they don’t take care of their own Alewife Brook CSO, MWR003. Speeth pointed out that the MWRA’s Alewife CSO discharged over 20 million gallons of sewage water in 2021.
In response, a consultant spokesperson for the MWRA, Don Walker from AECOM replied, “The MWRA system is limited by downstream capacity. Under very large storm events, the capacity of the Alewife Brook Pump Station, which is downstream of [MWR003] is reaching capacity – very large facility, has 90 MGD capacity. That then discharges into sewers that are conveying flow further downstream and going to the Chelsea Creek Headworks, that then reaches capacity. And there are events when the capacity of our Deer Island treatment plant, 1.2 / 1.3 billion gallons per day is reached. So there are limits to what the MWRA can push through the system.”
What Mr. Walker is stating here is that the MWRA’s sewer system through the Alewife is not capable of handling the area’s current needs during some rain storms. This is because stormwater in the combined systems is overloading the MWRA sanitary sewer system.
We note that separating the combined sewer systems will greatly reduce stormwater flow into the MWRA system and thus address the capacity issue.
What does this mean for the future? What is the solution?
Climate Change projections and current data indicates that if the CSOs are not closed, the sewage pollution problem will snowball, and become exponentially worse. Therefore, the combined sewer systems which mix sanitary sewage (what you flush) with street water in West Somerville and North Cambridge must be separated. They must stop sending their street water (AKA stormwater) to the Deer Island sewage treatment facility. This will reduce the overloaded capacity on the system. And the MWRA’s Alewife CSO, which dumped 20 million gallons of sewage water in the Alewife Brook in 2021, must be replaced with a pumping station.
Thank you, Alewife Supporters!
Save the Alewife Brook would like to thank all of the supporters who attended the MWRA’s Final CSO report briefing, including: Adam Chapdelaine, Amy Schofield, Barbara Moran, Ben Beck, Beth Kudaruskas, Beth Melofchik, Betsy Davis, Carolyn Francisco-Murphy, Carolyn M Fiore, Charlie Jewell, Chris Goodwin, Christian Klein, Clare Nosowitz, Dan Codiga, David Wu, Denise Ellis-Hibbett, Don Seltzer, Douglas Heim, Eugene Benson, Eric Helmuth, Eva Murray, Fang Yu, Gwen Speeth, Jane Carey, Jean Devine, Jianjun Wang, Jill Carr, Jim Barsati, Jimmy Johnson, John Reinhardt, John Salo, John Tortelli, Julia Hopkins, Kane Larin, Karen Graham, Kelly Morton, Lealdon Langley, Leon Cantor, Lucner Charlestra, Maret Smolow, Mary Adelstein, Mary Kay, Michael Fager, Michele Barden, Michele Gillen, Mike Altieri, Minka vanBeuzedom, Nancy Bloom, Pallavi Mande, Pam Heidell, Patricia Worden, Patrick Herron, Peg McAdam, Rachel Roth, Rich Raiche, Sally Carroll, Shavaun Callahan, Stephen Perkins, Steve Cullen, Susan Stamps, Susy King, Todd Borci, Tricia Carney, Wynelle Evens, Yuyou Chen.